• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

financing an EB

Whoaa

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 26, 2014
Messages
1,059
So here is a hypothetical situation, and only the OP knows if it would work for him. Suppose a home equity loan would be 4%. After taxes it might actually cost 3% or less. You could buy the perfect Bronco now for 20k but instead you start saving. Three years later you have 20k cash. Guess what? That 20k Bronco is now going to cost you 25k.

If you had financed it, it would still be worth 25k, you would have only spent about 22k, so you would be 3k ahead, the Bronco would be paid off., and you would have enjoyed it for 3 years..... But since you decided to save and pay cash, you now need 25k to buy it, you only have 20k, so you keep looking and saving......and Broncos keep appreciating and getting harder to find.....

^...I agree that this investment strategy is fundamentally correct. We all love to make money using someone else's money, and its even better while minimizing our personal risk and exposure :)

I have few issues that include:

1) There is such a small margin, a small margin for error and a small margin for profit/increased value.
I won't spend more than 10 minutes of my time for less than 7 or 8 percent on a "secure" investment. I need well over 20% potential rate of return on higher risk deals.

2) A 40 year old classic car doesn't make a good year-around daily driver, and especially when it's your only wheels.

3) The geographic location of being located in the Salt Belt region has a severely negative influence on the whole deal.

4) There is conflicting information from the OP in regards to having a house "paid for", but paying interest on a car loan....this doesn't make sense and raises a red flag to me -maybe we're not getting full and complete info to base our opinions on?

If I had to drive 10-15K+ miles a year to/from work, in the Salt Belt region, I'd buy a new car every 4-5 years and have it setup on an advanced depreciation schedule. (some factory incentive programs offer 0% interest for 5 years, plus used cars keep most of their value if less than 7 years old and under 100k miles)
Today I would buy a $30k car, drive it for about 5 years w/o doing ANY maintenance to it besides oil changes, sell it for about $18-20k -rinse and repeat. The cost of ownership (plus operating cost/insurance/registration), $10k / 60 months = $166-$200 +/- per month.

Then I'd use the money I saved by my reduced cost of my daily driver to spend on a play toy that I'd only drive on nice summer days!
 

Slowleak

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
4,013
Loc.
Georgia
You are right on track Whoaa. The strategy works but only under the right conditions.

I pay cash for a used daily driver, usually an off lease well maintained 30k vehicle which will last me 10-12 years with proper maintenance. The money I save pays for my toys. I hate vehicles that depreciate......and I would never buy an EB as my only driver.

BTW - If you are finding 7 to 8 percent secure investments these days you are doing well.
 

Juiceman

Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2014
Messages
367
I live in this world everyday. Finance heavy equipment, but "grew up" financing high end cars and bikes (Corvettes, Ferraris, MB, Harleys). All good advice coming from other members. I agree with not financing toys - even though I made a good living doing it. Have seen too many deals go bad. No 0% financing in used cars (no manufacturer incentives) is out there. I drive an F150 as my daily driver and have a 77 as my "toy". If I only drove 15 miles a day, I could see making a Bronco an every day driver, but anymore just can't see it. And we have similar winters to you as well. Good luck with whatever decision you make. Should you decide to make a Bronco your daily driver, you might want to consider something like a Honda Civic for a couple grand as a back up.
 

roundhouse

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 5, 2003
Messages
2,956
Thats true, but there is a difference.......The typical vehicle you by at a dealership starts depreciating as soon as you buy it. You are instantly losing money on both the interest and the vehicle.

If you finance a vehicle that is appreciating in value it can easily offset the cost of the financing. If you wait a few years to buy while saving up cash, you will be paying more anyway. You are just letting someone else benefit from the appreciation while you save up to buy it....

So here is a hypothetical situation, and only the OP knows if it would work for him. Suppose a home equity loan would be 4%. After taxes it might actually cost 3% or less. You could buy the perfect Bronco now for 20k but instead you start saving. Three years later you have 20k cash. Guess what? That 20k Bronco is now going to cost you 25k.

If you had financed it, it would still be worth 25k, you would have only spent about 22k, so you would be 3k ahead, the Bronco would be paid off., and you would have enjoyed it for 3 years..... But since you decided to save and pay cash, you now need 25k to buy it, you only have 20k, so you keep looking and saving......and Broncos keep appreciating and getting harder to find.....

thats if nothing goes wrong, no layoff, no illness, no medical bills,
no economic collapse if Hillary gets elected.....

borrowing money for anything other than real estate (at a 15 year loan NOT a 30 year loan,) is always always always a mistake.

even a loan for a new car, is always a bad idea.
 

roundhouse

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 5, 2003
Messages
2,956
still a bad idea to finance a car, toy or daily driver, even at 0%


I get my cars about 6-8 years old at a repo auction or the scratch & dent auction where the ins co's sell the damaged cars.

drive em till the wheels fall off and get another one.
last one was 7 yrs old,excellent condition, some schumck paid $52K for it new , I paid $6K,
already put 90K on it, with $300 or so in repairs, and $700 in consumables, brakes, spark plugs, coil packs (its a ford, so lots of coil packs) weve put more miles on it than the original owner did for 90% less $$$$

the one before that was 6 years old, $32K new we paid $6K, spent $2K in repairs,
put 200K on it, with zero repairs, sold it with 320K on the clock, for $2,000..
cost us $6K in depreciation for 200K miles

best one I ever had: bought a 10 yr old Toyota with 120K on it for $1200
engine blew at 300K, replaced it with $500 junkyard engine , it blew at 420K
replaced it with $750 junkyard engine.

got wrecked at 499K, sold it for $700

380K miles for less than $3K


few years ago we bought a 86 garage kept mazda with 90K miles from the origional owner, with ice cold AC.
for $200, spent $300 for tires, battery, & waterpump, put almost 50K on it, sold it for $1000

if I lived in the rust belt, Id make a trip to AZ or rural GA and get a cheap reliable car , take it back and drive it to death.
 

