• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

gear ratio question

Airborne_Sapper

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
59
Loc.
Fayetteville
Fellas I am reaching the end of the restro on my 77 EB. A little back ground on the truck it has a 302, NV 3550, D20, Dana 44 and 9 in with 3.50 gears on 33x12.5x15 tires. I don't really know that much about gear ratios and how they affect engine rpm, speed and fuel mileage. The main use of this bronco is cruising to the beach, approx 75 each way, and everyday driver. Will the 3.50 gears be approiate for this type use or will I need to install some taller gears I.e. 4.11s?
 

Dave

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 25, 2006
Messages
2,264
I ran 3.55 with a ZF (.76 OD) and 31 tires. Too low. I think 3.73 would have been about perfect. 4.11 would be about the same with 33 tires for the type of driving you stated.
 
OP
OP
Airborne_Sapper

Airborne_Sapper

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
59
Loc.
Fayetteville
So the best bet would be to buy some 4.11 gears to get the desired rpm range while driving on the highway? Well on that what would be the best place to get a decent set of 4.11s for both the dana 44 and 9 in? Also does it make since to get the 31 spline axles or is the 28 spline sufficent for mostly road use?
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
I think 4.30-4.56 would be good if you want to actually use that 5th gear. 4.30 would put 2500 rpm @ 73 mph. 4.56 would be 2500 rpm @ 69 mph. Stock tire size and 3.50 gears would have 2500 rpm @ about 60 mph.
 

needabronco

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 2, 2004
Messages
6,411
Loc.
Prescott/Farmington
The standard 302 likes around 2200-2500 RPM's at cruise on the freeway. I say don't fear the gear and go bigger like 4.56's or even 4.88's. You won't regret the decision to go with a higher ratio, at least I've never heard anyone wish they had but have heard plenty (like me) wishing they went with more gear the first time around...
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,114
I would agree that you will need more gear. How much is dabatable but the above 4.10 or more is what I think would be good. Maybe even as high as 4.88. Depends on how well the engine runs, acceleration desired, comfort level, etc. But 3.50 gears are not low enough, especially with an overdrive.

You can change gears all you want and not have to do any axle shaft changes. If changing the differential (adding limited slip, locker, etc. then I would do 31 spline upgrade at that time. Also check the shafts, see if there is any spline twist or excessive wear on the seal area. Those are also signs to upgrade.

My recomendation would be to put a set of gears in only the rear axle (for now). Drive it around and see how you like it. Can't run in 4WD that way, but you will get a feel for how it drives on the street. If you don't like the gearing the 9" is simple and cheap to swap to another ratio, sell the old ones for only a little loss on Craig's list. It is one thing to discuss therotical ratios and how they behave, it is another to actually have them in an axle and drive around. I have had some vehicles that the change in ratio had little effect in how it drove and only noticed a different highway RPM, others were day and night different with a change in gear.

To an extent the higher the gear (lower number) the better the fuel economy. But it is a curve. Go too far and you are now running too low of an RPM, engine is no longer in the happy spot and gas mileage drops. For a standard carbed 302 at highway speeds, 2000-3000 RPM is a good spot to aim for.

Side note on this; some state best fuel economy comes at the peak torque RPM. This is only partially true. It is true when run at full throttle. At less then full load the best fuel economy will be at a different engine speed, generally a little lower.
 
OP
OP
Airborne_Sapper

Airborne_Sapper

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
59
Loc.
Fayetteville
Everyone thanks for all the info. It was extremely educational. The plan is to finish putting the truck together drive it around with the 3.50 gears to get a feel with the new trans and tire size. Also I have an extra 9 in laying around going to rebuild with some 4.55 or higher gears amd swap the whole rear end one weekend and see how it runs. Worst case I can sell either axle since they both will be fresh rebuilds. Once again thanks for the info.
 

patrickk1

Jr. Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
135
Loc.
Cambridge
But 3.50 gears are not low enough, especially with an overdrive.

I partially disagree with this. He is running a nv3550 with a 4.01:1 first gear. Running the 3.50's with th nv is like running a stock 3spd manual (2.99 first) with 4.71's or a c4 (2.46 first) with 5.67's but having 2 extra gears, the final gear maybe even being useless. These numbers are based on the final drive ratio of the transmissions and their respective gearing. He's only on 33" tires. With this transmission and what he's using it for, IMHO the gearing is fine. He would be at 70mph in 4th gear at 2500rpm's or 70mph in 5th at 1950rpms. Depending on his engine, he might get better fuel economy in 4th gear than 5th. I was originally planning on a nv3550 swap with 37"tires but after creating many spreadsheets that take into account 8 different transmissions gear ratios and different rearend gearing at different highway speeds, the nv3550 is kind of overkill for what I am needing and I can get away with a manual 4sp and save a ton of money on not buying adapters. I would not switch gears for the sake of switching gears. Running the nv with 4.11's is like running the 3spd with 5.43's or a c4 with 6.50 gears. I would not be surprised if he just starts out in 2nd gear alot of times in normal traffic driving if he runs the 4.11's with the nv. That being said, If he plans to do some more than mild offroading, he may want to upgrade them for the deep first gear but he will still probably ignore 1st gear for normal everyday driving.
 

