• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Lost Front passenger wheel while towing

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
No matter how tight you though they were they were obviously not tight enough. and probably not retorqued after 100 miles(well we know they werent you didnt make it that far). Along with previous loose lug nuts well the wheels were probably toast at that point. Another thing about aluminum is it expands and contracts quite a bit. say they wheels where installed on a hot day lugs are tight overnight the wheels cooled down and the lugs are a little loose take off on a run and they loosen more and damage/loss occurs.
 

Action

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
579
Drum brakes

OK my mistake-I wasn't look at the drum brakes-Studs look right but very loose? How is the balance on the wheels? I once lost a wheel after playing the mud it was so out of balance-Just a thought.
Jack
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
Some good basic info here

http://www.bargaincarrims.com/acorn-lug-nuts.php


http://www.stu-offroad.com/axle/hubconv/hub-6.htm

hubconv-26a.jpg


8202BK-2.jpg

Nice web sites but none of this applies to my application. If I did have "shouldered" lugs, the shoulder wall would be so thin as to not be and good. Hole thru the wheel is .625 in diameter. Stud is .500 diameter. That would leave less than an .062 wall on the shoulder........
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
What you are seeing is damaged studs.

I think the wrong lugnuts was the problem. Just because they came with the wheels doesn't mean they are correct. Look at the wheel, is it tapered by manufactuing or tapered because a tapered lugnut was gammed in there?

But the aluminum on the studs and the studs all sloppy in the hub were from it running down the road with loose lug nuts. The wheel flopped around as the nuts fell off. when the last one finally fell off then the wheel was finally allowed to fall off. But until it fell off it just rolled around on the hub and studs beating everything up.

There are millions of cars on the road with all right had lugnuts, There wheels stay on. You don't need left hand lugnuts.

I still think wrong lug nuts. I have seen enough to know what happens and yours has every sign of running down the road with loose nuts. Now why the nuts were loose? You said you lost a couple on that wheel just before this happened, there was something going on.

The older aluminum wheels generally took shouldered lugnuts. I have seen aluminum wheels that took tapered lugnuts but without a steel seat the nuts would pull through the aluminum. I have also seen studs there were not pressed all the way into the hub. The lugnut could be torqued, but after a few hard turns the stud would pull into the hub a little and the nuts would be loose. Try and figure out why a new set of wheel studs needed the lugnuts tightened every few miles? Took it apart again and noticed it. Stuff you learn when young.

The lugnuts you probably need look a lot more like this http://store.mettec.com/product/1050/179

There is a large chamfer on the wheel that matches the taper on the lugs.

I agree about left hand threaded studs, but it was a suggestion, so I threw it out there.

Wheels aren't set-up for shouldered lugs. Studs were seated. I had both sides apart to inspect, clean, and re-pack all the bearings and locking hub parts. Drums were turned on the hubs and inspected by the shop and then me before re-assembly. And I had these wheels on and off many times while preping for the maiden 4x4 trip, which went fine. All wheels were then removed and brakes adjusted.
Your right when you say that "something" was happening. Just can't figure out what.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
why, when the wheels never backed off the previous 2 broncos, did they back off on his? the wheels came off 68ford's bronco, then were on one of my customer's bronco for a few thousand miles. we never had a problem with them, neither did 68ford. those lugs were the ones on those wheels when he bought them from my customer.

Ben's right. The only thing that I can think of is maybe some weird force on the hub while flat towing......
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
Looks like the hub has previous damage. On front drum brakes, the drum and hub are pressed together with the studs, since the drum has been taken out of the equation, you had less holding area. To get to your front brakes, you are supposed to remove the whole hub assemblt.

That's what I did. Took the hub and drum assembly as a unit and had them turned. Drum exploded when it hit the pavement at 50mph when the wheel came off.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
Looks like the hub has previous damage. On front drum brakes, the drum and hub are pressed together with the studs, since the drum has been taken out of the equation, you had less holding area. To get to your front brakes, you are supposed to remove the whole hub assemblt.

Hub didn't have any previous damage.......
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
No matter how tight you though they were they were obviously not tight enough. and probably not retorqued after 100 miles(well we know they werent you didnt make it that far). Along with previous loose lug nuts well the wheels were probably toast at that point. Another thing about aluminum is it expands and contracts quite a bit. say they wheels where installed on a hot day lugs are tight overnight the wheels cooled down and the lugs are a little loose take off on a run and they loosen more and damage/loss occurs.

