I have the Cross bumper and tire carrier (Trail Mate 1) and like it a lot. The tire does sit up high and is centered, not offset. My only dislike is the carrier doesn't sit on top of the bumper like other designs. This isn't so much of a functional issue as it is about looks - although I suppose that because the carrier is mounted on the face of the bumper, not on top - it could get hung up, but that's improbable. My bumper is 1/4" and I was pleased with the fit and finish and would recommend it. Here is a pic: