My preference is on the column. Just rebuilt a column in a '67 and it is amazing how much nicer it is now, I have never drove a 3 on the tree off the showroom floor so I have no comparison as to that BUT in my opinion, this is the smoothest shifting I have seen or had out of a 3 speed. I am not a fan of the 3 on the floor conversion due to how intrusive they are. That being said, I have 2 original Hurst shifters and tunnel covers I was going to take to SC to sell but if you want them, let me know. One is missing the knob but both in general are in decent shape. One came out of a bronco we are switching to a NV3550 and the other came out of a '67 that we rebuilt the column on to go back to original.