• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

I am not a Battery Guy

Comemonday71

Jr. Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2019
Messages
138
Hey gang!
So I brought my ’71 to my local cars and coffee this morning and had a nice conversation with another Bronco brother. I had my hood up and he made a comment that I should not be using a yellow top optima battery for daily use as it is a “deep cycle” battery. Also mentioned that I could damage the battery if I drive her often. Said I would be better off using the red top optima instead. I am not a battery guy so is he correct? I do not drive my Bronco every day probably 3-4 times a week max. Thanks!
 

68ford

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 26, 2004
Messages
2,710
Simplest way to put it. He is wrong. Yellow top is fine to run daily.
 

chuckji

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
May 5, 2017
Messages
471
Loc.
SE Michigan
Yep, dude is misinformed. You’ll be fine.
BTW, the main purpose of the battery is to start the car. Once running, the alternator acts as the main source of power.
 

SteveL

Huge chevy guy
Joined
Jun 24, 2001
Messages
11,969
Loc.
Hawthorne ca
Correct me if I'm wrong but from what I remember the red tops are for higher cranking amps for a beefy cam or tough to start motor. The yellow top is deep cycle for longer duration of power as in winching, welders, high amp stereos ...
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
Actually it isn't the color of the top, it is the color of the case. Dark gray is a starting battery, light gray is a deep cycle. The top color is for the post design (regular posts, studs, both). So he is wrong on that account as well.

A deep cycle battery will work as a starting battery just fine. Although it is more optimized for discharge/recharge cycles than for brute cranking amps, it is still a good battery. When it is -38° and it is borderline if the engine will start or not, a starting battery holds a slight advantage over a deep cycle. A starting battery of exactly the same condition might reach its limits at -40° instead. You pretty much need lab conditions to tell the difference. and after the battery is aged a little, it is all meaningless.
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
Yes, it's the other way around. You wouldn't want to use an automotive battery for coach power on an RV, or for running an electric trolling motor. Battery labels can be confusing. There are batteries labeled RV/Marine. Those aren't deep cycle, even though they have a stud post on top. A real deep cycle battery is considerably heavier. You'll realize the difference when you pick one up.
 

Rusty_S85

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
120
Optima also has a marine version. Is it labeled blue top?

Yes, Optima`s marine battery are blue tops.

Red tops are typically cranking batteries as every side post and top post cranking optima Ive installed at work had a red top.

Yellow tops every one ive seen said deep cycle on the side.

As far as using a deep cycle or a cranking battery, you can use either one in a vehicle application, its just one is better at cranking than the other.

But in the end optima`s from my personal experience are junk. They take excessively long to recharge and after they go dead once and you recharge them they don't seem to hold a charge for that long.

But I personally am still going to try the gel cell reproduction power punch battery for my '56 as the regular 29N batteries I get, you get 1 year out of them and after that they wont hold a charge for more than a day. Can even disconnect the battery and one day and they are dead again.
 

Rusty_S85

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
120
Yes, it's the other way around. You wouldn't want to use an automotive battery for coach power on an RV, or for running an electric trolling motor. Battery labels can be confusing. There are batteries labeled RV/Marine. Those aren't deep cycle, even though they have a stud post on top. A real deep cycle battery is considerably heavier. You'll realize the difference when you pick one up.

I think the optima deep cycles are not designed to be a true deep cycle but to be capable of being drained multiple times as a auxiliary battery. I know the red top starting optima`s we hate them at work as they go dead once they basically are ruined. Even with a optima brand charger that slowly charges them they still wont hold a charge.
 
OP
OP
Comemonday71

Comemonday71

Jr. Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2019
Messages
138
Hey Guys!
Thanks for the input; I have enjoyed reading all the comments. So I went out popped the hood and took a look at my yellow Optima and there is a sticker on it that clearly states the batter is a “deep cycle and starter battery.” So like Rusty_S85 mentioned maybe this type of batter is not truly a deep cycle battery after all. I have a 347 stoker with a roller Comp Cam (part #35-410-8) camshaft. I have not had any issues with turning her over even during heat soak. I think I will keep things as they are and just hope the optima doesn’t die on me with no warning like some of you guys have mentioned. This is such a great forum!
 

