• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

gear ratio question

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,114
With a 5-speed the gearing is good for a 5-4 downshift at highway speeds. Gives the ability to pass. Try that with most 4-speeds and when you drop from 4-3 you don't have anything left because the gear spacing has the engine topped out in 3rd.

As for 1st being too low, it is never too low. Back when I had the 435 I would drive around mall parking lots in granny. I would also idle down the highway in bumper to bumper, wreck ahead traffic. Low gears on the street come in handy. With my daily driver (geared very close to the NV3550) I do shift from 1-2 halfway across the intersection i I am putzing around. If I am in a little bit of a hurry it stays in 1st a lot longer. I also find that if I am at a little bit of a roll or pointing downhill I often just start in 2nd gear.

Now with this in mind I am doing this with properly geared axles to match the engine and tire size. If the gearing is wrong, it just sucks and you will hate it. Hopefully you will be smart enough to blame the gears and not the transmission swap.

As for the noob telling you a 4-speed will fix everything, he didn't even mention what 4-speed he is thinking of. To be honest I can't figure it out either. I can only guess a granny as tall tires, high gears and tall tires would be pure hell to get moving.
 

patrickk1

Jr. Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
135
Loc.
Cambridge
As for the noob telling you a 4-speed will fix everything, he didn't even mention what 4-speed he is thinking of. To be honest I can't figure it out either. I can only guess a granny as tall tires, high gears and tall tires would be pure hell to get moving.
Maybe you need to reread the post. When I mentioned 4th gear rpm and speed, it was 4th gear of the nv3550. That's what's currently in there so I wouldn't change it. Unfortunately, I was unaware that automotive knowledge on this forum was based on post count. Like I said originally, For his purpose, if he does not want to, he doesn't have to upgrade. I am the only one here that seems to be showing him both sides of the story. Everyone here just says upgrade even though for his current usage, it might not be necessary to spend the money. If he intends to offroad, then upgrade it. He asked about mileage and rpm for daily driving. I don't see how any of you can say I did not answer that question. With his current setup, he is already running better than a c4 on 33's with with 5.38's.

To clarify, 5th gear on the nv w/ 4.56's (i am just randomly choosing that gear based on recommendations in this post) is no different rpm/speed/economy wise than 4th gear on the nv w/ the 3.50 gears.
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
Maybe you need to reread the post. When I mentioned 4th gear rpm and speed, it was 4th gear of the nv3550. That's what's currently in there so I wouldn't change it. Unfortunately, I was unaware that automotive knowledge on this forum was based on post count. Like I said originally, For his purpose, if he does not want to, he doesn't have to upgrade. I am the only one here that seems to be showing him both sides of the story. Everyone here just says upgrade even though for his current usage, it might not be necessary to spend the money. If he intends to offroad, then upgrade it. He asked about mileage and rpm for daily driving. I don't see how any of you can say I did not answer that question. With his current setup, he is already running better than a c4 on 33's with with 5.38's.

To clarify, 5th gear on the nv w/ 4.56's (i am just randomly choosing that gear based on recommendations in this post) is no different rpm/speed/economy wise than 4th gear on the nv w/ the 3.50 gears.

Post count has nothing to do with knowledge or experience or common sense. Please refer to the original post in this thread. You'll see that the original poster (OP) is completing a restoration and has a NV 3550. Not many early Broncos came from the factory that way, in fact, none did. Obviously the OP paid for that NV 3550. Probably paid a lot of money. He didn't spend all that money restoring a stock Ford 3-speed trans. Ask yourself why. Because of this, it can be assumed that he prefers to use all the gears that he paid for. 3.50 gears won't do it.

Your advice is akin to someone asking about a pressurized air source to use with an air locker that is currently installed and you telling them they don't need an air source.
 

patrickk1

Jr. Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2011
Messages
135
Loc.
Cambridge
Your advice is akin to someone asking about a pressurized air source to use with an air locker that is currently installed and you telling them they don't need an air source.
There is a huge difference in cost for new carriers, axles, and gears for both the front and rear axles vs a pressurized air source.
 

dbevans2249

Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Messages
610
Loc.
Buena Park, Ca.
patrick1 going back to reply to post #11.
With 33" tires, 4.11 Gears and the NV3550 first was to low to start out on the street. The problem IMO was that second was to high starting out from a stop and overdrive was to high. I installed 4.56"s that I got a good deal on but am afraid that 4.88 would have been the better choice. IIRC with the 4.56's, starting in second with 33's will still be higher than the original ratio was from the factory with the original tires. I am also wondering if overdrive RPM will be a little low.
 
Top