• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Full width 9 inch build…31 or 35 spline

JSmall

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
3,224
Planning my axle build and I’m curious if the 35 spline stuff will be needed. Mild 302, 4-link, and 37 inch tires are planned. Unless I’m missing something there isn’t a huge price difference between the two.

31 spline
Yukon 5.13 gears $266
Yukon Install kit $211
ARB 31 spline $1040
Yukon 31 spline shafts $335
Total $1852

35 spline
Yukon 5.13 gears $266
Yukon Install kit $232
Yukon nodular 3rd $355
ARB 31 spline $1123
Yukon 31 spline shafts $388
Total $2364

I read a 3.250” Nodular Iron 3rd member is needed for 35 spline axles so that basically makes up most of the price difference. Am I missing anything? Is the 35 spline conversion worth it?
 

Glass Pony

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
1,954
Loc.
Sussex County Delaware
For $500 I would do it, but that's just me. You might upgrade on the power or lower geared transfer case someday.
If you go 35 spline go with the ARB RD99CE. I like the ring gear bolt keepers on it.
That will make the price jump.
 

broncosbybart

Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 13, 2002
Messages
2,644
No. He won't need a drive shaft. I'd spring for a nodular center either way as the stock ones are prone to breaking at the rear pinion bearing area.

35 spline FTW
 

bigjhoov

nobody
Joined
Apr 10, 2005
Messages
3,583
Pretty sure you will need a new pinion support and yoke as well.
 

krashnpa

Jr. Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2012
Messages
115
Loc.
Mounted Joy, PA
Better deals to be had than what you're listing up there. I've worked with Brydon from quick performance, he can get you some decent deals on yukon parts. I'd also check the vendor pages on Pirate.

Yukon does not make ring gears for the 9 inch. They re-box and sell motive performance gears, so buy the motives, get the same thing, and pay less.

If you get an ARB RD99 35 spline and plan to do some hardcore off road, you probably should get a heavy duty locking collar for it, the stock ones are prone to breaking. Spidertrax and other companies make a better locking collar.

I just built a 31 spline pumpkin with a used ARB, Yukon nodular case, Yukon daytona pinion support 4.30 gears for less than 1800.
 
OP
OP
JSmall

JSmall

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
3,224
For $500 I would do it, but that's just me. You might upgrade on the power or lower geared transfer case someday.
If you go 35 spline go with the ARB RD99CE. I like the ring gear bolt keepers on it.
That will make the price jump.

WOW!!! That's out of my price range :(

If you need a different 3rd member will you also need a new driveshaft?

Not sure why I would need a new driveshaft. I'll be extending my wheelbase a little so I'll probably end up getting mine reworked anyway.

Better deals to be had than what you're listing up there. I've worked with Brydon from quick performance, he can get you some decent deals on yukon parts. I'd also check the vendor pages on Pirate.

Yukon does not make ring gears for the 9 inch. They re-box and sell motive performance gears, so buy the motives, get the same thing, and pay less.

If you get an ARB RD99 35 spline and plan to do some hardcore off road, you probably should get a heavy duty locking collar for it, the stock ones are prone to breaking. Spidertrax and other companies make a better locking collar.

I just built a 31 spline pumpkin with a used ARB, Yukon nodular case, Yukon daytona pinion support 4.30 gears for less than 1800.

Thanks for the great info...this is the type of feedback I'm looking for. I grabbed those prices from a quick Google search so I would be shopping around a little more. Didn't know Yukon used Motive...that will save me some cash.

Is the locking collar part of the locker? Sorry for my ignorance here.

I didn't add the pinion support into my price list so I'll look into that as well. Ruffstuff has a complete 35 spline, ARB third member (WC935ARB) for $2129 so that could be the way to go.
 

welndmn

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 12, 2001
Messages
2,112
Make sure your Install kit is a solid spacer.
If your pinion support is a Daytona style, you need a yoke to match it.
Anyone that's wants to buy new 9" parts, I always try and push to 35 spline because there is just so little cost difference.
 
OP
OP
JSmall

JSmall

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
3,224
If you get an ARB RD99 35 spline and plan to do some hardcore off road, you probably should get a heavy duty locking collar for it, the stock ones are prone to breaking. Spidertrax and other companies make a better locking collar.

Found it - http://www.spidertrax.com/RD-99-Engagement-Collar

Make sure your Install kit is a solid spacer.
If your pinion support is a Daytona style, you need a yoke to match it.
Anyone that's wants to buy new 9" parts, I always try and push to 35 spline because there is just so little cost difference.