dbevans2249

Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Messages
610
Loc.
Buena Park, Ca.
I have the NV3550 and 33 in tires. 4.11 was not low enough to allow 5th gear to be realistically useable. I have changed to 4.56 and think that would be a good choice for 75-mile trips to the beach.
 

Dave

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 25, 2006
Messages
2,264
Everyone thanks for all the info. It was extremely educational. The plan is to finish putting the truck together drive it around with the 3.50 gears to get a feel with the new trans and tire size. Also I have an extra 9 in laying around going to rebuild with some 4.55 or higher gears amd swap the whole rear end one weekend and see how it runs. Worst case I can sell either axle since they both will be fresh rebuilds. Once again thanks for the info.

I'f you have a set of 31" tires and wheels you can stick on it, you can get an idea of of what I would be like with a similar final drive ratio and bigger tires. I ran 3:55 with a ZF 5 speed and 31 inch tires (as I mentioned earlier). Low was usable on the street and 5th was in the sweet spot about 70 mph. A little high for a EB.

As stated above there is a ballance between too low of a first (on the street) and an unusable OD. Personal preference and intended use has a lot to do with the selection.
 

patrickk1

Jr. Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
135
Loc.
Cambridge
I have the NV3550 and 33 in tires. 4.11 was not low enough to allow 5th gear to be realistically useable. I have changed to 4.56 and think that would be a good choice for 75-mile trips to the beach.
With 4.56 gears and the nv, I would suspect that you wouldn't really need 1st gear for daily driving and you would be fine starting in second gear. Out of curiosity, do you ever skip 1st and start in 2nd when driving on the street? As I stated above, with 3.50's, overdrive might be useless. My point was that for his purposes of daily driving and trips to the beach, he would be either wasting overdrive or wasting 1st gear.
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
With 4.56 gears and the nv, I would suspect that you wouldn't really need 1st gear for daily driving and you would be fine starting in second gear. Out of curiosity, do you ever skip 1st and start in 2nd when driving on the street? As I stated above, with 3.50's, overdrive might be useless. My point was that for his purposes of daily driving and trips to the beach, he would be either wasting overdrive or wasting 1st gear.

How can 1st gear be wasted? It's still useful when creeping in traffic jams or on the trail. On the other hand, if 5th gear can only be used during long, fast downhill runs, how useful is that?
 

patrickk1

Jr. Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
135
Loc.
Cambridge
Will the 3.50 gears be approiate for this type use or will I need to install some taller gears I.e. 4.11s?
I had another winded reply based on the above responses but decided not to send it.

The short answer is yes, but 5th gear is pretty much useless. At 70mph, 4.56's in 5th is 2535rpm. 3.50's in 4th gear is 2495rpm. Only a 40rpm difference.. 1st gear is still low enough for city driving with 3.50's.
 

patrickk1

Jr. Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
135
Loc.
Cambridge
Why have a five speed if you can't use overdrive? Seems like a waste to me.
I completely agree. What it comes down to is he has the nv3550 already installed. Will he see a difference between 70mph 4th gear with 3.50's vs 4.56's in 5th or for daily driving? Absolutely not. RPM, Speed, and fuel economy will be identical. 1st gear will pull harder for the 1/2 second he is in it, if he even uses 1st in daily driving. He doesn't NEED to upgrade anything unless he wants to offroad it or just spend money for the sake of spending money. Yes, other gearing would open up more options for what he can due with his rig but if he never plans to offroad it or doesn't at this time, why spend the money unless you find a screaming deal.
 

trailpsycho

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 11, 2003
Messages
4,856
I ran a mostly stock 302 with stock gears and 31s after a NV3550 install for about 6 months. 5th gear (OD) is mostly useless on all but the flatest of drives. I hauled a tub and some other parts up to MI after the install and was unable to use 5th gear much of the time. Even though there was enough gear to hold 65 or 70, there wasnt anything much for passing.

On the flipside, I ditched the NV3550 for an NV4500, regeared with 4.88s (35" tires) with a fresh 5.0. Its pretty good...however, 70 mph with grades still leaves a little to be desired. At 85, it pulls hard...more gear isnt a bad thing here. As it is now, low speed highway driving (60-65) is fine in OD, but if you get into grades, sometimes I need to downshift as it isnt in the "powerband". The peak power for most of these 302/5.0s is between 2500 and 2700. The closer you can get your 70 mph to the 2600-2700 range, the happier you will be--power-wise. Keep in mind, this is largely Bronco-specific due to the inherent aerodynamic-deficiencies of the truck likely compounded by the presence of suspension and or body lift.

