• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

high torque starter

00gyrhed

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
2,428
There are quite a few recommendations for how these things should be wired and all of them reuse the existing starter solenoid.

Why??

My starter solenoid on the fender well died and I just wired the high torque starter like a chevy starter and it seems to work just fine. I ask this question because my 96 F-250 utilizes the fenderwell solenoid and starter solenoid as did my 92 fullsize.

Again I have to ask why Ford would leave another potential point of failure in the system if it was no neccesary. I ran my 96 ford for the last two years using the fender mounted solenoid as only a distribution point, didn't see a reason to spend the money to replace it.

Is there a reason other than using it as a distribution point to leave it in the system?
 

7bronco6

Full Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2008
Messages
229
Loc.
PA
I think I read that most chebby people switch over to the ford setup because of heat. The starter gets hot and having the separate solenoid helps it start...I may be wrong, I'll have to see if I can find where I read it.

Found It
Ford solenoid
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
I kept mine because it's a convenient location to hookup the alt charge cable, body power wires, and for the hot in START terminal.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
Having a cool relay on the fender won't help or fix a hot solenoid on the starter. If the solenoid sticks, it'll still be stuck when the relay triggers, and the starter won't work. But Ford starters don't suffer from heat anyway.

Ford used the fender relay so they wouldn't have to pull so much current thru the ig.sw., which was already known to be slightly overloaded. The solenoid pulls much more than the relay because it does a lot more work.

 
OP
OP
00gyrhed

00gyrhed

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
2,428
OK maybe

Having a cool relay on the fender won't help or fix a hot solenoid on the starter. If the solenoid sticks, it'll still be stuck when the relay triggers, and the starter won't work. But Ford starters don't suffer from heat anyway.

Ford used the fender relay so they wouldn't have to pull so much current thru the ig.sw., which was already known to be slightly overloaded. The solenoid pulls much more than the relay because it does a lot more work.


I agree heat has nothing to do with it. My only thought was the ignition switch micht not be up to it, I ran might straigt to the starter for over a year with no problems, as well as my F-250 for several years, but that doesn't mean it wont crap out next time I try to start it. But does the fender monted solenoid actually pull less power than the the starter mounted solenoid, since they were both basically designed to perform the same task?

My experiencve so far is that the fender mounted solenoid is much more likely to doe than the ignition switch.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
Most high torque starters don't have an "I" post to boost the ignition voltage during crank. My ignition switch sometimes drops the run voltage during crank. Without the "I" bypass the engine will cranks but not have any power to the igntion system.

Second is that wehn you release the starter it is a spinning coil in a magnetic field, a.k.a. a generator. When you tie the little solenoid wire into the feed wire (using a fender mounted solenoid to trigger the starter feed wire and jumps solenoid wire) the spinning starter will keep the starter drive engaged until it slows enough (giving that sprag a workout).

So the fender mounted solenoid can be removed, but leaves a potential starting problem.
Just hooking it up can give problems with the starter hanging in the flywheel.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
But does the fender monted solenoid actually pull less power than the the starter mounted solenoid, since they were both basically designed to perform the same task?
Did you actually look at that diagram? The functional section shows what the solenoid does, and it's not the same as the relay.
The solenoid pulls much more than the relay because it does a lot more work.
 

76 bronco J

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 20, 2005
Messages
1,480
Did you actually look at that diagram? The functional section shows what the solenoid does, and it's not the same as the relay.

>>>>> I've always been curious too why lots of people & parts houses call the fenderwell mounted relay a solenoid ...... it may be because a solenoid is used within the relay ........ a solenoid is a mechanical device that converts energy into linear motion. Solenoids can be constructed to use electricity, compressed air (pneumatic solenoids), or pressurized fluids (hydraulic solenoids). ..............
 

RRRAAAYYY2

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 10, 2004
Messages
1,684
Loc.
Brantford, Ontario
Ford left the solenoid in place because they didnt want to rewire the vehicles at the time. That is why after about 92 or 94 (cant remember) the solenoid is gone, and the trucks are still using the same starter.

The Chevy system was prone to failure only because they used a 4 ga power cable to a very large starter draw. When it got hot, usually only with headers, it had a hot start problem. The fender wall solenoid would not fix this. Bigger cables, and in some cases a 130 turn solenoid or going to the metric solenoid fixed the problem.

As for failures, GM vs Ford starters (old style), I would say they were very evenly matched in proportion to the vehicles on the road. Chrysler was the only one making a decent starter in the 60,70,80, early 90's. Actually Toyota had some kick arse stuff in the early 80's, what everyone made the original racing starters from.

