• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

2.3 ecoboost

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
The 2.4 data means little. It only makes more power at higher RPM's than a OLD 6cyl but at lower RPM's its about the same power level. About all that means is it may go faster overall than a 6cyl but it still needs the low gearing to get it moving in the first place. So in the end is it really any better? Maybe so you can hit 75 instead of topping out at 60. Will it get better mileage I doubt it.

Boost is boost more boost means more fuel period. While mild boost wont require a fat A/F it will still drink more fuel. So if the engine has to boost to maintain a certain cruise speed it will use more fuel. The smaller the engine is the more boost it will take to get the power needed to maintain speed so you end up using more fuel boosting than you would with a engine that is not boosted but larger in size that has the power needed to maintain the speed.

The 2.0L explorer has less than stellar reviews by those that have drove them. Lacks real acceleration. Good for a grocery getter but little else. Also have to consider the 2.0 is only a 2wd no 4wd versions. The 2.3 may have some more power but its still a small engine. The goal with these small engines is economy. They throw the big numbers out there to attract people to buy but in the end its economy. They have to be able to get the economy numbers in the range the goverment mandates.
You also have to consider that the truck engines are tuned differently than the car engines. Mainly because the truck takes more power to move and because its expected to do some work so the powerband tends to be lower just look at the 5.0 in the mustang and the F150. You have about a 50 hp differenace although the torque is still up there just lower in the RPM's.
Small turboed engines are attractive to the small car crowd as you can get the economy and still have power to boot plus it doesnt take much to make bigger numbers.
Theres a fine line in what it takes to power a vehicle effectively each one has different requirements and dyno charts dont always tell the whole story.
 

WheelHorse

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 22, 2004
Messages
2,511
No real need for that tuned 2.3, a stock one would be plenty of power for a stockish EB, it walks all over the motor that everyone agrees is a fine std for replacement, the 5.0 HO.

Walks all over the 302 at WOT on the dyno, but what's the real feel at 1/4 throttle? I don't think anyone here could intelligently answer this seeing that it hasn't been done in an EB using the EB's drivetrain. Plus, the Bronco's drivetrain is a ridiculous power sucker. I'd love to see that same 410 ftlbs mated up to a c4 9" Bronco and see what it drops to or with the heavier load if they could still be as aggressive with the boost without melting a piston with having to carry a load for a longer period.

Speaking in theory:

Could the e-pedal be tuned to really blow the feeling away to spool early and not as peaky as the modified graph to really outshine the 302...I'd bet good money an excellent tuner could do just that feat.

I guess the question is if your budget X could afford a 2.3 swap plus tune or a 408W swap, which direction would you go?
 
OP
OP
O

OX1

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 26, 2003
Messages
3,472
The 2.4 data means little. It only makes more power at higher RPM's than a OLD 6cyl but at lower RPM's its about the same power level. About all that means is it may go faster overall than a 6cyl but it still needs the low gearing to get it moving in the first place. So in the end is it really any better? Maybe so you can hit 75 instead of topping out at 60. Will it get better mileage I doubt it.

Boost is boost more boost means more fuel period. While mild boost wont require a fat A/F it will still drink more fuel. So if the engine has to boost to maintain a certain cruise speed it will use more fuel. The smaller the engine is the more boost it will take to get the power needed to maintain speed so you end up using more fuel boosting than you would with a engine that is not boosted but larger in size that has the power needed to maintain the speed.

The 2.0L explorer has less than stellar reviews by those that have drove them. Lacks real acceleration. Good for a grocery getter but little else. Also have to consider the 2.0 is only a 2wd no 4wd versions. The 2.3 may have some more power but its still a small engine. The goal with these small engines is economy. They throw the big numbers out there to attract people to buy but in the end its economy. They have to be able to get the economy numbers in the range the goverment mandates.
You also have to consider that the truck engines are tuned differently than the car engines. Mainly because the truck takes more power to move and because its expected to do some work so the powerband tends to be lower just look at the 5.0 in the mustang and the F150. You have about a 50 hp differenace although the torque is still up there just lower in the RPM's.
Small turboed engines are attractive to the small car crowd as you can get the economy and still have power to boot plus it doesnt take much to make bigger numbers.
Theres a fine line in what it takes to power a vehicle effectively each one has different requirements and dyno charts dont always tell the whole story.

