good dialog
When shopping for a replacement pump shaft, don't get too excited about larger sizes. The ends have to remain the same size to fit the pump and distributor. If you use too fat a center section all the torsional load is focused on the short end lengths.
Picture the pump shaft as a torsion beam. Under load it should yield uniformly along it's whole length. With that design, it can offer the longest fatigue life.
Also, think of the pump shaft as a fuse. If it does experience an accute failure, it's the least expensive link in the chain.
Am a huge fan of ARP products.