...Have any of you seen a specific flaw?
The only "flaw" that gets the most discussion that I can remember is the more complicated wiring as most see it. While it's not that big of a deal for anyone with some moderate wiring understanding and patience, many look at it and cringe. And when you add multiple choices of modules and connector layout to the mix, the cringes get deeper and more mind-numbing.
To the point that they just go with the supposedly simpler fixes of things like Ignitors, all the "ready to run" stuff out there, and even HEI distributors. The number of people using HEI's in fact, kind of bears out my assumption that the only real fault anyone finds with Durasparks are the wiring.
When doing a conversion from points, a Duraspark is really the only one that requires you source/build a separate ignition harness to control the distributor and separate module and ignition coil. This alone is enough to sway some in the direction of one of the other choices.
Yes, there were some here over the many years that did have some module failures. For whatever reason, they had a few burned out Duraspark boxes. I even had three failures, but I concluded that it was the cheap $18 knockoffs I was buying. Bought two different types for about 100 bucks each and never had an issue after that. Those two are still good and up for sale in fact. Probably why finding an OE original in the junkyard is not such a bad solution.
Funny though, that in all the discussions of "what's better" nobody seems to remember the legions of complaining GM vehicle owners in the '70's and '80's that could not keep a GM HEI alive very long either. But things change...
Even savage here started the discussion, if I remember correctly, because there were different wiring configurations, his had been modified anyway, and which way to go to keep it Duraspark. Or something to that effect. So even here that aspect did cause some drama. But in his case at least he's sticking with the Duraspark.
I always grin when I see some aftermarket setup, such as an MSD or Mallory distributor, that is utilizing the magnetic trigger design from the Duraspark distributors in their versions. Whether controlled by an internal or external module, the pickup and stator/reluctor(?) are the Ford design.
That part at least must be well thought of in some minds then.
Paul