The vacuum units, if not maintained do not work well. Their movement slows when climbing a hill. The units stop a lot in cold climates because they rely on a fluid lubrication to move and seal. With that all said. If you get small amounts of rain and want to stay stock, the vacuum units can be adequate. The electric units are superior and reliable. If you have the cash, and need more creature comforts, go electric. I like the weird old style units and to keep my 66 broncos stock, so I am intresred in the vacuum units that are in repairable condition. Bob