• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Help! I'm overthinking tire sizes!

NickMcAFP

Contributor
Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2021
Messages
83
Loc.
Sturbridge
I'm in a mental death spiral over tire sizing. Over the past year I've really come to terms with what I want vs what I need out of my build and it is causing me to question the automatic tire choice I made at the beginning of this journey.

Quick overview: My father passed a year ago and left me his 1975 bronco. It needed EVERYTHING so I sent it to a friend I trust to be completely rebuilt. I haven't had the luxury of being able to experience it and upgrade it over time. I just have to make up my mind and hope I'm right.

On day one I decided on 33s with the words of my father still echoing in my head that that is the perfect size tire for an Early Bronco. He had been telling me this since I was like 6 years old. He also really enjoyed offroading so there was a practical reason for the 33s. I DO really like the way they look.

The issue: I want this to be a daily driver (more or less). I can't help but wonder if I would enjoy actually driving it more with more road friendly tires. 31X10.50s look good. They aren't as exciting but they look fine. 32s also look fine..

I have another car at my disposal all the time so I never HAVE to drive the Bronco but why the heck wouldn't I drive it if I had the option???

The quarters are the Dennis Carpenter quarters and there's going to be a 2.5 inch suspension lift. Mostly stock, cleaned up, factory 302. Factory carb. Wide ratio 4 Speed top loader. I'd be gearing the axles to suit whatever tires I land on.

Thank you in advance! This is actually keeping me up at night.
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,607
Loc.
Fremont, CA
Your dad was right. An Early Bronco lifted 2.5 with Carpenter quarters should be on 33's.

The proportions are right, and the tires fit, and it will be very capable off road.

I'm running 35's, but I'm 3.5 lift with a 2 inch BL. I'm not saying that 33's would be perfect...but they actually are.

If you want road friendly, get the BFG All Terrain KO and 17 inch wheels. And listen to your father...he's not wrong.
 

Attachments

  • 8BD07FF0-D794-498F-B4C6-85794C5F50BA.jpeg
    8BD07FF0-D794-498F-B4C6-85794C5F50BA.jpeg
    271.2 KB · Views: 108

TDubya

Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2009
Messages
381
Loc.
Fortuna, CA
I also agree with 33s on a Bronco with your lift. I'm running 33x10.50r15 BFG KM2s and think they are a good fit for on and off road. Also, if you're running the C4 4.11 gears work well with that size tire.
 

Rustytruck

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
10,872
wide 33" for off road for a street compromise narrow the 33" providing you have 4.11 gearing for either one. if you only have 5.50 gearing stop at 31 you can go 35 but you need more lift and deeper gearing too.
 

amfw

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2008
Messages
522
im gonna pile on with everyone else here and say that I also say that your dad was right. 33 is the ideal tire size for your setup. Im on 35s myself, but that is only because they are in good shape and they came with the bronco. Every time I see Bronco on 33s I get jealous.
 

BGBronco

Contributor
N A S H V I L L E
Joined
Jun 23, 2017
Messages
1,622
Loc.
Tennessee
I have 33/12.5/15s and a 1.5" Lift. If I changed it up, I would go to 17s and stick with something close to 33
 

Yeller

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
7,692
Loc.
Rogers County Oklahoma
if your concerned about streetability of 33's go to a 17" wheel and run 285/70-17 tires in a mild all terrain, BFG KO3, Cooper AT3, ect. It will drive great and you won't suffer any ill street manners, as stated proper axle gearing is critical to get the best results. I have a truck with 33x12.50-15, I was going to go the 17" wheel route but have no regrets with the 15" route I went, and it saved me over $1000 in cost of tires and wheels.
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,607
Loc.
Fremont, CA
if your concerned about streetability of 33's go to a 17" wheel and run 285/70-17 tires in a mild all terrain, BFG KO3, Cooper AT3, ect. It will drive great and you won't suffer any ill street manners, as stated proper axle gearing is critical to get the best results. I have a truck with 33x12.50-15, I was going to go the 17" wheel route but have no regrets with the 15" route I went, and it saved me over $1000 in cost of tires and wheels.
Have you run the Cooper AT3's?

I had a 1/2 set of Cooper AT2's for a few years. Centering force and vagueness on center were problematic. I was forced to rotate them to the back of my truck to restore the handling. After 40,000 miles, and 4 years, my AT2's developed tread bulge and ultimately carcass failure. Somehow the wear indicator measured only at 50%, so I received a cash reimbursement of half of the cost of a NEW tire. Turns out that new tires are a lot more expensive than my old ones. So I got something like $160 each.

Happy with the customer service, but not happy with the performance. Also not happy that when I needed a single tire, I was forced to buy two, but when I went to warranty the tire...they only wanted to replace the one??? Also not happy with the straight line highway manners. The BFG KO2 tread design is much more streetable, with sharper response. This was 285/70/17 on my 2006 Mega Cab Cummins 4x4. Also not happy with the Goodyear DuraTrac's in All Terrain tread design. It is also vague and squirmy. The BFG Rugged Trail TA handled well on my F350 4x4.

So far, my favorite is the Michelin highway tread for freeway performance. I never would have thought it made that much difference...but it does. I also blamed my Bronco for a lot of bad road manners, but when I finally put the BFG KO2's on it, it miraculously got better.
 

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
33's (LT285/70R17's) on Method NV wheels......2.5SL 1 BL......

DC Quarters is my next project....