Rusty_S85

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
120
Hey Guys!
Thanks for the input; I have enjoyed reading all the comments. So I went out popped the hood and took a look at my yellow Optima and there is a sticker on it that clearly states the batter is a “deep cycle and starter battery.” So like Rusty_S85 mentioned maybe this type of batter is not truly a deep cycle battery after all. I have a 347 stoker with a roller Comp Cam (part #35-410-8) camshaft. I have not had any issues with turning her over even during heat soak. I think I will keep things as they are and just hope the optima doesn’t die on me with no warning like some of you guys have mentioned. This is such a great forum!

Yep, Ive been seeing a lot of yellow tops at work lately, seems like people are moving away from the red tops. I haven't seen a yellow top have a issue the only ones that give us issues at work seem to be the red tops. You can drive the vehicle in park it two days later go to start it up to work on it and find the optima is just dead. Or my favorite spend 2 weeks trying to figure out why the thing is so hard to start and floods out with FITech only to find out the red top battery was losing too much voltage during cranking due to it just being a bad battery.

The blue tops I don't think I ever heard anything bad about them. I keep telling my boss to run the blue top in his jet boat but he keeps running the redtop.
 

Glass Pony

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
1,954
Loc.
Sussex County Delaware
The blue tops I don't think I ever heard anything bad about them. I keep telling my boss to run the blue top in his jet boat but he keeps running the redtop.
The blue top is a marine starting battery and I agree with you on your other post that Optimas are a piece of crap. I had one in my boat and didn't last 1 season.:mad: I get at least 6 years out of Dekas.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
The yellow top is working for you. Keep using it.
But as others have mentioned there are better batteries. Consider those for a future replacement unless you have an Optima specific battery hold down.

My daily driver is known for eating batteries every 2 year. That is just how it is. AZ heat is hard on them. I put in an Oddessey battery and almost 8 years later I got a slightly slow crank one winter morning. Went ahead and replaced it as a preventative measure. Another battery was in my boat for 8 years as well. Replaced that one as preventative as well. I still have that one in the garages as a kick a round battery. easy power source for testing electrical stuff. My latest battery of choice is NorthStar. USA made in Springfield, Mo. Has the start in telecommunications backup batteries and branched into the auto battery a few years back. I have two of them that feel very much like an Oddessey. They are a couple of years into my test and are working perfect so far.
 

73azbronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 11, 2007
Messages
8,782
Best long lasting battery in AZ heat, fords own version of AGM heavy duty MAX battery. Have one in a daily driver going on three years plus now, 100 month guarantee. My other fav is the Auto Zone platinum highest costing AGM with 3 year guarantee, when it dies at 2 years, they all do, I get another for free to last another two years.
 

SteveL

Huge chevy guy
Joined
Jun 24, 2001
Messages
11,969
Loc.
Hawthorne ca
The blue top is a marine starting battery and I agree with you on your other post that Optimas are a piece of crap. I had one in my boat and didn't last 1 season.:mad: I get at least 6 years out of Dekas.

Starting to wonder about the optimas. I had good luck with emin tha past. My broncos sit for periods of time when doing upgrades. I have noticed in the last 5 years or so they seem to take a crap if they sit. This is with the red tops. They is an odyssey dealer at the hot rod swap meet we hit every month. Thinking maybe go that route next time.
 

Rusty_S85

Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2019
Messages
120
The blue top is a marine starting battery and I agree with you on your other post that Optimas are a piece of crap. I had one in my boat and didn't last 1 season.:mad: I get at least 6 years out of Dekas.

Yep and that is what my boss should be using in his jet boat. He doesn't so now he got a 24V alternator I believe he said it is and hes going to install a 24V battery so he doesn't have slow cranking.

I agree there are better batteries. The battery that works great for me is Diehard Golds. I get 7 to 9 years out of a battery before I have to replace them.

I tried Duracell as that was one option for a group 29N for my 56 Ford. battery lasted 2 years then wouldn't hold a charge more than a few days. I then switched to Napa Commercial as that is the only one I can get locally now in a group 29N and that battery lasts 1 year where you can let the car sit 1 week to 2 weeks and it will start the car. After 1 year you get about 2 or 3 days before the battery is dead again. Ive replaced this battery numerous times under warranty.

