• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

EFI vs. Carb Pro's and Con's

SaddleUp

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 23, 2004
Messages
9,655
Loc.
Vancouver, WA
Miley said:
BTW... those codes lie! Or at least they stretch the truth. I had too much resistance in my factory harness ground wire for the HEGO and the computer swore I had 2 bad O2 sensors, a bad MAF, and too low fuel pressure.
Huh? %) %) %)
The codes lead you to a specific circuit that tests bad. They don't specify that a particular component "is" bad. The book I use always lists a number of possible problems with any particular code. It might list a bad sensor as a possible cause of a code with further instructions elsewhere for testing the sensor itself and the wiring circuit leading up to it to verify whether it is good or bad. (When listing the tools above I missed a good EFI book which I also have found to be invaluable) As for a code saying the fuel pressure is low there isn't a single code that the ecm gives that would say this. %) The ECM doesn't even check fuel pressure. (Hence the requirement for a fuel pressure guage when diagnosing problems)

As far as burning up fuel pumps the only thing I can think of that would cause that many of them to go out would be either from feeding garbage through them or using a really cheap low quality pump. (My brother went through 2 pumps on one of his vehicles before he pulled the tank out and cleaned it and he hasn't had a problem since) The EFI system itself would not cause a fuel pump to fail since it doesn't really control it. If a mechanical pump was capable of pumping out enough pressure the EFI system would accept it as a subsititute even though it would report a failure from the FP Monitor circuit. It wouldn't even throw the ECM into limp mode.
 

Rustytruck

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
10,872
You buy the dice and you roll them if it comes up snake eyes you loose. I have never been stuck on a trail with a carb because of the carb. You can always seem to get them running enough to get home. On the other hand I have strapped more than my share of electrical wonder boxes back to a paved road to await a tow truck. Yes the wonder boxes work well and they can throw all the codes the want and keep going without stopping but when the electronics actually fail your stuck dead. There are a few wizzards that know their stuff and can trick them to keep going but there are hundreds of bumblers who will burn out a part and then just plug in their spare and burn it out too. All I can say is if you do this, read everything yourself and make the harness you need and install the thing yourself. Then you will probably know enough to keep yourself out of trouble when your off the pavement. If you run strictly a street truck go for the EFI you will love it and should you ever need help it isnt very far away.
It is all based on what you know and feel confident with. I lived with carbs of all types for 30 years so I can deal with them. I carry a 30 dollar rebuild kit and a couple of cans of carb cleaner when i go off road on long trails. Carbs dont break they leak. electronics dont leak and warn you, they just fail, and only the part your not carrying a spare for. I dont carry a 100 dollar scanner, spare computer, spare high pressure fuel pump but do carry a spare low pressure one that even most of the efi guys still have to carry. No special o rings, fuel lines and throttle position sensors.
I do have some skills and all the tools to deal with efi as my street car is efi but my personal feeling is my Bronco used to run trails isnt gonna get it.
This is old dinosaur speeking but what I feel comfortable with in this current time. So throw your dice and dont come up craps. Maybe you will have the shot at being a winner. Just remember a carb will never be as good as a properly running EFI but a poorly running carb is far better than a sick Efi 50 miles from pavement.
 
M

Miley

Guest
SaddleUp said:
Huh? %) %) %)
The codes lead you to a specific circuit that tests bad. They don't specify that a particular component "is" bad. The book I use always lists a number of possible problems with any particular code. It might list a bad sensor as a possible cause of a code with further instructions elsewhere for testing the sensor itself and the wiring circuit leading up to it to verify whether it is good or bad. (When listing the tools above I missed a good EFI book which I also have found to be invaluable) As for a code saying the fuel pressure is low there isn't a single code that the ecm gives that would say this. %) The ECM doesn't even check fuel pressure. (Hence the requirement for a fuel pressure guage when diagnosing problems)

As far as burning up fuel pumps the only thing I can think of that would cause that many of them to go out would be either from feeding garbage through them or using a really cheap low quality pump. (My brother went through 2 pumps on one of his vehicles before he pulled the tank out and cleaned it and he hasn't had a problem since) The EFI system itself would not cause a fuel pump to fail since it doesn't really control it. If a mechanical pump was capable of pumping out enough pressure the EFI system would accept it as a subsititute even though it would report a failure from the FP Monitor circuit. It wouldn't even throw the ECM into limp mode.


Just relating my experiences man. Don't even know you...
 
M

Miley

Guest
Oh yeah, first two pumps were Autozone F250 pumps - so they were cheapies if you call $100 cheap. The last one was a Walbro 255 lph - not so cheap at $220. The "lean" codes directed me to check fuel pressure. I'll refrain from clicking the eye-rolling icon.

