• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Reasons why diff oil pukes from vent?

garberz

Bronco Influencer
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
6,864
Loc.
Conejo Valley, Ca.
What are different reasons why the diff fluid keeps blowing out the vent line on there rear end? It's never been a problem before. I just bought a new Currie housing, same third member with Detroit locker, same 31 spline axles w/set20 bearings. I've always used Lucas 85/140wt oil. It's making a mess. Why is this happening?

Mark
 

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
Damn...and you're already using a high quality heavy wt. oil (vs. 70 W 90).
Is the fill plug on the Currie housing higher?
Wait the fill plug is on the carrier right?
I have seen some aftermarket housings that have a separate higher fill port for some axles that get shimmed up real high fo pinion adjustment. This high pinion adjustment can apparently leave the pinion bearings not as well lubricated as they should be at low axle speed.
Atleast thats how it was explained to me....
Anyway maybe your lube level is too high for your vent location.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
Where is the vent located at? How does this compare to the original housing that didn't do it?

Oil splash combined with thermal expansion. Splash gets it to the breather, expansion pushes it up the hose. My guess is the new breather location is exactly where the oil splash from your rear end is spraying at. Just like splashing water in a pool, a little different angle (of the gear teeth hitting the oil) changes the angle of the spray. Probably got the perfect storm of breather and gear tooth angle.

Have you considered adding a baffle or moving the breather?
 
OP
OP
garberz

garberz

Bronco Influencer
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
6,864
Loc.
Conejo Valley, Ca.
Where is the vent located at? How does this compare to the original housing that didn't do it?

Oil splash combined with thermal expansion. Splash gets it to the breather, expansion pushes it up the hose. My guess is the new breather location is exactly where the oil splash from your rear end is spraying at. Just like splashing water in a pool, a little different angle (of the gear teeth hitting the oil) changes the angle of the spray. Probably got the perfect storm of breather and gear tooth angle.

Have you considered adding a baffle or moving the breather?

The vent is closer to the third member and is located on top of the housing. I had to fab something to hold the brake line tee, because of the different location. (More towards the center) You may be on to something with the "perfect storm theory".
 

pbwcr

Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2007
Messages
652
Diff vent pukes

Pretty common in the aftermarket world.
As already mentioned - fill port and or vent port in the wrong place.
Much more common is slightly higher temps than you are used to. Cause is the install tight. Not a problem just add a catch container at the top of the vent. A high percentage of the go fast trucks have the catch container due to high speeds and extra heat causing thermal expansion. I have 3 rigs and all are aftermarket gears/lockers and only one axle has the issue. Nice tight gears with no backlash like the stock setups.
PaulW
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,622
Loc.
PNW
You will probably have to weld in a deflector to divert the oil from being "sprayed or flung" towards the vent tube like BB mentioned above.

I was cruising the Rubicon with a bunch of other PNW Bronco buddies and my rear diff was spewing 90Wt out the vent hose (which was 2' above the rear diff).

I was running a standard low pinion 9" (vent on axle tube) with a second gen ARB, 31 spline. Couldn't figure it and was wheeling with Tim from ARB once, told him the issue and said that it's very common problem with ARB's (maybe just that gen? I can't remember now). Anyway, he said he had the same issues. He said to move the vent to the top of the housing but off to the side of where oil would spray off the ring gear AND then weld in a baffle so it would also help keep oil from spraying in the tube it would cure the issue.

I did it, problem solved.

When I built a new housing for my TrueHi9 with an ARB a couple years back...no issues with it either.

Kind of a pain to have to pull the axles, rear pumpkin, etc to fix this but it's an absolute cure...
 

shamu

Lucky as the day is long.
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
5,290
Loc.
Sachse,Tx
What are different reasons why the diff fluid keeps blowing out the vent line on there rear end? It's never been a problem before. I just bought a new Currie housing, same third member with Detroit locker, same 31 spline axles w/set20 bearings. I've always used Lucas 85/140wt oil. It's making a mess. Why is this happening?

Mark

WHY ARE YOU USING SYNTHETIC OIL???????????????????????????????
All ford 9 inch axles need hipoid oil. Remember oil needs to clime up the ring gear in a solid hydro state.
Ck out the true Hi9 page.
ring me later
 
OP
OP
garberz

garberz

Bronco Influencer
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
6,864
Loc.
Conejo Valley, Ca.
WHY ARE YOU USING SYNTHETIC OIL???????????????????????????????
All ford 9 inch axles need hipoid oil. Remember oil needs to clime up the ring gear in a solid hydro state.
Ck out the true Hi9 page.
ring me later

It's just the standard Lucas oil, not synthetic.
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,622
Loc.
PNW
TrueHi9 requires non-synthetic oil so it WILL cling and follow the ring gear up so it will help lubricate the pinion brgs.

They have done extensive research on rear diff fluids and what works best for this application.
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,622
Loc.
PNW
I checked out the bellows you are closing out...curious?...how come they are being closed out? Sure sounds like they work on your rig!