For your setup, go with the 4.56s. If you EVER think you might want larger tires (35s), then go with 4.88s. Dont bother with 4.11 or 4.30s...you wont gain anything on fuel economy and it will only hurt you on the highway (in passing and pulling power--in general and especially uphill or pulling a trailer--never say never).
 
OP
OP
Airborne_Sapper

Airborne_Sapper

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2010
Messages
59
Loc.
Fayetteville
I have drove the truck with the stock 3.50s, nv 3550 on 31's and first gear was pretty useless in everyday driving. I would either start in 2nd gear or would start in first and then shift directly into 3rd gear. I also had the same result that trailpsycho had with 5th gear it was pretty worthless anywhere except on flat interstate driving unless I wanted to pass someone and then there was no power at all. So in the end should change my gears to a lower than 4.11's or are they sufficient or just keep the stock ones?
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
I completely agree. What it comes down to is he has the nv3550 already installed. Will he see a difference between 70mph 4th gear with 3.50's vs 4.56's in 5th or for daily driving? Absolutely not. RPM, Speed, and fuel economy will be identical. 1st gear will pull harder for the 1/2 second he is in it, if he even uses 1st in daily driving. He doesn't NEED to upgrade anything unless he wants to offroad it or just spend money for the sake of spending money. Yes, other gearing would open up more options for what he can due with his rig but if he never plans to offroad it or doesn't at this time, why spend the money unless you find a screaming deal.

You're missing a key point. He has 33" tall tires and 3.50 gears now. That alone is already providing an overdrive effect. Swapping to 4.56 gears will keep that same overdrive ratio but will also provide more usable torque in all the lower gears where it's needed. Keep the overdrive in the last gear.
 

trailpsycho

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 11, 2003
Messages
4,856
1st gear in the NV3550 isnt useless. It will actually get you up and moving nicely and the shift to second affords a nice pull. I would say that 2nd gear is not deep enough to start in, in general.

Now, in the NV4500, 2nd gear is just as 1st in the stock 3 spd, so I use it most of the time. 1st comes in handy in heavy traffic/jams and off-road/crawling.

Again, If you are going to put in new gears, go with 4.56s or 4.88s. You will be surprised at the difference in power and driveability in all gears.

As far as where to get them...its probably about the same most places. Gear sets start about $125 and range to 200. Most of the vendors sell them, Complete Offroad has good prices and have supported this site over the years as well. Hell, Summit is a good source. You will need appropriate install kits. For the 9", I would recommend upgrading to a Daytona Pinion support. If you decide to upgrade the 9" to a 31 spline, definitely get the DPS and consider buying a Strange Engineering Nodular Case to install it all in. The Strange case is only ~$230 and is many, many times stronger than a factory 9" case. It has alot of material adjacent to the pinion support bearing. This area is not cast with alot of material in the stock cases...and to boot, when you install larger ring gears like 4.56 and 4.88s, this support area often requires 'clearancing' which makes this a weak, failure prone area in a stock 9" case. It is the most common failure in a 9". I found this out the hard way. 31 spline would be the HD option (more desirable); factor in ~ $230-400 for 31 spline axle shafts. The Yukons are decent and reasonably priced. There are other options. Check with Strange, they problably offer something as well. Good folks there.

If you are considering this option, its often a good option to order an entire 3rd member...as the supplier tends to absorb some of the gear-setting-up cost, often times. Makes it nice, slap it in, install axles and go.

For the front end, you will need a new open carrier, carrier/lunchbox locker or locker/carrier (ARB, OX, detroit), if you go with the 4.56 or 4.88s. The OX or the ARB are preferable, but costly. I dont think they make "thick gears" that big for the D44.

Do it right, do it once. You wont be disappointed, the weak link in the group or stranded when the group's not around....

Best

John
 

needabronco

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 2, 2004
Messages
6,411
Loc.
Prescott/Farmington
Believe it or not you'll get less fuel economy and more engine wear lugging your engine along all day. Drive it in the middle of the power band where your engine is designed to operate and it will be more efficient in the long run. So what you don't use first gear that much, some day you'll find yourself starting at the bottom of a steep driveway or hill and you'll be happy you have it. If you never use 5th gear because your too under powered, you'll still never use it, which is a total waste!

My engine will cruise at 2200 rpms doing 70 on the highway, it's MUCH happier at 2500 rpms, there I find I actually use less throttle to keep it there. And I have 4.88's, I still think all the time that I should have gone to 5.13's...
 
Top