Point is a DI engine in that size range with a modern trans behind it, should make enough power (with no or mild boost) to run a mild street bronco down the road up to 55 in my neck of the woods. My terrain is pretty MPG friendly. Lots of back roads in the 40-55 MPH range, flat @ sea level.
Will you be able to run 75 with this engine and get good mileage, probably not.

Not talking to 2.0 explorer, was using last year explorer for weight purposes only. You keep saying these small ECO's will only work in lighter vehicles. Ford disagrees and if you ever drive a 2.0 Escape, about same weight as stock EB, you might change your mind a bit too.

Walks all over the 302 at WOT on the dyno, but what's the real feel at 1/4 throttle? I don't think anyone here could intelligently answer this seeing that it hasn't been done in an EB using the EB's drivetrain. Plus, the Bronco's drivetrain is a ridiculous power sucker. I'd love to see that same 410 ftlbs mated up to a c4 9" Bronco and see what it drops to or with the heavier load if they could still be as aggressive with the boost without melting a piston with having to carry a load for a longer period.

Speaking in theory:

Could the e-pedal be tuned to really blow the feeling away to spool early and not as peaky as the modified graph to really outshine the 302...I'd bet good money an excellent tuner could do just that feat.

I guess the question is if your budget X could afford a 2.3 swap plus tune or a 408W swap, which direction would you go?

I certainly would not do the swap with any older style trans vice a 435/T-18. They have the low gearing that small motor could use and should be pretty efficient in 1:1. Slightly larger tires with stock gears would have a mild overdrive affect. For efficiency, I would use a newer 6 speed auto though.

I also am not talking this kind of swap until they are near as cheap and an explorer drivetrain is now. Probably 10 years from now min. At some point you will not be able to get a JY 302 anymore, that will not need a full rebuild. As mentioned in the beginning, I only bring up these new small ECO's as a possible candidate, as they emulate a small V-8 very very well (like no small engine ever has), in a package that is close in weight to an EB.

Will they be an amazing improvement in economy. Maybe not (most likely not if you usually use 80% of the 5.0 HO's capacity, doing whatever it is you do with your own EB). But they will have some chance of getting better than older design V-8 fuel economy, if some of your driving is lower speed steady state. To think there is not some improvement in efficiency of a new DI engine over a 30 year old W is kind of silly, equal power to equal power
(that's why I included that ford presentation above, it shows some graphs about the improvements).

I also don't see why would be unreliable in close to stock form. Heck, even the thermostat is computer controlled now and already has aftermarket upgrades to handle additional heat from the new tune's (which also tune the thermostat).
 

WheelHorse

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 22, 2004
Messages
2,511
So for the sake of this discussion does the 2.3 get taken off of the table for a guy who wants to use a c4 and a tight converter?
 
OP
OP
O

OX1

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 26, 2003
Messages
3,472
So for the sake of this discussion does the 2.3 get taken off of the table for a guy who wants to use a c4 and a tight converter?

I would take it off the table for any 3 speed auto. Not enough gear in first and no overdrive.

Would be interesting to see what a stockish bronc with maybe 30's (stock 3.5 gear)
and 5.0 EFI HO/C4 gets for mileage on flat ground, steady highway (55-65), sea level.
I've seen reports up to 22, but I don't consider that anywhere near typical.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
I still see the dyno charts as not telling the whole truth about the engine. Maybe the 2.4 would be ok but its still no better than a stock 6cyl in the range you listed 55MPHish Theres a reason they use those 6sp trannys in these vehicles they need the gearing to get moving and keep moving until it gets into the powerband. Of course the gearing they have gets the engine RPMs up fast so thats part of the feel. Take almost any engine and low gearing and it feels like it has lots of power. Granted they have done a lot in the past few years to make smaller engines more powerful but they still lack the actual torque in the low end.

It may keep you happy where and how you drive. but on the flip side if your looking 10+ years down the road guess why that vehicle is in the junkyard or being parted out? Turbos trashed, pistons melted, cam phasers broken the list goes on. As really your talking about a engine that for one is boosted, two is asked to make more power than normal, three has more parts to wear out along with the higher heat generated by the extra power and all that comes at a cost. I just wouldnt count on them being good junkyard swaps. After 10 years or so they will most likely be near the end of there lifespan in one way or the other.

