Who makes the Mickey T's? My understanding is that some of their tires are made domestically by Cooper Tire, some are made elsewhere out of country. If you look at the manufacturing code on the side, something like "3D6V MBD 2006", the "3D" would be indicative of a domestically made Cooper Tire if I'm not mistaken...not that we can't make out of round tires here in the US, Interco has been for years.
Between the Toyo and Nitto though, I'd go Toyo M/T assuming mud tires given your 50/50 use. I don't have any experience with their all-terrain options other that what I see on other rigs. My rig is getting BFG KM2's, although the Toyo M/T and MTR Kevlar were definitely in the running, I just got a better deal on the BFG's.