It was snowing the morning we left camp. Lugs were all tight.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
OK my mistake-I wasn't look at the drum brakes-Studs look right but very loose? How is the balance on the wheels? I once lost a wheel after playing the mud it was so out of balance-Just a thought.
Jack

Studs are very loose, now. They spun in the hub flange until they got ground down enough to put a groove in them. Wheel and tire are gone. You would have to see the section of freeway I got stuck on, but it was two lane transition from 41 to 99 in Fresno. I was 100 feet over railroad tracks. Wheel and tire must have gotten thru the guard rail because it was gone when the tow truck driver went to find it with the CHP.
 

Action

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
579
Hubs

If you need some I have some drum brake hubs-Not sure how far you are from me? That whole Fresno hwy99 is a mess.
Jack
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
Well, I've decided to do the chevy disc conversion.
I'll try and keep accurate records and pictures to post later.
I know it's been done allot of times and there's lots of post, but none are complete.
That's what I'm going to attempt to do. (Wish me luck).......LOL
 

Ranchtruck

Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
768
The only way wheels fall off and studs snap is if the lugnuts weren't tight. Sorry. There's a couple ways they can end up loose. First, not tightening them enough. Or, wheel not seated flat on the hub surface, so the nuts are tight but when the wheel pops into position later, they're loose. Or studs not fully pressed into the hub, so as you drive the stud gets pulled further in, making the nuts loose. Or corrosion on the mating surfaces of the back of the wheel or the face of the hub/drum. The pillow of corrosion will crumble and the dust will leak out, leaving the wheel loose. Magnesium wheels can be real bad for that.

I've had it happen twice on different cars. I even used a torque wrench and set them to 90ftlbs on the first one and 110 on the second one, and the wheels still came loose further down the line. I know they were torqued to spec, so they should have stayed put. It's immensely frustrating. Only way to avoid it it to overtorque the lugs. If it specs 90, do 110, if 110, do 130.

Big burly guys may undertigthen bolts because they're afraid of snapping them off. It's an overcorrection compensating for their strength. Only way to know how tight it is is to use a torque wrench.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
The only way wheels fall off and studs snap is if the lugnuts weren't tight. Sorry. There's a couple ways they can end up loose. First, not tightening them enough. Or, wheel not seated flat on the hub surface, so the nuts are tight but when the wheel pops into position later, they're loose. Or studs not fully pressed into the hub, so as you drive the stud gets pulled further in, making the nuts loose. Or corrosion on the mating surfaces of the back of the wheel or the face of the hub/drum. The pillow of corrosion will crumble and the dust will leak out, leaving the wheel loose. Magnesium wheels can be real bad for that.

I've had it happen twice on different cars. I even used a torque wrench and set them to 90ftlbs on the first one and 110 on the second one, and the wheels still came loose further down the line. I know they were torqued to spec, so they should have stayed put. It's immensely frustrating. Only way to avoid it it to overtorque the lugs. If it specs 90, do 110, if 110, do 130.

Big burly guys may undertigthen bolts because they're afraid of snapping them off. It's an overcorrection compensating for their strength. Only way to know how tight it is is to use a torque wrench.

Sorry, none of the above fits. Possible causes, yes.
Thanks for the suggestions, though.
 

Ranchtruck

Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
768
Then the lug nut fairy stopped by and loosened them just before you left.

You can slam a truck sideways into a curb and it will break the rim or ball joints before the wheel studs will break. There's no force involved in flat towing that will cause wheels to come off.
 

casadejohnson

Bronco Alchemist
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
3,587
I would like to see a closer photo of the lug seat in the wheel. In that photo you have it sure looks like it should take a shank type lug instead of an acorn style.
 

turbotim2

Contributor
____________
Joined
Jun 26, 2003
Messages
2,158
Studs are very loose, now. They spun in the hub flange until they got ground down enough to put a groove in them. Wheel and tire are gone. You would have to see the section of freeway I got stuck on, but it was two lane transition from 41 to 99 in Fresno. I was 100 feet over railroad tracks. Wheel and tire must have gotten thru the guard rail because it was gone when the tow truck driver went to find it with the CHP.

I can't imagine what would cause the studs to actually spin inside the hub flange. I do know that over tightening lug nuts with aluminum wheels can break them right off as the aluminum heats up and expands. It happened on a vehicle of mine after a tire change and the guy used an impact wrench putting the wheels back on. Broke all five lug bolts off and the wheel went flying off turning a corner. It doesn't look like your studs broke off though.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
Then the lug nut fairy stopped by and loosened them just before you left.

You can slam a truck sideways into a curb and it will break the rim or ball joints before the wheel studs will break. There's no force involved in flat towing that will cause wheels to come off.

We call her "Mrs. Secrest" in my house.......LOL
 
Top