Cactus killer said:
well if you have long arms you can get a little more down travel but less up, if you look at the top side of the long arm you will see where the arm hits the frame. with stock length arms this cannot happen. I have a 7" lift and 37" tires with stock arms and uncut front finders, I can get to the top of most ramps just fine. Once you cut your frame it is too late and to bad, IF you ever change your mind. The reason I will be buying a set of the BC arms is for strength over stock (I actually bent one into a u),the adjustability,I don't have to cut anything and I have seen a set in person. + they are made in America ( I am not sure but I would guess the Duff arms are cast in Canada)Far superior to any thing available. when you see a set you will understand.
Your way off base.
1: You gain travel both directions and it is more than just a little.
2: The Cage long arms do not hit the frame nor do any of the long arms setups I have ever seen.
3: (Assuming you don't have a wristed axle housing) If you are getting to the top of ramps with that setup then they are either very short ramps or your not stopping when one of the tires comes off the ground. The maximum distance up a ramp you can get with stock arms is in the range of 31 to 33 inches. (Rubber bushings and soft springs) Typically it is more like 27". Compare that to 48" or so which is what long arms can generally get close to with a soft set of springs. (I'm also assuming the rear suspension has nothing more than a soft set of springs)
4: All that would be required to go back to a stock set of arms would be to weld new mounts back into the stock location. So far I don't know anyone that has ever been sorry that they went with long arms over the stock ones though.
5: If you bend a set of Cage arms then you have done something pretty serious. They are made from 2" x .313" tubing. I'm sure the BC Arms are strong as well but the cost is extra unsprung weight in the frontend. (I've heard they are pretty heavy)
6: I'm not certain whether Jim builds the Cage arms in his shop in Oregon or farms them out to someone else nor do I know where Duff's has them done. They are both Jim's design though. The only cast parts are the ends for the C-Bushings.
7: Regardless of where Jim has the arms made it is a certainty that they are a quality product. If they were not then he wouldn't be selling them.
8: Where did you get the idea that Canadians can't build a great product? I'm sure TOFIC and a few other Canadian members here would take offense to that.