• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Can someone school me on MOOG springs

in2broncoz

Full Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2015
Messages
223
Looking to lift my 69 a couple inches to fit 33s (rear fenders cut). Ive seen MOOG springs but know nothing of them...looking for a nice ride and they are close so shipping is cheap compaired to others..

If your running them please tell me about and part numbers

thanks in advance for any and all help ;D
 

jckkys

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 15, 2012
Messages
5,221
Moog and TRW make springs for most anything. Their product lines are essentially identical and use the same part numbers made to the same specs. I've used them on both my '77 and 3 different cars. Unlike most EB parts venders Moog lists the rate, free hieght, installed hieght, load rating, and wire diameter. I use one of the springs made for '78-'79 Broncos. All the coil springs for trucks are called cargo coils and are variable rate. Doing the math you can see that CC 814 gives you a 1 3/4" lift and CC 816 means a 2 1/4" lift over stock EB coils. The increase in rate is 297 lbs/in. over 245 lbs/in. for stock EB coils.
 

grant_71

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 6, 2002
Messages
1,936
FWIW....

When I rebuilt my 71 I used the original leafs in the rear, and brand new TRW springs (stock height) in the front. It sat almost 4-5 inches higher in the rear, and rode like $#!t.

I picked up a set of almost new WH "Rock crawler 2-1/2" lift coils from a member here, and threw on a set of old Rancho 5000 shocks I had in a parrts pile. It leveled the truck out and rides like a dream now.
 

dave67fd

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Messages
2,864
Also FWIW
WH's is located in Lodi not that far from you as far as shipping goes. WH's suspension is known as one of the best which others will mimic. Not sure on the difference in costs to the MOOG's but you will get unsurpassed quality and service from WH's.
Good luck with whomever you choose.
 

Seventee

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2012
Messages
999
Loc.
In the sticks of MT
I've run Moog cargo coils in my 79 for years. The first set sagged, for which I got a replacement set. Now the second set has sagged. :(
 

dave67fd

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 24, 2010
Messages
2,864
Thanks for the help

2.5" front lift should clear 33s uncut ?

Can only speak for what I have heard here but it will depend on tire width, spacing etc.. I think 2.5" will be tough to clear 33's without some rubbing on a LUBR.
Also consider your usage. Mainly street maybe ok, any even mild off-roading maybe an issue.

Consider your full ride height with whatever lift. Full hardtop, aftermarket large bumbers, spare tire, tools, how many passengers do you typically host etc... all these and more will account for your total ride height not to mention any system will sag over time.
 

stout22

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 13, 2006
Messages
3,019
Loc.
Athens, AL
I went with WH 3.5" suspension lift to clear my uncut front fenders with BFG MTs on 8" wide wheels. Still had some fender rub on hard turns when coils got compressed. I later put 4.5" colis up front and no more rubbing. 10" wheels would have also fixed the problem.
 

jckkys

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 15, 2012
Messages
5,221
If you get either the Moog or TRW catalog, you will find all the important specs on coils that fit in all '66-'79 Broncos. They list inside diameter, wire diameter, installed height, load rating, spring rate in lb./in., and free height. With simple math you can figure out what spring you need to get the ride hieght your looking for. I've used these coils in the front and rear of cars and trucks. I've yet to see any change in the ride hieght of any of these vehicles so the "sagging" story is hard to believe. Try to find the specifications of any of the vender's springs. All you get is 2 1/2", 3 1/2", etc. lift. What exactly does that mean? What is the starting point? What's the spring rate? How much will more or less weight change ride hieght? How can specifications be a classified secret? They're springs, not missile guidance systems.
 

ransil

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 6, 2003
Messages
8,138
They will be too stiff, buy from a bronco vendor and buy a Bronco specific lift.
do not buy lifts with names like super lift, Rancho .
 

jckkys

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 15, 2012
Messages
5,221
Ransil, can you quantify how you define too stiff? Can you tell us what is not too stiff? I don't believe you've ever owned or driven a Bronco that was equipped with Moog or TRW springs.With no specifics of any kind, your generalized comment that springs of known specs are too stiff is not persuasive. Can springs be too soft? You imply that springs from a "Bronco vender" are just right. Are they all the same? Is there one manufacturer that supplies the same springs for all the "Bronco venders"? Do the so called "Bronco venders" offer different springs that are all miraculously still, just right? How can anyone make an informed decision with no information?
 

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
I have had Moog coils before. They were alright, nothing to write home about.

