My reason for getting a larger one was that I kept wearing out bearings on the smaller ones. They never failed to charge, but often made lots of rattling noises as the bearings wore out.
In hindsight it was probably just cheap parts. After the original one went out (I think it was a 55, but will have to look at my Marti to see if that's correct) I would put in just the regular 29.95 rebuilt ones from Kragen. They had always lived long on our other cars, but only lasted 1-2 years on my Bronco. Maybe cheap, or used parts, but I know I was never one to over-tighten the belts.
Went with the big case 1G 70a model too, and never had to replace another alternator. Ended up putting it on a friend's Bronco which I think ended up on member MtFit's Red Buggy. Probably still working for all I know!
It was a great bonus that the idle power was much greater and no more low speed dimming.
Have the 100a version on the pickup and it's got the larger pulley so no squealing either. Maybe the shorter run of charge wire helps too? Goes straight to the battery rather than around the truck for the ammeter.
Either way you go, whether you really need more power or not, it's not a downgrade to go bigger when you're no longer stock anyway.
Paul