• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Front locker question/advice

broncbuster

Sr. Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
414
I'd like to get some input from people who have experience with a detroit locker in the front. This is not a daily driven bronco. I have a detroit in the back, 4.56 gears, 35s. It's time to lock the front. This is kind of an all around bronco. Very straight body so my rock crawling is moderate because I'm not willing to give it rock rash. It gets run in very loose deep sand a few times a year, moderate stuff at Moab once a year or so, Moderate stuff at Brown's camp once a year or so. Off road snow a few times a year, snow on road very rarely. It gets driven on the street about 1/4 of the time, but I guess that doesn't matter because obviously it's 2 hi and hubs unlocked on the street. It gets trailered if I'm going more than about 30 miles to the trail head. I really don't want to go ARB, I don't want to spend that much and some friends have had reliability problems from air lines and/or internal air leaks, so I'm kind of against that. I've already got cromo axles from Wild Horses that have the larger spicer u-joints that will be going in at the same time. So basically I'm debating between a detroit vs a tru-trac or maybe something else that's high traction and tough. I guess the detroit will perform better, than a tru-trac but not sure about the down side it may have in the front. I guess these axles I got a deal on aren't the best, but better than stock, So maybe a detroit won't tear them up. I'll be going to a twin stick so I can shift out of 4 low as needed. Thoughts, experience and advice appreciated.
 

sprdv1

Contributor
REBEL
Joined
Mar 8, 2007
Messages
81,996
Think you'll be alright w/the Detroit.. When you have the selectable hub, unlocked and on street should be good..

I get most of my chirping on the street from the rear w/the damn mini spool.. lol But it's funny seeing some people's looks

Lots of others here that can share their experience as well

Look at Grizzly locker as well
 

Nevadasmith

Full Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2016
Messages
182
Loc.
Fallon, Nv
I have a tru-trac in the front, and a locrite in the back... I absolutely love the tru-trac in sand, snow and ice.....and especially on tight technical trails....I don't do hard core rocks, but I do wheel it often...most of my Wheeling buddy's have lockers in the front and I keep up just fine... I've spent hours of my life waiting/helping fix, electrical/air line issues on the trail from Elockers /air lockers.....no experience with cable lockers.

It's smooth as glass, can barely feel through the steering wheel....no popping no binding, and it is way less prone to the off camber down hill slide, like lockers and possi diffs. To be fair I've never run a Detroit locker in the front, but over the years I've run welded, clutch style possi, locrite lockers and hands down the tru-trac is my favorite!!!!!!

The only bad thing I can think of, about the tru-trac, and it doesn't bother me, if you break an axle there is not enough bias to help it lock so it's basically an open diff with a broken axle...... I have never broken an axle with the tru-trac!!!
Yes if one front tire is completely off the ground it behaves like an open diff....but with a light touch of the brakes I can get it to lock back up, and with the locrite in the back it has never been an issue!!!!
Good luck!!!!

.
 

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
Detroit locker rear
Detroit Tru-Trac up front.

Many years now.
Very happy.
 

904Bronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Messages
6,720
Loc.
San Martin, CA
Detroit locker in the front tends to want to go straight when you are on the gas...
That was with 4:56, 31 x 10.50 sized tires, Explorer motor, 4R70W, and D20
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,622
Loc.
PNW
904Bronco is right...straight is where you're going to go unless you spin the front end so you can turn either direction... this gets spooky on an off-camber trail.

Air lockers are SO much more dependable than a Detroit. Seriously, if a SHOP or a GUY can't run a freakin' air line so it won't melt or leave enough slack in it so the axle can move OR not have it rub against something to wear a hole in it then they should NOT be trusted to work on a car/truck... treat it like a fuel line...hold it, guys screw those installations up also! lol

anyway...

I've never been on a trail ride where an ARB failed...not once. I wheel a lot...

I've wheeled at least a 1/2 dozen times when a Detroit has grenaded because the axle or ujoint failed. This is very common with a Detroit. Better run RCV's up front or you will be buying a new Detroit- don't think this isn't common because it is.

I'm not saying buy an ARB... buy what you need/want. I've run ARB's since Feb '87...same seals, same air lines, ZERO problems with it... none.

I've run an ARB in the rear since ARB finally perfect the 31 spline 9" unit in '95. After grenading another 9" Daytona bearing support, then I upgraded to a 35 spline. The only issue I had was with the strongest unit, tje RD99. I literally twisted the case in half on a 6K shift into second on pavement...oops. I do have some hp.

Other than that, all 3 have been flawless... have both wheels locked when I want it, open when I need it on a side hill or street... your call... but don't let anybody tell you they aren't reliable... they are super reliable but you can't have a shadetree mechanic not install it properly. I know of 2 that have the inner seal fail, but 99% of the time that is an install issue or production issue. Not common but I've seen it.

TruTrac's are great up front.

Good luck, go wheeling!!
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
No Detroit in the front.
Nothing wrong with a properly installed ARB.
But what you describe, tru-trac.
 