Napa is now trying to get out of the deal but I told them to get better batteries. They tell me I have a drain. Yeah what drain do I have on my old Ford, the clock is unplugged as I need to remove it and service it so I didn't want to burn up the points in it. The radio doesn't work it needs to be recapped so I have it unplugged. Plus if it was a drain it wouldn't be capable of sitting 1 to 2 weeks without going dead but then after 1 year of age it wont hold a charge then.

Only other option I personally have left is the 1000 cranking amp gel cell battery that is a reproduction of the old ford power punch battery. Im wary of it as I just cant justify spending $500 for a battery that might act the same way of what I get now for $80.
 

Bronco4x4

Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2009
Messages
621
I have 9 years in my EB with a Sears Platinum AGM battery. I do use a battery cut off switch on all my classic vehicles to eliminate any drain. It’s a piece of mind with >50 year old electrical systems. This is a nice day/show EB so it’s not a daily driver. I brought up in another post that Optimas can be brought back from being dead by charging with a good battery hooked up in parallel. Of course, if things spark big when connected this way, do not continue (may have internal issue).
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Luckily I've never had the bad experiences of others with Optima. Just got rid of my last Red Top only because I sold the car it was in.
Just over 9-years old according to the date code and still cranking. The new owner is still using it though it might not be long for this world as he drained the battery doing something or other. Re-charged it and so far it's working, but we'll see. That's awful old to ask a battery to come back fully from a discharge.

If they still have the same practice, the Blue Top batteries are available in both Deep-Cycle and Starting styles. The top connections are the same "marine" standard stuff, and they rated them in MCA (marine cranking amps tested at 32°f) instead of CCA (cold cranking amps tested at 0°f) so the numbers look higher on the label but are identical in use to the Red and Yellow tops. So the guts can be had either way and you can tell by the label or the case color as was mentioned earlier.

Unfortunately I killed two Blue Tops with neglect. Bought then before I really needed them because it was a good deal, then let them sit. I checked them at 2 years and they still had almost a full charge. Put them on a charger at 3 years just because I thought I should, but then let them sit unattended for the next 7 years. One was DOA and the other recovered mostly, so I still have that one. But at this point it'll never be a main battery because I won't trust it. Almost $400 down the tubes because of that "good deal" I got!
But that's 100% my fault right from the beginning purchase to the neglect.
Other batteries may not have fared even that well.

According to their info, even Optima starting batteries have higher deep-cycle capacities than a standard flooded cell lead-acid battery does anyway. So your deep-cycle Yellow Top is able to handle discharging better better still. In theory anyway.
Which is likely why their own version of a deep-cycle does not have to stray too far from the "starting" capabilities of a regular battery like many old time deep-cycle types used to. Where an old deep-cycle may have had slightly more RA (reserve capacity) they often had much fewer cold cranking amps.
The DC version of an Optima may have lower CCA ratings than the starting version too, but only just, at 800cca vs 700cca I think? Which is still adequate for up to a 350-ish cubic inch engine.
Standard recommendation from the manufacturers is to at the very least double your cubic inches when choosing cold cranking amps. Hence the 800cca being recommended for up to 400ci engines.
But it's just a general rule of thumb and not etched in stone.

So like the others have said, if yours is working then save your money and keep it. If it shows any signs of weakness that's not related to your Bronco's charging system not working (an unfortunately all too common occurrence too!), get something new.
For me I'd still use an Optima if the opportunity arose. But I've got a relatively new (4 years or so?) Odyssey and other new batteries that came with vehicles and are still good

Good luck with yours!

Paul
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
I have 9 years in my EB with a Sears Platinum AGM battery. I do use a battery cut off switch on all my classic vehicles to eliminate any drain. It’s a piece of mind with >50 year old electrical systems. This is a nice day/show EB so it’s not a daily driver. I brought up in another post that Optimas can be brought back from being dead by charging with a good battery hooked up in parallel. Of course, if things spark big when connected this way, do not continue (may have internal issue).

That vintage, should be a rebadged Oddessey battery. Since then Sears has changed suppliers and mostly closed everything. But that older DieHard Platinum is a great battery. The new ones, if you can find a Sears, are not the same.
 

Bronco4x4

Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2009
Messages
621
Thanks for the info. Do you where to get an Oddessey battery? Would like to get one if my Diehard Platinum goes or for another vehicle.
 
Top