Our eb vendors have coils with spring rates that people seem to really like.

Our friend above that is directing you to the vendors is just trying to help.
Your safer bet is with our eb vendors.

Then the question becomes linear rate coils ie,..JBG & BC.
Or
Variable/Progressive rate coils.

I ran the pro/variable rate springs for 20+ years.
For the last 3 years I have been running linear rate coils. I like them. I like the consistent deflection. The pro/variables could articulate really well, but not so good at washboard or hard 4 wheeling.

The linear coils aren't quite as soft but hold up better to rough trail off road.
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,213
Coil spring ride quality can be very subjective because people have different ideas on what is 'comfortable' and 'rough'. And factor in variables like shock valving, tire size, tire construction, tire pressure, vehicle weight, desired ride frequency and other variables and it can become quite the interesting exercise.

I've probably played around with Bronco coil springs as much as anyone over the years - I'm the geeky engineer with a calculator and a pair of calipers that loves to calculate spring rates and evaluate ride quality. A few general rules of thumb from over the years:

1. Ransil's correct that Superlift and Rancho have generally been far too stiff for EBs. The Rancho coils are 485 lb/in. and you don't have to be too sophisticated to know that rate will rattle your fillings.
2. I would say most of the Bronco vendors' offerings are pretty good in terms of matching the correct spring rates/ride quality for our trucks. Are they all the same? No. Are they close enough that the average driver wouldn't notice much of a difference if they were swapped onto the same truck? Probably. The Deaver coils (I believe those are sold by JBG) are on the low end of the spring rate scale and BC's are probably on the high end (going from memory here).
3. Is there a rate that's too low? Perhaps. I don't think I'd want to go below 180 lb/in based on some testing with some springs I designed and sold late in the last century.
4. I haven't run the particular Moog coils mentioned in the thread above. I did run the CC812 coils from 85/86-'95? with the 245 lb/in rate and I thought they were great. Another 50 lb/in is probably within the bandwidth of comfort for most of us. At the very least, coils are cheap - try a set and if you don't like them, swap them out and try another set.

I will say that I like the lift amount on the Moogs mentioned. I wish we had more options in the 1-2" lift height range.

Todd Z.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,622
If you get either the Moog or TRW catalog, you will find all the important specs on coils that fit in all '66-'79 Broncos. They list inside diameter, wire diameter, installed height, load rating, spring rate in lb./in., and free height. With simple math you can figure out what spring you need to get the ride hieght your looking for. I've used these coils in the front and rear of cars and trucks. I've yet to see any change in the ride hieght of any of these vehicles so the "sagging" story is hard to believe.

Spring sag is a perfectly normal occurrence. It can happen no matter what brand. Lots of variables at work, but sag is just another simple fact of life. Glad you've never had it, but it's hard to believe you've never heard of it.
I've used Cargo Coils too, and for a short time we even sold them at WH.
All springs of any type are susceptible to sag. Some will, some won't, but it's all due to whatever circumstances you care to mention. My first set of Moog CC's did sag. Not a ton, and not right away. I used them very happily for a few years. These were only about 1.75" of lift, so when I lost over 1/2" I needed to get it back up and so changed the coils. But I considered that performance very acceptable.
The application of the ones I used were early F100 with 6-cylinder (I forget the part number). Since I was not looking for a tall lift they were perfect. Tried those same springs in a '78 Bronco once, and they lowered the truck almost to the bumpstops.

Same rules apply for our springs as any other vendor. My WH Rock Crawler set is over 20 years old now, and has settled "maybe" less than a 1/2". But at 3.5" of lift I'm not as worried about that quarter to half inch as I was with the shorter springs. Other customers have had varied results to report in that same time. Some of ours have sagged out over the years. But many more have not. Again, your results may vary.

As I've said before, no matter who makes them, all springs are still as much art as science. Metals differ per batch even when they're not supposed to. Probably other variables as well. I'm just happy that the various manufacturers can make them as good and as consistent as they do and that ours work as well and last as long as they do.


Try to find the specifications of any of the vender's springs. All you get is 2 1/2", 3 1/2", etc. lift. What exactly does that mean? What is the starting point? What's the spring rate? How much will more or less weight change ride hieght? How can specifications be a classified secret? They're springs, not missile guidance systems.

