Hey guys, just my .02 here, but I've been running rail type rockers on my rigs for years with no issues. I was thumbing through my old issues of Hot Rodding and in the September '05 issue, they actually recommend rail type rockers, claiming that they are just as reliable and maintain more stable valvetrain geometry.
These eliminate the need for head machining (other than tapping for studs) and the cost of guideplates and hardened pushrods. Now, I've heard the stories of how the rails can tap the spring retainer, causing it to bounce and let the locks fall out, but I'm here to tell you, if there's a few thousandths clearance between the rail and the retainer, it's never going to happen. Like I said, just my thoughts on the matter, but I run a smallblock to 6,600 rpm in my '66 Mustang regularly and those Comp Magnums have never had an issue.