After some research and looking at many pictures online -heck, I was taking photos into photoshop, inverting colors and counting holes and looking at placement. Seems there are a couple of different sized flares (regular and larger) and a couple different hole patterns. My pattern has holes above and below the rear lower body lines; the other pattern has a hole between the two lines.
This post also helped me... (the second post by DirtDonk)
http://www.broncofix.com/viewtopic.php?t=275340
My old ones were plastic and measured about 45" at the outside bottom (small/regular size).
I did not take his advise and "GO BIG" but I started looking at the Bushwackers.
Broncohut has a good picture online of the Bushwackers and the pattern looked promising.
Ordered a set and... purfect fit in the same holes ;D
These will come back off this weekend for painting.
One small negative, these have a textured finish. Oh well.