• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Lost Front passenger wheel while towing

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
Here's one for the Gurus........
Some history: 68 EB with a 250 ci six, Dana 30 front with stock but freshly rebuilt drum brakes. Refurbished wheel bearings and I went thru the hub parts too.
While flat towing the rig home from a 4x4 run 280 miles from home, I lost the front passenger tire on the freeway. I was approx 35 miles from camp and all 5 lug nuts were tight. The reason I know this is because when I got back to camp after the 4x4 run, 2 lugs were missing and the other 3 were loose. We took a lug off each back tire and put them on the front.
This was not the first 4x4 trip for the vehicle since I bought it. All lugs were tight before leaving home.
The studs look to have spun allot in the flange. The spline of all studs are gone. The stud holes in the flange are wow'd out but yet the stud won't come out. I even tried putting a lug nut on one of the studs and hit it with a small sledge. Nothing.
The lugs didn't strip off. The aluminum on the studs in the pictures is from the wheel.
I've talked to several car guys and even a fellow EB owner. No one can figure it out.
My Dad came up with one idea. Maybe that side needed left hand thread studs like they use to do in the old days.......
Any constructive help?
Thx.
 

Attachments

  • downsized_0629011411.jpg
    downsized_0629011411.jpg
    30.8 KB · Views: 225
  • downsized_0629011411a.jpg
    downsized_0629011411a.jpg
    29.9 KB · Views: 212
  • downsized_0629011412.jpg
    downsized_0629011412.jpg
    22.4 KB · Views: 222
  • downsized_0629011412a.jpg
    downsized_0629011412a.jpg
    19.9 KB · Views: 200

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
Nuts were loose to begin with. That may have caused the threads to become galled with aluminum. When you tightened them back up the nuts were probably seizing in the aluminum galling, making you think they were tight. As you dragged it home the loose wheel beat the lug nuts off and loosened the studs.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
To Viperwolf: Lugs were tight. Wasn't any aluminum on the studs when we put the extra lugs on in camp. And my co-driver tighten all 5 lugs when we put the extra two on. I watched him, they were tight.
To Broncodriver: Lugs came with the wheels and tires when I bought them. All the other wheels are fine.......tires and wheels came off a daily driver. I don't know yet how many miles the guy had on them.
 

broncodriver99

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Messages
4,780
Loc.
Glen Allen, VA
To Viperwolf: Lugs were tight. Wasn't any aluminum on the studs when we put the extra lugs on in camp. And my co-driver tighten all 5 lugs when we put the extra two on. I watched him, they were tight.
To Broncodriver: Lugs came with the wheels and tires when I bought them. All the other wheels are fine.......tires and wheels came off a daily driver. I don't know yet how many miles the guy had on them.

I ask because the wheel appears to have a flat seat in it. Can you get a pic of the lug seat from one of the other wheels. It may just be misleading from the pic as well. Are those American Racing outlaws of Ford wheels?
 

Action

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
579
Just wrong

Nothing in the pics looks right to me! First problem-You didn't tighten your self!
Jack
 

Boss351

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2007
Messages
510
Loc.
Foxboro
Here's one for the Gurus........
Some history: 68 EB with a 250 ci six, Dana 30 front with stock but freshly rebuilt drum brakes. Refurbished wheel bearings and I went thru the hub parts too.
While flat towing the rig home from a 4x4 run 280 miles from home, I lost the front passenger tire on the freeway. I was approx 35 miles from camp and all 5 lug nuts were tight. The reason I know this is because when I got back to camp after the 4x4 run, 2 lugs were missing and the other 3 were loose. We took a lug off each back tire and put them on the front.
This was not the first 4x4 trip for the vehicle since I bought it. All lugs were tight before leaving home.
The studs look to have spun allot in the flange. The spline of all studs are gone. The stud holes in the flange are wow'd out but yet the stud won't come out. I even tried putting a lug nut on one of the studs and hit it with a small sledge. Nothing.
The lugs didn't strip off. The aluminum on the studs in the pictures is from the wheel.
I've talked to several car guys and even a fellow EB owner. No one can figure it out.
My Dad came up with one idea. Maybe that side needed left hand thread studs like they use to do in the old days.......
Any constructive help?
Thx.

aluminum wheels need to retightened after 50 to 100 miles. I put my aluminum wheel on my truck after the winter and was going down a side street and looked in the mirror and my wheels were loose retightened them and check them again next day and all well here.
 

Revelation

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 9, 2004
Messages
4,825
Those wheels should have had Shouldered lug nuts, Don't care that the ones you have are the ones that came with them, you were given the wrong ones.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,110
The studs in the hub are not right?
Jack

What you are seeing is damaged studs.

I think the wrong lugnuts was the problem. Just because they came with the wheels doesn't mean they are correct. Look at the wheel, is it tapered by manufactuing or tapered because a tapered lugnut was gammed in there?

But the aluminum on the studs and the studs all sloppy in the hub were from it running down the road with loose lug nuts. The wheel flopped around as the nuts fell off. when the last one finally fell off then the wheel was finally allowed to fall off. But until it fell off it just rolled around on the hub and studs beating everything up.

There are millions of cars on the road with all right had lugnuts, There wheels stay on. You don't need left hand lugnuts.

I still think wrong lug nuts. I have seen enough to know what happens and yours has every sign of running down the road with loose nuts. Now why the nuts were loose? You said you lost a couple on that wheel just before this happened, there was something going on.

The older aluminum wheels generally took shouldered lugnuts. I have seen aluminum wheels that took tapered lugnuts but without a steel seat the nuts would pull through the aluminum. I have also seen studs there were not pressed all the way into the hub. The lugnut could be torqued, but after a few hard turns the stud would pull into the hub a little and the nuts would be loose. Try and figure out why a new set of wheel studs needed the lugnuts tightened every few miles? Took it apart again and noticed it. Stuff you learn when young.

The lugnuts you probably need look a lot more like this http://store.mettec.com/product/1050/179
 

Action

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
579
Studs

They have a huge shoulder on them? I still say hubs are shot and yes the lug nuts are wrong. Work to be done.
Jack
 

73stallion

Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 5, 2004
Messages
16,786
Loc.
Eugene, OR
why, when the wheels never backed off the previous 2 broncos, did they back off on his? the wheels came off 68ford's bronco, then were on one of my customer's bronco for a few thousand miles. we never had a problem with them, neither did 68ford. those lugs were the ones on those wheels when he bought them from my customer.
 

iwlbcnu

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 1, 2001
Messages
3,349
Looks like the hub has previous damage. On front drum brakes, the drum and hub are pressed together with the studs, since the drum has been taken out of the equation, you had less holding area. To get to your front brakes, you are supposed to remove the whole hub assemblt.
 
OP
OP
prosys1

prosys1

Full Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2011
Messages
307
Loc.
Victorville, CA
I ask because the wheel appears to have a flat seat in it. Can you get a pic of the lug seat from one of the other wheels. It may just be misleading from the pic as well. Are those American Racing outlaws of Ford wheels?

There is a "chamfer" on the wheel for the corresponding chamfer on the lugs.
The counterbore around the hole in the wheel doesn't do anything other than create clearance for the lug wrench.
And there isn't any manufacturers marking on the wheel, but the hub covers say American Racing.
 
Top