• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

TIG v. MIG

Alpacket

Full Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
241
I hope this is Bronco related enough. I've been using an old (20 years or so) 160 amp MIG for all my metal work. So far, I've used it to replace the floors, inner fenders, kick panels, seat platform, lower quarters and inner and outer rockers on my project. I'm self taught, and I'm doing okay, but I'll admit there's been some splattering, popping, burn throughs and what not. A good friend demonstrated his TIG for me this week, and I was overcome with envy. And I've got a line on one. But they're not cheap. So my question is: Are they worth it? I've still got upper rockers, bed, wheel wells and misc. related panels to go. Thanks.
 

Bferrari

Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
857
They are very worth it in the right hands. If you haven't done alot with a tig, thin sheet metal is not a good place to learn. I have both and am very comfortable with each, however, find myself using the mig the majority of the time with my panel replacement.
 

67 Halfcab

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
251
While allowing more control of the welding arc, GTAW (TIG) puts a higher heat input on the base metal than MIG making it much easier to warp sheet metal. For body panel replacement I would stick with the wire feeder.
 

langester

MASTER OF MADNESS
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
2,681
I am with the others, MIG is your best friend for the work you are doing. MIG is the most versatile for fabricating bumpers, cages and sheet metal work. I too have both, but only use my TIG for stainless and aluminum. If you don't use it a lot its not worth the money IMO.
 

67 Halfcab

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
251
I am with the others, MIG is your best friend for the work you are doing. MIG is the most versatile for fabricating bumpers, cages and sheet metal work. I too have both, but only use my TIG for stainless and aluminum. If you don't use it a lot its not worth the money IMO.



I didn't say don't buy a GTAW machine, I just said stick to GMAW for sheet metal work! ;D
 

Crawdad

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 16, 2011
Messages
3,635
Mig is all you need for fabrication being performed in an everyday garage. I do a lot of welding for the Air Force and 90% of the time it's with Mig. I can adjust our Lincoln down to spot weld thin metal as long as I give some time in between to reduce warping. I can adjust it back up to make a couple of passes on 3/4" mild steel. I use TIG for certifying and for all non-ferrous metals like Al, SS, Co, Ti. TIG is best used when trying to control heat in your part you are welding. Besides, TIG welding is an art that takes years of practice. I'm certified but I still don't consider myself a pro. Mig welding can be done by most garage monkeys. I've seen some Mig welded up rollcages that wouldn't pass a weld cert. Either too much or too lil Amps, too much or too lil wire feed. If you want to improve your welding, see about taking welding classes at your local Tech School. Some offer a 20 hr course for basic welding (MIG and stick), pass that and you can move up to more advance welding such as TIG and heat treating. If you want to keep ur life simple, keep to MIG. Lots of good info from YouTube is out there. TIG is fun but not beneficial for most garage monkeys. Besides, if a TIG doesn't adjust up to 200amps you are really wasting your money.
 

Whoaa

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 26, 2014
Messages
1,059
Same advice from me. A simple wire machine will do everything you're working on right now. And just because your MIG welder is old, doesn't nessesarily mean that it doesn't work well.

I literally have a lifetime of experience welding. I have welded everything from race car frames, trash dumpsters, to space shuttle parts.

TIG welding has its place for certain applications, but for body panels a simple MIG machine is your best friend.
 

Unaweep

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2013
Messages
215
Loc.
Grand Junction CO
Alpacket

I know the envy your speaking of when looking at a TIG setups and the beautiful welds they can produce.



However, MIG is probably what you want to stay with. The reason I'm saying this, if your still having problems with burn through and stop/starts, etc..it will only be worse with TIG. Why? Because essentially the MIG is doing all work, when in TIG you do all the work.


But if you got a good line on that TIG, it might be a good deal, would you let us know what machine your looking at? Some of the smaller TIGs like Lincolns 175 might not be enough machine or too basic for your needs. But they can be a great starter machine too.