Slowleak

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
4,013
Loc.
Georgia
thats if nothing goes wrong, no layoff, no illness, no medical bills,

no economic collapse if Hillary gets elected.....



borrowing money for anything other than real estate (at a 15 year loan NOT a 30 year loan,) is always always always a mistake.



even a loan for a new car, is always a bad idea.


I would never buy or finance a new car so i agree with that part. However, most businesses would never get started without borrowed funds and most real estate would never sell. A tangible appreciating asset like a collectible vehicle is really no different than real estate as an investment. Its just on a smaller scale and much easier to dispose of.

We are basically debating toys vs. investments and I agree that financing a toy is not a good idea. Financing an investment can be but there are too many variables involved to say it is always a mistake.
 

EricLar80

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 14, 2001
Messages
2,170
How can it possibly be a bad idea to finance something at 0%? I don't get it.....

It really isn't if you can truly afford it. If you can finance something at an honest 0%, then you can put that lump of money into a high-yield savings account (currently 0.75-1.0% ) and make payments while collecting a small amount of interest. There is also something to be said for keeping the money in your pocket vs handing it over on day one - you have a lot more financial flexibility if something were to come up.

That being said, you usually have to pay at least some fees with a 0% loan on a new car purchase. You would not be able to find something like that for a Bronco.

But, it is generally not wise to finance a toy that you don't have the cash for to begin with because you are on the hook to pay it off. Make sure you have good insurance. I knew a guy who had a street bike stolen and he only had liability insurance - the financing company accelerated the loan when they heard it was stolen, meaning that he had to pay it off in cash that month.

Eric
 

norm02

Full Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2016
Messages
336
I agree with the "don't finance toys" group. It's a bad idea and so is getting an old vehicle for a daily driver. I got sick of daily driving my '77 when I was 16-19 so I have no doubt that you will feel the same as an adult. It sucks, but you're better off paying cash for your toys.
 

Slowleak

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
4,013
Loc.
Georgia
Because: the borrower is slave to the lender .


If you are prepared to pay cash for a vehicle and have the opportunity to finance it for zero cost, you get the benefit, and security, of keeping your cash to earn interest and provide a cushion and you can pay it off anytime you want. That's a nice benefit, its not slavery. Obviously you would not do that if you fall for them just adding the interest into the price.....
 

Seventee

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2012
Messages
999
Loc.
In the sticks of MT
If you are prepared to pay cash for a vehicle and have the opportunity to finance it for zero cost, you get the benefit, and security, of keeping your cash to earn interest and provide a cushion and you can pay it off anytime you want. That's a nice benefit, its not slavery. Obviously you would not do that if you fall for them just adding the interest into the price.....

Even though mathmatically it can work, the problem is not many people actually follow through with this plan. They end up blowing the extra money on other stuff (depreciating toys, furniture, vacations etc.). Then get hit with a bunch of medical bills or a job loss. Suddenly they're in a hole they can't get back out of.

Is the puny percentage rate on secure investments really worth the risk? Everyone has a different security level, but to me not oweing someone money is more important than a percent or two of interest gained.

IMO, the other bad part of financing classics such as this, is making the assumption that it will always appreciate. You can end up upside down in a hurry if the fad ends, or things go south.
 

Slowleak

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
4,013
Loc.
Georgia
I agree.... Like i said, it only works under the right conditions. You can get hit with medical bills, job loss etc, even if you only use cash. The key is to use your common sense, have a cash reserve and/or highly liquid assets, and be disciplined just like with any financial transacations. All of my comments are based on the premise that people are financially responsible and do that. If you are not, then you have no business spending cash on such a vehicle either.

This is getting away from the original topic but my point is that a financially responsible person can finance and enjoy a vehicle without it being a "bad idea". It may not be the perfect investment but it doesn't have to be. Part of my assumption is that you have other investments and are just leveraging equity so your more secure securities remain intact and that you do research and buy right. Then you have a moderate risk investment that you can enjoy rather than a stock certificate......those can go south too.
 
Last edited:

Slowleak

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
4,013
Loc.
Georgia
True, but if your truck is paid for the bank ain't gonna come and get it.


Thats true but suppose, as some people do, you spent all your cash on a truck so you won't have a payment. Then you find yourself without a job. What are you going to pay the mortgage with? If you had financed that truck and left the cash in the bank, you could make payments while you looked for a job or even sell the truck and have the cash and no payments....... Like i said, there are a lot of variables.
 

Seventee

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2012
Messages
999
Loc.
In the sticks of MT
Thats true but suppose, as some people do, you spent all your cash on a truck so you won't have a payment. Then you find yourself without a job. What are you going to pay the mortgage with? If you had financed that truck and left the cash in the bank, you could make payments while you looked for a job or even sell the truck and have the cash and no payments....... Like i said, there are a lot of variables.

Simple...don't spend all your cash on the truck. Save and purchase what is reasonable and affordable. And have an emergency fund to cover your other expenses.
 
Top