As for wiring. If you have a starter where you hot wired the solenoid, i.e. put a jumper from the main battery post over to the switch terminal. And then use a fender mounted solenoid to power the whole starter at once. You WILL cause a premature drive failure in the starter, which might only show as a whole starter failure, but usually just as a slipping drive. I know some companies supply starters with this already done, doesnt mean it is right.
 

RRRAAAYYY2

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 10, 2004
Messages
1,684
Loc.
Brantford, Ontario
>>>>> I've always been curious too why lots of people & parts houses call the fenderwell mounted relay a solenoid ...... it may be because a solenoid is used within the relay ........ a solenoid is a mechanical device that converts energy into linear motion. Solenoids can be constructed to use electricity, compressed air (pneumatic solenoids), or pressurized fluids (hydraulic solenoids). ..............

True. But the Ford fender mount solenoid is really not a relay either, it is a Mag Switch. :)
 
OP
OP
00gyrhed

00gyrhed

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
2,428
RAY,

I was hoping you would chime in. It sounds from your comments that there is no reason to use the fender mounted switch since you said ford has dropped it anyway.

An ignition terminal for the coil bypass is of no concern I am running 87 Mustang EFI.

Theres a lot of misinformation out there on this. I have a 96 F-250 that came with a fender mounted solenoid. I looked at my records and found that it died 8 years and 120,000 miles ago. I was out in the middle of the ranch at the time so I just wired the starter without it. Still that way. I went through two starters before the change and haven't changed one since the change.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
Ford left the solenoid in place...
No, they ADDED the solenoid around '91.
...after about 92 or 94 (cant remember) the solenoid is gone, and the trucks are still using the same starter.
No, the starter changed around '91 when they went to the solenoid-style. The relay is still used in trucks; it's just in the fuse/relay box now, and is a standard Bosch/ISO type. Before that, the starter used a swinging pole shoe to accomplish what the solenoid does, and IMO, it was a better system.
But the Ford fender mount solenoid is really not a relay either, it is a Mag Switch. :)
There is no fender-mounted solenoid - there's a fender-mounted relay, and it's a really a relay.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relay
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solenoid
Solenoids can be constructed to use electricity, compressed air (pneumatic solenoids), or pressurized fluids (hydraulic solenoids).
Those are linear actuators or motors; not solenoids. A solenoid is electrical - see the link above.
 

76 bronco J

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 20, 2005
Messages
1,480
>>>> I'm not going to doubt you steve83 ,but if you want to educate us could you atleast not use links to that fuc^&g joke called wikipedia....... also curious why you hangout here instead of http://www.fullsizebronco.com/ since you have a 1983 model...............
 

KyleQ

Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 24, 2008
Messages
5,480
Steve83 is on quite a few sites and knows his shit pretty damn well. Wiki is also widely known for is wide range of knowledge - but isn't to be 100% trusted. I'd trust it to wire up a starter, not perform brain surgery. Why would you even complain about the knowledge links he posted - it wasn't in-depth technical knowledge, it was simply the definition of relays and solenoids...

I recently installed a Tuff Stuff Hi-TQ mini starter and had to figure out how to wire the stupid CHev style starter. Here is a comparison of the two -


What I did to make it work was start by adding an Optima Red Top, a new solenoid on the fender (and another one in the spare parts box in the Bronco) some 14GA wire and some 0GA wire. I ran the 14GA to the ignition wire on the new starter and ran it to the output of the solenoid (where the old power cable ran) and the 0GA directly to the battery.

The mini starter rocks! It is much easier to handle, is sealed and starts the truck much easier. I ran the truck through some very deep mud and the starter didn't even complain - it sits further away from the exhaust manifolds and the only down side of things is the power cable runs by the manifold, but if you fasten it to the fender it won't give you any troubles.
 
Last edited:

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
...could you atleast not use links to that fuc^&g joke called wikipedia...
You have a computer - Google up any reputable site you like, and I bet it says the same as those Wiki aritcles. %)
also curious why you hangout here instead of http://www.fullsizebronco.com/ since you have a 1983 model...
I have ~24,000 posts on FSB, and I still browse around there occasionally. But in addition to all the work I've been doing recently on Frank's '75 to get it ready for OCBR, there's also this little reason that I'm not spending as much time over there: ;D

 
OP
OP
00gyrhed

00gyrhed

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
2,428
It appears you are opinionarted

You have a computer - Google up any reputable site you like, and I bet it says the same as those Wiki aritcles. %)I have ~24,000 posts on FSB, and I still browse around there occasionally. But in addition to all the work I've been doing recently on Frank's '75 to get it ready for OCBR, there's also this little reason that I'm not spending as much time over there: ;D


Or I am reading too much into this banned from the forum thing? ;)
 
Top