I really want a soft top and Bestop seems to be the top choice out there...
Go for the good deal, of course, but not because Bestop seems to be the top choice now. When your top was made, Bestop wasn't. It was less expensive and easier to get certainly, but most people I knew at the time, liked the Kayline better. Better looking, bigger windows, more color choices, lower profile (part of the better looking part too, I guess), first to offer zip out side windows (just before they closed their doors!) and all that.
Since then, not only has Bestop improved their design (quality was never an issue), both from a looks and function standpoint, but they also became the only game in town for awhile. There are now other choices again of course, like BC Broncos and Wild Horses, but among the soft top manufacturers, Bestop had it all going on. All that money from being Jeeps O.E. supplier didn't hurt things either. Kayline and then STC struggled along, building nice stuff, but never quite getting into the mainstream unfortunately. Good stuff, I thought.
But hey, cheap is cheap. And if it's a good deal by you, it's worth getting. Just for the fun-factor.
Paul