What appears to be equal power is not always equal power. Fancy charts and such are great for guys in suits in a board room. But we all know that the charts dont always reflect what the real world is.

Of course if you want 4cyl power and mileage then go this route http://offroadaction.ca/2010/03/23/ford-bronco-focus-hybrid/
There are 2 of these running around AZ. Ive got pics somewhere. If I remember mileage was around the mid 20's at best and these were stripped down.
I just think that the bigger engines would be more suited to bronco use. Like the 3.5 or 3.7. I dont see the 2.3 being a all around performer in a bronco.
 
OP
OP
O

OX1

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 26, 2003
Messages
3,472
Well, we know the RPM limit is somewhere south of 8500 :p
(accidental overrev, supposedly)

attachment.php
 

fallduckcamp

New Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2013
Messages
10
Loc.
N Texas,SW Colorado
I pulled my 71 bronco back from Colorado with my 2012 3.5 is was sweet. I pulled it with my 2014 6.2 and now I'm waiting for 2015's to drop in price so I can get another 3.5.
 

pcf_mark

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
3,697
If you ever watch a dyno pull and observed the way the engine is loaded you can see what Broncobowsher is getting at. Ok so the 2.3 Eco makes say 300 ft-lb at 2500 - this is at full throttle like every dyno pull. Think about that - full throttle. But off idle rolling down the road your trying to overcome drag - mechanical and aero - just to keep going. Your 289/302 makes 150 ft-lb just off idle at light throttle. The Eco would need to be half way to the floor to make that number.
 
OP
OP
O

OX1

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 26, 2003
Messages
3,472
If you ever watch a dyno pull and observed the way the engine is loaded you can see what Broncobowsher is getting at. Ok so the 2.3 Eco makes say 300 ft-lb at 2500 - this is at full throttle like every dyno pull. Think about that - full throttle. But off idle rolling down the road your trying to overcome drag - mechanical and aero - just to keep going. Your 289/302 makes 150 ft-lb just off idle at light throttle. The Eco would need to be half way to the floor to make that number.

So the dyno sheet for the 5.0 HO I posted that claims 150 ft-lbs @ 2000RPM is not at full throttle, but the ECO dyno sheet is? You really believe that??

Please show me this mythical dyno sheet that shows any stock 5.0 is 150 ft-lbs @ the wheels, of any car, just off idle, at less than full throttle.

I understand the concept of needing the smaller engine to be under boost and the yet to be proved theory that ford immediately goes full rich @ even lower boost levels, but lets not get crazy with mythical claims.

I'll keep saying it. The more I hear about what these small ECO's can and can't do, the more I realize that those opinions are based on having little or no seat time behind the wheel of one.
 

pcf_mark

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
3,697
OX1 I think you misunderstood. I was using a part throttle reference for the 5.0 at off idle.

Fact 1: two dyno sheets if conducted properly will show the hp and torque when the engine is at full throttle. If you drive at full throttle all the time this is very helpful.

Fact 2: At a given rpm and throttle setting (less than full throttle) each engine will make less HP than the dyno sheet.

Fact 3: A modern drivetrain is optimized to work together and has substantially less drag at every point from the fan to the wheel bearings and everything in between and is an amazing aero package

What I am trying to convey is that rolling down the road at light throttle the 5.0 easily makes enough HP to overcome the drag of your rig. This is because the swept volume of your engine is large (physical size * rpm). If you take an Eco and put it up against the drag and aero the load will exceed the engine output at light throttle. You will need to open the Eco throttle to make enough power. This is where you need the dyno sheet because you will need heavy throttle to make enough power.

Or I'm nuts. That is entirely possible too.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
PFC Mark has probably explained it better than I have.

But aside from that small engine thats boosted and making big numbers vs bigger engine thats not boosted making smaller numbers. It comes down to application that engine is intended for. The small engine has to work harder to get to that number where the larger engine can loaf. Theres trade offs with the smaller engines and each vehicle has a balance point of what it takes to push it down the road in various modes.

