Everything from color to wheels to seats in an EB is personal but I wanted a ton of options. Here's why I didn't go manual VB whether it's "Silver Fox" or maybe somebody else's manual valvbody is three things:
1- you no longer have an auto- ever not an option. Sometimes you need to shift just when both hands are needed whipping the steering wheel around as your sliding around trying to stay out of trouble when hammering the throttle when wheeling. Just happens more than we think. Plus you can sip coffee or eat an ice cream cone when cruising at 20mph in town.
2- with the US shift stand alone controller you have both options with 2 tranny's, the 4r and the 6r. You also get full adjustments of line pressure, shift points, etc, etc, etc and you can do all this with 4 different tunes available with the twist of a knob when moving or sitting.
3- manual valve body you have to roll thru the gears when approaching a stop (no problem) but when shifting from 4 low to 4 high lets say and you are moving because you need to keep your momentum you have to go from low range 4x4 from 3rd gear to 2nd to 1st to neutral then shift into high range then go back to 2nd then to third- you've already lost your momentum. You could also go from low range 4x4 to neutral but you can't just go from 3rd to neutral without hitting 2nd then 1st THEN neutral then shift the tcase then back to 1st and 2nd and since you've lost momentum you have to start all over again. Whereas with the P, R, N, D, 2 shift pattern you can just pop the trans into N, then t-case into 4hi (all in about 1-2sec w/o losing much speed), hit the gas and the trans will shift down to 1st or whatever gear it needs quicker than you can and your not stuck.
They way we snow wheel we go thru all this several times a day depending on the snow. Or after an obstacle on a trail and you can just keep moving instead of having to come to a complete stop. Not an issue if wheeling with a group as you end up waiting anyway but snow is different.
Those can be huge benefits with the stand alone controller