Also, perhaps you might consider a newer MIG unit. They weld very differently and have different arc characteristics which we can go over if you want. Perhaps the issues your having are do to an old machine?


Are you using shielding gas with your MIG, either C25 or CO2? Or are you using self shielded wire? That also makes a big difference.


I personally don't care for self shielded wire, but it works in a pinch.


There is also duel shield wire, perhaps some of the best looking welds I have ever scene. AKA - Flux Core Arc Welding. http://www.esabna.com/us/en/products/index.cfm?fuseaction=home.product&productCode=237

Want to make your MIG "look
like TIG?
Check out this thread. http://weldingweb.com/showthread.php?30845-Mig-like-Tig


67 Half Cab wrote:
"While allowing more control of the welding arc, GTAW (TIG) puts a higher heat input on the base metal than MIG making it much easier to warp sheet metal. For body panel replacement I would stick with the wire feeder."

I have to disagree with the first part he stated. TIG doesn't input higher heat unless the operator allows it (either intentional or unintentional). For my initial training I had 1200+ hours of TIG welding and we used to weld up "pop" cans all the time, and I consider myself average in TIG. I couldn't weld that with a off the shelf MIG unit.
I do agree with 67 Half Cab that for most applications a wire feed welder is better for body work.



Without really knowing you and your budget and future ambitions, its hard to know what advise to really give, so I hope these general examples work right now.

J.E.
 

Letsgocrawling

Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2008
Messages
513
Loc.
Tucson Az.
I hope this is Bronco related enough. I've been using an old (20 years or so) 160 amp MIG for all my metal work. So far, I've used it to replace the floors, inner fenders, kick panels, seat platform, lower quarters and inner and outer rockers on my project. I'm self taught, and I'm doing okay, but I'll admit there's been some splattering, popping, burn throughs and what not. A good friend demonstrated his TIG for me this week, and I was overcome with envy. And I've got a line on one. But they're not cheap. So my question is: Are they worth it? I've still got upper rockers, bed, wheel wells and misc. related panels to go. Thanks.

To have both it would be great, generally speaking. If you think you have the time and good resources for help and have patience go for it---both processes can do it all but it takes skill with both, mig is more forgiving with the experience thing but to have both you will steer your own ship with a difference of both kinds of welding ability. From a welders standpoint having both could be a big deal.
 

67 Halfcab

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
251
67 Half Cab wrote:
"While allowing more control of the welding arc, GTAW (TIG) puts a higher heat input on the base metal than MIG making it much easier to warp sheet metal. For body panel replacement I would stick with the wire feeder."

I have to disagree with the first part he stated. TIG doesn't input higher heat unless the operator allows it (either intentional or unintentional). For my initial training I had 1200+ hours of TIG welding and we used to weld up "pop" cans all the time, and I consider myself average in TIG. I couldn't weld that with a off the shelf MIG unit.
I do agree with 67 Half Cab that for most applications a wire feed welder is better for body work.


J.E.

That's because when you were welding pop cans together you were using ac current that balanced the heat input. When welding steel (or most other metals for that matter) with GTAW you use straight polarity (electrode negative, ground positive). This puts 70% of the heat input on the base metal, keeping your tungsten electrode from melting back into your torch.

Now try switching your GTAW leads around to reverse polarity (electrode positive, ground negative) to match how your GMAW machine is set up and see how long your tungsten last. Now 70% of the heat input is on your tungsten electrode as it burns back into your collet body.
 

Unaweep

Full Member
Joined
Sep 11, 2013
Messages
215
Loc.
Grand Junction CO
That's because when you were welding pop cans together you were using ac current that balanced the heat input. When welding steel (or most other metals for that matter) with GTAW you use straight polarity (electrode negative, ground positive). This puts 70% of the heat input on the base metal, keeping your tungsten electrode from melting back into your torch.

Now try switching your GTAW leads around to reverse polarity (electrode positive, ground negative) to match how your GMAW machine is set up and see how long your tungsten last. Now 70% of the heat input is on your tungsten electrode as it burns back into your collet body.