Go back to the broncos orginal 302 Some years it was making 240 ft lbs at 2000 RPM while it probably doesnt make that at idle it is a fairly flat torque curve from idle on up. Even a stock 5.0 HO will have a fairly flat torque curve from idle on up. While tq numbers are lower at the given RPM than the earlier engine its peak is higher.
Now go back and look at the 2.3 torque below 2000 RPM its pitiful while its higher than the dyno chart shows you have to be into the boost so the torque starts climbing and its still a steep climb.. You dont get the power numbers without the boost out of the 2.3 So say your trying to cruise the neighbor hood in your 2.3l bronco well that 2.3 will struggle to keep you moving at engine speeds below 2000 RPM so you either need to be in a lower gear or get into the boost. Where your 302 powered bronco will loaf around in high gear.
Out on the hiway you want to be able to loaf. That 2.3 will not push you around at engine speeds below 2000 RPM at least not without boosting which is not loafing and is using more fuel.
In the end yes the 2.3 will push a bronco around but its not a all around engine for a bronco. It may be good to drive above 2000 RPM but thats about it you will not get the fuel economy you think you would see in fact it may end up being worse than a well tuned 302.

Dyno numbers are just that numbers and you really need to consider all of what your looking at to know the story and to make a comparison. Seat time makes little differance when seat time is in a vehicle the engine was designed for. As its going to be good in that vehicle. If it was the answer it would be in all vehicles. We dont need seat time for every instance. Yes we all have opinions. A bronco is not a 2015 mustang, explorer or lincoln MKC. But a 2.3 is still a 2.3 it only acts bigger when boosting.
As I said before your more than welcome to do a real world swap to show us what it can actually do in a bronco. Something different it would be but all around performer highly doubtful
 
OP
OP
O

OX1

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 26, 2003
Messages
3,472
OX1 I think you misunderstood. I was using a part throttle reference for the 5.0 at off idle.

Well, you said " Your 289/302 makes 150 ft-lb just off idle at light throttle."

I'd need proof that a stock early bronco 289/302 makes 150 ft-lbs (remember, the numbers we are throwing around are @ the wheels)
of torque right off idle, when floored. I sure don't buy it will make
that at light throttle, period.


Now go back and look at the 2.3 torque below 2000 RPM its pitiful

It's says 175 @ the wheels @ 1944 RPM for the stock curve.
Where does it show torque below that?

With a larger engine you have to loaf along with RPM to get any kind
of mileage. These smaller engines can run all day @ 2500-2700 and
still get as good or better than a 5.0, while still making enough
power at those RPM's to get down the road, out of boost.

The big difference vs 4 bangers of old is in the throttle response
and massive amount of near instantaneous torque available
under a cruise situation, @ CRUISE RPM. Even compared to this
2013 turbo engine, same engine size, man trans (plenty of
comparative gearing), no AWD, smaller wheel tire weight, etc.
does not come near the ECO in torque until 3000 RPM.

0610_c%202007_mazdaspeed_3%20dyno_chart.jpg


I understand all the points on efficiencies of the modern auto/drivetrain, and I sure don't believe it would ever get even 20 MPG
in an EB, but I think it has good shot of getting and honest 15 driving just about any way you want, which would be a 50% improvement
on my 70 with stock engine, small 4bbl, full length headers, duals, 1:1 man trans, 3.50 gear and 33" tires.

Normal, very light throttle, day to day accel in our new escape is absolutely effortless to 70 MPH (or way higher, but it is rare
that vehicle ever goes much over that ), never going much over 2500 RPM. That is the only reason I brought it up.
If it struggled in any way, it would have never crossed my mind to even suggest it.

It would be interesting to put an A/F-boost gauges in it and datalog that vs throttle % and mileage.............
 
Last edited:

lonesouth

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 18, 2003
Messages
5,048
Fact 2: At a given rpm and throttle setting (less than full throttle) each engine will make less HP than the dyno sheet.

I just went crosseyed trying to figure that out...I think I've convinced myself it is true. It would be interesting to see the dyno overlayed at 25/50/75/100% and then compare.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
O

OX1

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 26, 2003
Messages
3,472
I just went crosseyed trying to figure that out...I think I've convinced myself it is true. It would be interesting to see the dyno overlayed at 25/50/75/100% and then compare.

If it wasn't true, you would accelerate @ full throttle no matter how much gas you gave it............:p
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,114
I just went crosseyed trying to figure that out...I think I've convinced myself it is true. It would be interesting to see the dyno overlayed at 25/50/75/100% and then compare.

