• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Mig or Tig?

Frankenhorse

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2004
Messages
448
Loc.
Smyrna,TN
I have a el-cheepo mig and have been looking at getting a tig. I know Crab has been tig welding his cages and been wondering if it is better. Is it just a better looking weld or is it stronger? I also know that a tig is duel purpose as far as being able to do stick welding with the same machine. Anyone have any input to share.

Also was looking at the Miller portable.http://www.millerwelds.com/products/tig/maxstar_150_sth/
 

NicksTrix

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 1, 2001
Messages
6,410
you don't mention your welding skills. tig takes far more skill and is a slower process. if you are a crappy welder, you be an ever crappier welder with a tig, don't waste your money. if that's the case i'd suggest buying a decent wire welder with bottle and learn how to really weld. there is more to it than pulling the trigger.
both can produce equally strong welds if done properly.
just my .02
nick
 

danny

Full Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2005
Messages
176
The Type Of Welder You Need All Depends On The Type Of Work You Will Be Doing.i Own A Welding And Machine Shop.i Have A 250 Miller Synchrowave , 250 Millermatic Mig , Dialarc 250 Stick. All 3 Machines Get Used Daily.if You Are Welding A Lot Of Thick Steel,3/4 And Over You Need A Stick Welder. With The Millermatic 250 I Can Weld Up To About 1/2 Thick Steel,stainless And With Optional Spoolgun ,aluminum.the Spool Does Great For Structural Welds.if You Are Looking For Tuna Tower Work Then You Need A Tig.the Tig Is Slow ,but It Does A Pretty Weld On Aluminum.if You Are Doing General Fabrication In Your Garage I Would Get A Mig, Go For The Biggest Machine You Can Afford.gas Bottle Is Not An Option,get It.i Used To Own A Millermatic 185, I Am Much Happier With A 250.if You Can Afford A Auto Darkening Shield Go For It.the Auto Really Will Improve You Welding Skills.
 
OP
OP
Frankenhorse

Frankenhorse

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2004
Messages
448
Loc.
Smyrna,TN
NicksTrix said:
you don't mention your welding skills. tig takes far more skill and is a slower process. if you are a crappy welder, you be an ever crappier welder with a tig, don't waste your money. if that's the case i'd suggest buying a decent wire welder with bottle and learn how to really weld. there is more to it than pulling the trigger.
both can produce equally strong welds if done properly.
just my .02
nick


Sorry your right I didn't mention them. Stepping back and being critical of my skill I would say high end of average. I was good with a stick but, it has been along time since I have picked up a welder. I have never attempted a tig. I can handle the slow speed but, was trying to weigh the benefits of a better Mig or just trying Tig.
 
OP
OP
Frankenhorse

Frankenhorse

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2004
Messages
448
Loc.
Smyrna,TN
danny said:
The Type Of Welder You Need All Depends On The Type Of Work You Will Be Doing.i Own A Welding And Machine Shop.i Have A 250 Miller Synchrowave , 250 Millermatic Mig , Dialarc 250 Stick. All 3 Machines Get Used Daily.if You Are Welding A Lot Of Thick Steel,3/4 And Over You Need A Stick Welder. With The Millermatic 250 I Can Weld Up To About 1/2 Thick Steel,stainless And With Optional Spoolgun ,aluminum.the Spool Does Great For Structural Welds.if You Are Looking For Tuna Tower Work Then You Need A Tig.the Tig Is Slow ,but It Does A Pretty Weld On Aluminum.if You Are Doing General Fabrication In Your Garage I Would Get A Mig, Go For The Biggest Machine You Can Afford.gas Bottle Is Not An Option,get It.i Used To Own A Millermatic 185, I Am Much Happier With A 250.if You Can Afford A Auto Darkening Shield Go For It.the Auto Really Will Improve You Welding Skills.

Ok. This is perfect. I don't have a bottle attachment to the mig I have. It was a present a year or so ago. Don't blame them they didn't know any better. I think I might have to start priceing migs now. I do have the auto dark shield love it.

Like the name by the way.
Thanks
Dan
 

slcpunk

Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2006
Messages
419
Loc.
The WB, UTAH
when I took a welding class at the local welding colledge I thought ok mig was cake and I can do stick no prob... tig is so much different then mig or stick. I would say its more like oxy/aceteline welding but much faster and cleaner.

tig really is an art form in the right hands but it takes time to learn the skill, and a mig is just so easy to do right and strong.

btw I agree the auto-dark helmets are real nice, I purchased one from harbor freight and I was very impressed. for the price of around $60 it is worth it
 

Madgyver

Bronco Madman
Joined
Jul 30, 2001
Messages
15,030
A 210 is a damn good unit. Perfect for a small shop with alot of welding. Might be overkill for home use.

Overkill is good.... ;D
 

66BroncoWA

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2004
Messages
105
It does depend on what you are trying to do. I have had a MIG and now have a TIG and will never go back. The TIG does take more practice but it is really pretty easy to use and offers much more flexibility. If you can only spend the money for one welder, TIG is the way to go. I own a Lincoln Precision TIG 185

Advantages of TIG:

1. High quality, clean weld
2. Ability to weld aluminum without an expensive spool gun.
3. Ability to weld other metals besides steel and aluminum
4. Most TIG welders can also function as a stick welder

Disadavantages of TIG:

1. Slower
2. Takes a little practice. (similar to gas welding but much easier to master)

That's my two cents worth.
 

tsmustangs

Full Member
Joined
May 16, 2005
Messages
271
Loc.
All Over
I'm an Autoshop aide and a Miller 175 will cover just about anything you'd ever want to do at home. Best welder for the money in my opinion.
 
OP
OP
Frankenhorse

Frankenhorse

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2004
Messages
448
Loc.
Smyrna,TN
I looked at the spool gun. Its a over $800 :eek: . That will put me over $2500. There is some aluminum I'd like to do. Keep the opinions come'n.

Overkill yes but, it's better then not enough. ;D I was looking at that one because of the spool gun attachment. Perhaps a step down.


Hmmmm Tig or Mig still thinking. %)
 

steward

New Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2006
Messages
5
Frankenhorse
I have been doing sheetmetal fabrication for the past 20years,and I can tell ya they both have there specific place and application,for genneral use the mig is fine. Really just depends on what your doing.For instace welding the floor boards in my bobtail I used the mig ,But I just finished a custom gas tank and oil tank for a friends motorcycle and wouldnt have dreamed of using the mig for that application,becuase of the extra build up of weld and heat zone caused by the mig.Really just depends on your skills and what kind of applications your going to be doing.

Just my 2 cents
Dan.S
 
Top