Questions...
So the bellows swells under pressure? Does it ever allow pressure out of the line/bellows?

What type of one way valve or restrictor is used to keep water/crap out of the "open" end?

Wouldn't something that allowed pressure to build in the system -- I have no idea how much pressure the bellows allows to build-neglible but some right? This would not be a good thing because it would promote oil to seep past seals or gaskets, correct?? In a street rig this would be a drawback.

Thanks.

Currently I use clear gasoline filters at the end of each vent line- no contaminates into the line and it allows the gearbox or whatever to breathe...cheeeeep too!
 

pbwcr

Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2007
Messages
652
The bellows is not open to the atmosphere. Its a closed device. You put it on in the relaxed state and it gets bigger as pressure builds and shrinks back as the fluid cools.
The beauty of a bellows is it expands and contracts with negligible pressure buildup. That is how a bellows works.
The drawback is it is more vulnerable to damage than the typical fuel hose.
The advantage is a high mounted catch tank is a lot more trouble to install even though the cost is less.
Reasonably new item with little field testing or use.
The catch tank is more common.
PaulW
===============
I checked out the bellows you are closing out...curious?...how come they are being closed out? Sure sounds like they work on your rig!

Questions...
So the bellows swells under pressure? Does it ever allow pressure out of the line/bellows?

What type of one way valve or restrictor is used to keep water/crap out of the "open" end?

Wouldn't something that allowed pressure to build in the system -- I have no idea how much pressure the bellows allows to build-neglible but some right? This would not be a good thing because it would promote oil to seep past seals or gaskets, correct?? In a street rig this would be a drawback.

Thanks.

Currently I use clear gasoline filters at the end of each vent line- no contaminates into the line and it allows the gearbox or whatever to breathe...cheeeeep too!
 

73azbronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 11, 2007
Messages
8,782
just remember any back pressure you induce in the breather line will force oil out the axle seals, so, you have that going for you...
 

shamu

Lucky as the day is long.
Joined
Jun 18, 2009
Messages
5,290
Loc.
Sachse,Tx
just remember any back pressure you induce in the breather line will force oil out the axle seals, so, you have that going for you...

I have blown up two toilet bowl plungers on my front axle. And no issues on the rear. Front diff has an ARB with a small air leak. It sounds like a 22lr when it gets so much pressure. Jim Creel was a witness on the explosion. Rear diff True HI9 with dinosaur oil and the toilet bowl plunger/bellow no problems.
 

MarkH@Wildhorse

Contributor
Full Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2012
Messages
282
Loc.
Stockton, CA
I checked out the bellows you are closing out...curious?...how come they are being closed out? Sure sounds like they work on your rig!

Questions...
So the bellows swells under pressure? Does it ever allow pressure out of the line/bellows?

What type of one way valve or restrictor is used to keep water/crap out of the "open" end?

Wouldn't something that allowed pressure to build in the system -- I have no idea how much pressure the bellows allows to build-neglible but some right? This would not be a good thing because it would promote oil to seep past seals or gaskets, correct?? In a street rig this would be a drawback.

Thanks.

Currently I use clear gasoline filters at the end of each vent line- no contaminates into the line and it allows the gearbox or whatever to breathe...cheeeeep too!

I believe PBWCR answered most of your questions, but these are not being sold by WildHoses4x4, they are being sold by PSC so I can not tell you why they are closing them out.
I've just always ran these things and will continue to. As Shamu said as well, if you have an ARB with a slight leak, they do pop off as that air needs to go somewhere.
 

ugly74

Bronco abuser
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
2,856
Loc.
Colorado
That bellows is pretty cool.
But im like nvrstuk, and use fuel filters run up into the engine compartment, and afixed so that the "inlet" is pointed down. Im a cheapskate
 

SpareParts

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 13, 2004
Messages
5,595
That bellows is pretty cool.
But im like nvrstuk, and use fuel filters run up into the engine compartment, and afixed so that the "inlet" is pointed down. Im a cheapskate

That's what I do as well.
 

sstclair

Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2007
Messages
399
After I clocked my axle back it started puking too. I went to a toyota bellows and it started forcing oil out the seals when it was working hard. My logic is that a 9 inch has lots more air volume inside than the toy axle. It turns out that my vent line had a droop in it right after it left the axle. Once I straightened that out and the oil didn't have a place to collect then it was fixed. BTW I'm a big fan of running the vents up with a filter too.

-Steve
 
OP
OP
garberz

garberz

Bronco Influencer
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
6,864
Loc.
Conejo Valley, Ca.
I made a small expansion tank from 1 1/2" ABS, about 4" long. It's mounted to the cross member, above the rear end. The vent from the housing feeds into the bottom, another vent comes out of the top of the tank, and is ran up a bit higher. That put an end to this making a mess. Any oil that get puked into the tank will drain back in.

Mark
 
Top