It's more complex than that. Throttle regulates engine vacuum. At low engine speeds little throttle opening is needed to get to zero vacuum. At idle there is no difference in manifold vacuum between 25% and 100%. As the engine speed increases throttle setting will alter manifold vacuum, thus cylinder pressures and power.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
In the end the dyno sheets for a boosted engine still dont tell the whole story. As your looking at the max power curve while under boost. To be effiecent the engine has to stay off or at very low boost. The amount of boost that is needed is a result of load but that has many factors that affect it as well.
It would take a lot of reengineering to get a 2.3 to work well in a bronco and even then your probably not going to realize any real benefit.
A properly setup 302 can get 15mpg and slightly more in a bronco. Plus you still have the lowend torque of a V8. remember that a 4cyl doesnt have the torque at low speeds its only half of what a V8 is(actually less than half for the 2.3vs a 302). The turbo is required to make the torque but the bad part is you have to be boosting to get that torque so it is not really going to have the torque needed off idle with no boost and it will probably need to be under some boost to maintain cruise speeds in a bronco.
Turbo charging is a great way to make a lot of power but there are still trade offs. A engine only makes X amount of power as is boost it to say 15 psi and that engine makes 100% more power but you generate more heat, use more fuel and put more stress on the engine and its componets.

I think you need a little more displacement than 2.3l to effectively and effiecently move a bronco. Thats why I would look at the ecoboosts in the F150's. Im not sold on the 2.7 yet but I think the 3.5 or 3.7 might be better options all around than a 2.3.
 

roundhouse

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 5, 2003
Messages
2,956
I still see the dyno charts as not telling the whole truth about the engine. Maybe the 2.4 would be ok but its still no better than a stock 6cyl in the range you listed 55MPHish Theres a reason they use those 6sp trannys in these vehicles they need the gearing to get moving and keep moving until it gets into the powerband. Of course the gearing they have gets the engine RPMs up fast so thats part of the feel. Take almost any engine and low gearing and it feels like it has lots of power. Granted they have done a lot in the past few years to make smaller engines more powerful but they still lack the actual torque in the low end.

It may keep you happy where and how you drive. but on the flip side if your looking 10+ years down the road guess why that vehicle is in the junkyard or being parted out? Turbos trashed, pistons melted, cam phasers broken the list goes on. As really your talking about a engine that for one is boosted, two is asked to make more power than normal, three has more parts to wear out along with the higher heat generated by the extra power and all that comes at a cost. I just wouldnt count on them being good junkyard swaps. After 10 years or so they will most likely be near the end of there lifespan in one way or the other.

What appears to be equal power is not always equal power. Fancy charts and such are great for guys in suits in a board room. But we all know that the charts dont always reflect what the real world is.

Of course if you want 4cyl power and mileage then go this route http://offroadaction.ca/2010/03/23/ford-bronco-focus-hybrid/
There are 2 of these running around AZ. Ive got pics somewhere. If I remember mileage was around the mid 20's at best and these were stripped down.
I just think that the bigger engines would be more suited to bronco use. Like the 3.5 or 3.7. I dont see the 2.3 being a all around performer in a bronco.



Yep. I'm in agreement here

The high tech over stressed tiny turbo engines will wear out quickly

What's a new turbo cost ?
There's no way a turbo on a gasser will last as long as the rest of the engine

The cam phasers are broken on every Ford I've ever seen if it has more than 90 k on it
And unless they designed it as strong as a diesel engine
I see the lower end self destructing way sooner than on a normal V-8 or 4 banger

Nowadays you can expect 200k trouble free miles from even a Hyundai or Kia
I could be wrong. Time will tell. But I just don't see these tiny turbocharged engines lasting that long

Only way to find out if it's another 6.0 disaster is to wait and see
Let someone else pay to be the long term tester
It's obvious car companies don't do any real long term testing
Their commercials brag about it but the 6.0 would never have happened if they did any actual long term, real world testing .

As long as it wasn't yours it was comical to watch .
I think of when GM converted the gas engines to diesel and slapped em in vehicles
I think some of those lasted longer than the 6.0

The junkyards are full of 90s Chevy and ford V-8s with 220k on em and they run fine
You can buy em all day for $500 and swap em in and get another 100k from it
And more computer stuff than the space shuttle

All modern cars are disposable
They are designed to last slightly longer than the warranty
And the turbo ones are just really expensive to repair disposable cars
 
Top