James
 
OP
OP
B

Buckshot

New Member
Joined
May 10, 2005
Messages
44
Loc.
BC, Canada
Thanks everyone, this was the kind of information i was looking for, I've decided i'll probably go with an EFI set up depending on what shape the rig i end up with is in and how much it costs me, at the very least this will be a mod i intend to make eventualy, has anyone gone EFI on a 289? what did you scavenge your set up from, and would i be better off going MAF with this engine?
 

68ford

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 26, 2004
Messages
2,710
if the air going in and the fuel from the pump forward is as clean as EFI, i think a carb will be as little maybe less maintinence, think aboput it, yeah the carb has more moving parts, but EFI is high presure and has electronic injectors whick or more suseptible to dirt. all the sensors and codes which have issues would not be there to be a problem in the first place, you guys are talking about troubleshooting codes and dealing with sensors, non of which you would be doing if it was a nice dialed in clean carb.
i do admit to the driveability and cold starting is much better.
i just dont see it being less maintince, 25,000mi(beatin it hard) havent touched a single thing on the motor, but ive changed my oil and cleaned my air filter,but that doesnt count. ;D
 

68ford

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 26, 2004
Messages
2,710
Miley said:
Oh yeah, first two pumps were Autozone F250 pumps - so they were cheapies if you call $100 cheap. The last one was a Walbro 255 lph - not so cheap at $220. The "lean" codes directed me to check fuel pressure. I'll refrain from clicking the eye-rolling icon.

James

this is kinda like comparing a B to a ISB cm850 with liquid cooled egr huh? one needs one 12volt wire to run, the other needs all kinds of shit everywhere. ;D
 

lars

Contributor
Been here awhile
Joined
Jun 29, 2001
Messages
3,334
Loc.
NorCal flatlands
This is fun reading. no one will ever win this argument, even if the thread goes to 20 pages.

My old stock tired 302 with never-rebuilt carb (at least not by me in 60k miles of driving) ran fine for all the years I had it, other than the occasional hot-start hiccup. Sea level to 10,000 feet, even on the side of a mountain. It sucked gas like an alcoholic at a cocktail party.

EFI is a PITA to sort out, especially if you don't keep the system stone-stock, or you mess with wild cams. The codes may tell you where to look, but at least one problem took me weeks of fiddling to get straightened out- at least in part because none of the famous EFI books touched on the issue. None of the systems on my stock engine took that much time to troubleshoot. That said, I went with nearly all new parts on my EFI system and after finally getting it running right I've had exactly zero problems in three years and 25k miles. I know my EFI system backwards and forwards and could probably troubleshoot any showstoppers in a few minutes. I'm happy with it and would never go back to a carb. Even though my current EFI roller engine (with twice the power) sucks gas like an alcoholic with his own distillery.

It's a hobby. Go with whatever yanks your chain and have fun. Lots of good help to be had on this board either way.
 

mxpaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 21, 2001
Messages
2,901
Loc.
KC
I'll throw a wrench in.. I think using propane is the best. Easy, cheap runs on angles will go forever. Cons- filling propane tanks.
 

Socal Tom

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 12, 2004
Messages
2,442
Loc.
San Diego, CA
ElJefe said:
Uh huh... and how many miles were on that mustang that you scavenged your system off of???QUOTE]

I have no idea, it was an 87 mustang harness originally. I made my conversion in 2000 or 2001, so the harness was 13 years old. Took me a while to sort out the issues. ( a lot like Lars' story). Now that I've got it dialed in I love it.
Tom
 

sicaz66

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 14, 2001
Messages
1,951
Loc.
san diego
HotWheels said:
I actually considered using EFI until I started using a Holley Truck Avenger. It works.

:D

yes it does. efi left me stranded after replacing $300.00 worth of sensors it still would not stay running. my t/a carb gets 13 mpg and runs like a champ. ;D
 

HotWheels

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 8, 2003
Messages
9,179
Loc.
Twilight Zone
I do however think there is room for both EFI and Carbs. Do what you like with your broncos. I love my bronco just for the fact that we CAN do anything we want...right?

Just look at Mr.PeroniS ride compared to a stocker. We want what we want...go figure.

Do what your skillset permits.

I like carbs...easy to fix and replace when necessary.
 

68ford

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 26, 2004
Messages
2,710
HAHA just realized between the first page and this thread, there are about 4 different threads of people having issues with efi, not one about a carb.
like i said keep the air and fuel just as clean, it will have same if not less maintinence. :)
 
Top