I did mine the other day, had a similar experience as previous post. First one was a bit loose. I was was more careful in my drilling on the next hinge and that one came out great. My advice is have a good vise and drill press and make sure your centered when drilling out the old pins/ bushings. I wound up drilling out the old pins bc I could not get them to budge using a sledge and drift. In the end the door closes perfect, even with the slightly loose one I did.