Yes, I know.


J.E.
 

BigBlueBronco71

Full Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2013
Messages
310
Loc.
Santa Maria, CA
As was said mig will be able to do everything you need on the bronco, and tig requires much more skill and hood time, having no experience it would take a long time to become competent to lay down good welds on sheet metal, but if you can find a good deal on a decent tig machine and can spend the money and want to learn by all means go for it, you can never know too much and tig welding is an excellent skill to know
 

pcf_mark

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
3,697
There is a lot of good info in thie thread about the machines and processes. When it comes to automotive panel work the mig is your friend. The most versatile because you can do it upside down, sideways and every goofy ass way you can imagine with little skill. YEARS of tig practice are required to duplicate that! I have mig welded stuff I can even fit my head in to see!

I recently bought an Eastwood tig for stainless and I like it but the production speed and skill are really different.

As someone noted you may have too large a diameter wire and you may have the incorrect shielding gas. These two can impact how low you can go and how well you can weld thin sketchy sheetmetal.
 

rastiss

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
1,264
Loc.
Wichita falls, Texas
Personally I think MIG is the way to go for Sheetmetal on most stuff. As a body technician for 25+ years, MIG is my go 2. MIG is certainly capable of the pretty weldswelds that TIG is known for. Here's some MIG from my bumper build.

IMG_20141122_173551_987_zps007ea966.jpg
 
OP
OP
Alpacket

Alpacket

Full Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
241
Thanks, guys. I'll stop blaming the tool. I'm getting better every day. Thanks for the links, too. Because some asked, I'm using C25 with .023 ER70S-6.
 

pcf_mark

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
3,697
Your wire type and diameter plus the gas are a good combination. You may just need more practice. I blew a half bottle of gas (sort bottle) one weekend practicing.
 

Jeff10

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 20, 2011
Messages
2,182
Loc.
Indianapolis
Hey Guys,

Great thread.

I got a good deal on a Miller Diversion 180 TIG two years ago thinking I would have time to learn. In two years I haven't found the time.

I also have an Ironman 230 that I use occasionally. I'm far from an expert; but, I go okay with a little practice to get up to speed for a project. One reason I thought the TIG would be a good addition is the capability to weld aluminum. (The $500+ that it would cost for a spool gun for the Hobart seemed steep.)

Hoping to have more time this coming year; but, when I read 1200 hours of TIG time by one of the posters I chuckled at thinking I have time to become average.

Good thread.

Jeff
 

67 Halfcab

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
251
Hoping to have more time this coming year; but, when I read 1200 hours of TIG time by one of the posters I chuckled at thinking I have time to become average.

Jeff

If it took someone 1200 hours to become a decent GTAW welder where I work they wouldn't have any GTAW quals. Don't let the training hours someone else has intimidate you. Each person learns at different rates. Enroll in a class at your local Community College or Trade School to get the basics and then practice, practice, practice. Remember, all you are doing is melting metal together!
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
I have found in teaching TIG to others that it is easiest for beginners to start on stainless steel. It doesn't boil as easily, just turns gray when too hot. If you have a lot of Oxy-Fuel welding under your belt then TIG will come more easily. The processes are fairly similar.
I'll echo a previous statement, slightly modified. I'm not certified, but I've been TIG welding for 20+ years and I consider myself to barely not be an apprentice.

As to the "too much heat for sheet metal" statement, that's hogwash. What needs to be considered is the nature of the heat and the resulting weld. In both methods it is a roughly oval shaped cross-section. With MIG that oval is laying on it's side with the pointy ends at or just below the surface of the metal. With TIG it is stood upright with one pointy end buried deep in the metal and the other at or just above the surface. the weldor controls the size of that oval by varying that amps. If he or she puts too much into the work then of course the weld will blow through the backside of the work piece. Saying TIG isn't suitable for sheet metal is like saying the gun, not the person holding it, killed the intruder.
 
Top