Why are you trying to put a negative spin on what is perfectly normal behavior?
And if they're so perfect, why doesn't Moog list the exact lift height for each vehicle that their springs could possibly fit then? That way you wouldn't have to look up the specs and make your own decision based on what you "think" might work best for you.
We and some of the other Bronco vendors have posted up our specifications many times here on the forums, as have our customers when they've had a chance. One thread even had a full chart.
They're not a complete secret, but for very good reasons neither are they generally advertised. As a good business practice we like them to remain ours for as long as possible. Anytime a business (the key word here) comes up with something new on their own that took time and effort (equals money) that you think is going to work better for your customers than similar products on the market, it's just standard practice to keep it under the radar as much as possible.
When you're talking about "stock" replacements like you're discussing with the Cargo Coils however, there is no secret right up front. They're using data that's purposely made public for just that reason. So the aftermarket can re-supply the public with replacement parts that are either up to, or better than the original stuff that the O.E.s no longer want to have in their system.
It's a completely different concept.

Our stock height replacements have an initial rate of 200 lbs, and a secondary rate of 300 lbs
The 2.5" coils have an initial rate of 200 and a secondary rate of 375.
If you need to know how many coils, what wire diameter and coil diameter, along with free and installed height, I have that info too. It's not a secret, I just didn't want to type it all up and most could not care less. As long as it lifts their Bronco close to the height that they expect, and they get the street ride and off-road flex that we claim, that other info is just something else to stuff into the noggin' and then forget.

Enquiring minds like ours need to know that stuff to keep us happy of course, but in the grand scheme of things, it's not always pertinent to everyone. So even after all these years and public discussions, it's still not likely to clutter up our catalog any time soon.

But any time any of you would like to know, just ask.

Paul
 
Last edited:

TX SS

Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
796
Loc.
Houston
On my mostly stock Bronco I'm running Moog CC810 springs and am very happy with them. The springs gave me a lift/level of 1" over stock height which is what I wanted. I have them paired with a set of Bilstein shocks from Wild Horses.

Before:
IMG_3636_zps94887fcf.jpg


After:
IMG_4047_zps3af4647a.jpg
 

jckkys

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 15, 2012
Messages
5,221
To clarify, I correctly stated that I haven't experienced any spring sag with TRW/Moog springs. To make that statement I obviously know what it is. I also experimented with Rancho coils. I think they were "Bronco venders" in the early 80s. Those things came out in days. I don't think they offered any specs either. I may have saved what turned out to be a waste of money. I also tried the CC812 coils that are described as heavy duty. These were nearly identicle to the OE 4900 GVW coils. Both tended to bottom out on any big bump or dip. The CC814 gave me a predictable 1 3/4" higher ride hieght and 297 lb/in rate. These eliminated the bottoming and brought the front closer to the slightly higher rear stance I wanted. What coil offered by the "Bronco venders" would do that? The combination of free length, installed hieght, rate, and load specs made the 1 3/4" predictable. With no specs, that's impossible.
My major rub with Ransil's post was the purely gratuitous assertion that the springs I suggested were too stiff. With no context or specifics, it was just a mindless generality. The OE 4900 GVW rear springs seem to be about 300 lbs/in. The package is firm but handles well with front and rear sway bars. My definition of too stiff is a CJ5 or FJ40.
 

Seventee

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2012
Messages
999
Loc.
In the sticks of MT
Pic for those that don't believe me. Anyone care to guess what the sag or spring rate is with these?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20150722_182632099.jpg
    IMG_20150722_182632099.jpg
    87.6 KB · Views: 141

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,213
Pic for those that don't believe me. Anyone care to guess what the sag or spring rate is with these?

They're variable rate but otherwise it's hard to guess. I wouldn't necessarily say they're sagging either.

Todd Z.
 

ransil

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 6, 2003
Messages
8,138
Ransil, can you quantify how you define too stiff? Can you tell us what is not too stiff? I don't believe you've ever owned or driven a Bronco that was equipped with Moog or TRW springs.With no specifics of any kind, your generalized comment that springs of known specs are too stiff is not persuasive. Can springs be too soft? You imply that springs from a "Bronco vender" are just right. Are they all the same? Is there one manufacturer that supplies the same springs for all the "Bronco venders"? Do the so called "Bronco venders" offer different springs that are all miraculously still, just right? How can anyone make an informed decision with no information?
thats a lot o questions. ;D
Being a cheap ass I have tried many of the spring I mentioned, in the end it was not so cheap. I got no data to support my findings except for they were too stiff. in the end I have found the modern springs produce by the vendors work very well for the price. Way back Cody H did a comparison with a bunch of different spring.
 
Top