After the discussion here and seeing there isn't much of a price difference, I've decided to go 35 spline with ARB and Nodular Iron 3rd member. Now I need to source all the part numbers I'll need or find a vendor that offers everything I need in a complete 3rd member. If I can find a vendor, I will make sure to ask if they used a solid spacer. Probably a basic question, but what is a Daytona style pinion support?
 

TN1776

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 24, 2006
Messages
2,632
31 spline axles are probably more than adequate, I know lots of guys running them without issue (myself included), and most drive a lot harder than I ever do.

For reference, I run a Currie housing, ARB locker, 31 spline axles with 37" tires. Feeding that is a 351w, NP435 and Dana 20 with upgraded rear output.

Prior to the Currie housing I ran a stock small bearing housing with 31 spline shafts and conversion bearings. All was well until I found an oil leak and discovered the axle bearing had cracked.
 
OP
OP
JSmall

JSmall

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
3,224
Stronger support and larger inner bearing.

What bearing ends are on the housing you plan on running?

"Stronger support and larger inner bearing". Are you saying I need those? On the bearing ends, I haven't thought that far forward. Any suggestions?

31 spline axles are probably more than adequate, I know lots of guys running them without issue (myself included), and most drive a lot harder than I ever do.

For reference, I run a Currie housing, ARB locker, 31 spline axles with 37" tires. Feeding that is a 351w, NP435 and Dana 20 with upgraded rear output.

Prior to the Currie housing I ran a stock small bearing housing with 31 spline shafts and conversion bearings. All was well until I found an oil leak and discovered the axle bearing had cracked.

I would agree that 31 spline is probably more than I'll ever need. For the small price difference, I would just rather go bigger ;D

I plan to run dual cases or an Atlas after I get through the axle builds and 3 and 4 links.
 

Amac70

ME
Joined
Mar 27, 2002
Messages
3,269
Dutchman is local "portland" and will build you anything you want almost. from the housing to the 3rd member and brakes built to order and are generally pretty reasonable on prices. a fab 9 housing and axles is only 900. then you just need the third member which they can build to spec also.

http://www.dutchmanaxles.com/
 
OP
OP
JSmall

JSmall

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 18, 2004
Messages
3,224
Dutchman is local "portland" and will build you anything you want almost. from the housing to the 3rd member and brakes built to order and are generally pretty reasonable on prices. a fab 9 housing and axles is only 900. then you just need the third member which they can build to spec also.

http://www.dutchmanaxles.com/

Thanks Arsenio, I will give them a call. I'm leaning towards Ruffstuff right now, but shopping around doesn't hurt.
 

moses_m

Full Member
Joined
May 5, 2013
Messages
262
Toms does theirs inhouse as well. They can build you what they want as well.
 

TN1776

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 24, 2006
Messages
2,632
I would agree that 31 spline is probably more than I'll ever need. For the small price difference, I would just rather go bigger ;D

I plan to run dual cases or an Atlas after I get through the axle builds and 3 and 4 links.

Nothing wrong with overkill! I too tell myself that an Atlas is in my future but can never quite pull the trigger.
 

krashnpa

Jr. Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2012
Messages
115
Loc.
Mounted Joy, PA
"Stronger support and larger inner bearing". Are you saying I need those? On the bearing ends, I haven't thought that far forward. Any suggestions?

I was answering your Daytona question, apologies.

For the housing ends, I wouldn't think you'd want to use a small bearing because the 35 spline axles take up more space which means an even smaller bearing for your axleshafts to run on. It might not be as much of something to worry about with 9 inch as say a rear D44 running 35 spline axles. Also likely a moot point as you're buying a housing and any aftermarket housing should be large bearing.

I was looking at building a 35 spline 9 inch for my other vehicle, but was thinking with 35 spline axle shafts the housing then becomes your weak point, so then I need a housing... then what about a hi-9... full float... Anyway, checking cost, the 35 spline ARB, aftermarket housing, shafts, nodular housing, disc brakes, gears, blah, blah, blah, the price topped out at close to 4k with a std 9 inch dropout. A rock jock 60 for an XJ/YJ from currie (60-5/8" WMS) which is a high pinion, 35 spline semifloat with disk brakes and integrated parking brake (like the explorer 9 inch brakes) is mid 3's and made more sense to me, even though the 9 inch is a lot lighter.

I ended up buying a dana 60-1SU (full float, smooth pumpkin, disc brakes) out of a 2000 E350 for $300 that I will shorten a few inches, add an ARB and gears for a lot less than any of the above (under 1800 complete) and still has a higher pinion than a std 9 inch. It's just F-eavy!

It's all in what you want, need, and what you want to spend, there's a ton of options out there.
 
Top