Ok, you are right, a couple of those examples are extreme. (Chevelle is exceedingly rare). Hemmings is not real world though either. I have not seen a $21k bronco in a long time.
My point is that I see Broncos on here in the high $50s and up. There are a few that are nice rigs, but all need something, so far from perfect. That $50-60k number is not far off anecdotally from Shelby's that I have looked at in the past year (68 FB at $58k, 69 FB at $47k etc.).
I would agree however, that a true rust-free survivor original bronco is a rare car. Not because of production numbers, but because so many have been modified, jumped, cut, rusted to pieces etc.
Hagerty uses results from private sales as well as auctions to determine their valuations. There will always be an oddball high or low priced vehicle skewing the average, but I expect it’s a pretty fair comparison. I don’t know of any better source...
Muscle cars in general have depreciated over the last few years while lower priced classics, including Broncos, have appreciated. It doesn’t mean Broncos are overvalued, or that something is wrong with the market. It simply means that the market is changing....
I would happily trade my stock original paint ‘77 Bronco for a stock original paint ‘68 Shelby convertible any day of the week.