JSBX

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2010
Messages
652
I have been running an Eaton E-Locker in the front of mine for 8 years with no problems. No real hard core stuff but hard enough trails to get some body damage.
 

gnpenning

Contributor
Bronco Slave
Joined
Dec 26, 2011
Messages
2,601
Loc.
I have more questions than answers.
Having owned a full locked vehicle and experiencing the fun of trying to turn it soft stuff and a side hill that required unlocking a hub. I would never again have a full locker that wasn't selectable in the front.

My 74 I did the tru trac front and Detroit rear back in the early 90's. It's a great combination and very reliable. Back in those days I did a bunch of Moab trails with no problems. Still have the same set up. Solid.
 

bmc69

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
12,015
I have not and will not run anything the front but the 100% reliable ARBs I've had in all of my rigs, past and present. Not a single problem with any of them in over 15 years of wheeling.

As others have noted, a nonselectable locker in front is hateful on tight trails.

I run Truetracs in the rear on a couple rigs...great ls
 

RADO

Jr. Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2016
Messages
138
Loc.
Phoenix
I have the Detroit rear / tru-trac front setup. It works fine, but will leave you wanting a bit more traction up front on the more challenging stuff. I'm going to swap it out for an ARB or OX locker this summer. I like OX lockers because you don't need to set-up on board air and can use their cable/lever instead.

I suggest you go for a select-able locker too (ARB, OX, E-locker), because you never know when you might need a little extra traction and will still have the ability to open the diff when you don't need it.
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,622
Loc.
PNW
Point to consider...IF you wheel you need air for your tires.... i always hear comments about "...if you buy an ARB you then need OBA -on board air)...

Of course you do! IF you wheel you need OBA...
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
A tru-trac can be tricked into locking up pretty solid by riding the brake a little. Puts a load on the gears and the amount of lock is based on the load on the diff. For that one time you have gone further then you wanted to and need the one front tire to pull while the other is in the air and the locked rear isn't enough. At that point you are probably at the point of body damage anyway, which is further then you describe you want to take it.
 

RADO

Jr. Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2016
Messages
138
Loc.
Phoenix
i always hear comments about "...if you buy an ARB you then need OBA -on board air)...

Of course you do! IF you wheel you need OBA...

Sure, but if you wheel, I'd argue you're better off with a CO2 tank. It's no fun waiting 30 minutes after you finish a trail for your compressor to fill your tires... :p
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,622
Loc.
PNW
Buy a better compressor! :) I've been using an alum case York since about '98. Built a bra ket to mount it above my PSC p/s pump with the Exploder serp...appr 8.6 cfm

Even the new ARB compressor is rated over 6cfm...

Besides, somebody in the group (it's not a race) will be using some $30 special and you will be waiting for them anyway! lol

Space is always at a premium in a Bronco- a PowerTank or equiv uses space that most of us need unless its a one day trip. Many of us go overnight or do trails like the Rubicon where ever cubby hole is stuffed with tents, tarps, ice chest, tools, you name it... just saying... either way...we still need air!
 
Last edited:

RADO

Jr. Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2016
Messages
138
Loc.
Phoenix
You're telling me my portable harbor freight compressor isn't the best option to fill 35" tires!? OBA with a York compressor is a great setup... I had one on another rig and was amazed with how well it worked!

I don't disagree with you, I'm just suggesting an alternative to building an OBA setup would be an OX/E-locker with CO2 for tires. I've gotten lazy with some of these projects recently, which is how I ended up with a powertank. ;D
 

Boss Hugg

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 8, 2010
Messages
2,213
I believe I'd do a Spartan before going to a Detroit. You save the cost of setting up the gears again. Once the axles are out, it took me about an hour to be ready to put them back in.

BUT if I were to do something in the front again, I'd go electric locker. They run them in jeeps enough for me to believe they are good enough for 35's. And then the cost difference between the E-locker and ARB will buy a good on board air compressor (if you need it.)
 

Nothing Special

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2016
Messages
848
I had a LockRight (basically the same operation as a Detroit) in the front of an F-150 for one winter.

Driving on snow covered freeways (which you said you do very rarely)? You have to leave it in 2WD with an auto locker in the front. SCARY dangerous when you hit snow with a front tire while you're on the gas. Even with a full-size truck it jumped 10 feet to the left before I caught it. It'd be worse in a smaller vehicle like a Bronco.

At low speed I found the front auto locker to be very annoying, but possibly worth it. If you aren't going straight (or if you lose traction on one tire) you get a TON of torque steer. If you need / value the performance of a full locker it's probably worth it. But you will be paying a price in driveability for that performance.

On my Bronco I just opted for an OX in the front to complement the rear Detroit. To me that seemed like a good compromise between driveability and locker performance. But I do expect it to be a little annoying too, as I need to switch it on and off when I need traction or need to steer.

For what you are talking about, I'd go with a TrueTrac. Not the absolutely positive performance of a locker, but still pretty darn good. And nowhere near the downsides.

Alternative perspective: I have been told that an auto locker in the front with an open rear diff has nowhere near the bad manners that front and rear auto lockers have (my F-150 had a LockRight in the rear too). That school of thought says that the best performance, still with good driveability, is an auto locker in the front and a selectable in the rear. I'd like to try that sometime, but until I do I'll keep advising against front auto lockers except for people who are willing to pay the price in driveablity for the performance.
 
Top