Tim
 

Attachments

  • 20220504_132729.jpg
    20220504_132729.jpg
    330.1 KB · Views: 137
OP
OP
NickMcAFP

NickMcAFP

Contributor
Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2021
Messages
83
Loc.
Sturbridge
if your concerned about streetability of 33's go to a 17" wheel and run 285/70-17 tires in a mild all terrain, BFG KO3, Cooper AT3, ect. It will drive great and you won't suffer any ill street manners, as stated proper axle gearing is critical to get the best results. I have a truck with 33x12.50-15, I was going to go the 17" wheel route but have no regrets with the 15" route I went, and it saved me over $1000 in cost of tires and wheels.
I was looking at 17" wheels but noticed that the overall tire/wheel weight seemed to be less on 15" wheels.. Which means less rotating weight for starting/stopping.. I may be over thinking that as well though 😬
 
OP
OP
NickMcAFP

NickMcAFP

Contributor
Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2021
Messages
83
Loc.
Sturbridge
I'm really surprised by how unanimously everyone is recommending 33s. When is the internet ever unanimous?

I had settled on 33X10.50r15s for a while but my attitude started to waiver and I started looking at 31X10.50s because I figured they would be better on the road and the 33X10.50s seemed a little skinny. I really doubt I'm going to see much off-roading time.. The natural progression from there was splitting the difference at 32x11.50.

I do agree that 33X12.50s look "right"
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,607
Loc.
Fremont, CA
I was looking at 17" wheels but noticed that the overall tire/wheel weight seemed to be less on 15" wheels.. Which means less rotating weight for starting/stopping.. I may be over thinking that as well though 😬
Apples and oranges.

In the BFG AT KO2 family:

the 33x12.50x15 is a load range C, and weighs 56.8 lbs.
The 33x12.50x17 is a load range E, and weighs 61.2 lbs. ( So it looks like the 17 inch tire is 4.4 lbs heavier.)
the 285/70/17 load range C, weighs 50,3 lbs. (less than the 15 inch, as you would expect...since the hole is bigger)
the 285/70/17 Load Range E tire weighs 57.9 lbs.

All of these tires are 32.5 to 32.8 inches OD.
 

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
I was looking at 17" wheels but noticed that the overall tire/wheel weight seemed to be less on 15" wheels.. Which means less rotating weight for starting/stopping.. I may be over thinking that as well though 😬
True.....but my W will spin them off the line and I barked 3rd a week or so back. First time I've really gotten on it the new trans.......

You might notice the difference in 1/4 mile times but daily driving with proper gearing....you're not going to notice.

Go for the look you want and don't worry about weight.

Tim
 

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
Apples and oranges.

In the BFG AT KO2 family:

the 33x12.50x15 is a load range C, and weighs 56.8 lbs.
The 33x12.50x17 is a load range E, and weighs 61.2 lbs. ( So it looks like the 17 inch tire is 4.4 lbs heavier.)
the 285/70/17 load range C, weighs 50,3 lbs. (less than the 15 inch, as you would expect...since the hole is bigger)
the 285/70/17 Load Range E tire weighs 57.9 lbs.

All of these tires are 32.5 to 32.8 inches OD.
My Mastercraft MXT's LT285/70R17 E weight 55 pounds......

Tim
 
OP
OP
NickMcAFP

NickMcAFP

Contributor
Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2021
Messages
83
Loc.
Sturbridge
True.....but my W will spin them off the line and I barked 3rd a week or so back. First time I've really gotten on it the new trans.......

You might notice the difference in 1/4 mile times but daily driving with proper gearing....you're not going to notice.

Go for the look you want and don't worry about weight.

Tim
Bigger engine, lower first gear lol.

I'm sure that in the real world most of the things I'm nit picking would make imperceptible differences. Unfortunately all I can do is sit around and drive myself nuts while I wait for things to get built. I'm used to upgrading things as they fail. I do not like having to make decisions without personal experience.
 

Yeller

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
7,692
Loc.
Rogers County Oklahoma
Have you run the Cooper AT3's?

I had a 1/2 set of Cooper AT2's for a few years. Centering force and vagueness on center were problematic. I was forced to rotate them to the back of my truck to restore the handling. After 40,000 miles, and 4 years, my AT2's developed tread bulge and ultimately carcass failure. Somehow the wear indicator measured only at 50%, so I received a cash reimbursement of half of the cost of a NEW tire. Turns out that new tires are a lot more expensive than my old ones. So I got something like $160 each.

Happy with the customer service, but not happy with the performance. Also not happy that when I needed a single tire, I was forced to buy two, but when I went to warranty the tire...they only wanted to replace the one??? Also not happy with the straight line highway manners. The BFG KO2 tread design is much more streetable, with sharper response. This was 285/70/17 on my 2006 Mega Cab Cummins 4x4. Also not happy with the Goodyear DuraTrac's in All Terrain tread design. It is also vague and squirmy. The BFG Rugged Trail TA handled well on my F350 4x4.

So far, my favorite is the Michelin highway tread for freeway performance. I never would have thought it made that much difference...but it does. I also blamed my Bronco for a lot of bad road manners, but when I finally put the BFG KO2's on it, it miraculously got better.
Yes I have, but have always been a BFG/Michelin guy, but as of late they have not had the quality control that they used to, been very disappointed. getting round ones is difficult and belts moving has been horrible. My f350 had 3 tires that would not balance at 25k. But in the past I would get 65k out of KO2 and KO3's. I've just become a fan of buy a name that you recognize, that isn't the new name on the corner and if made in the USA even better.

I
 

Gupster88

Contributor
Guppy
Joined
Jan 15, 2019
Messages
854
Loc.
Tillamook OR
Here is a pic of mine with 2.5” lift and 1” body lift with 32 x 11.50s . While 33s would fill the wells a little better. I think you could run 32s and be pretty pleased with the look. Kinda the half way point of what your talking about. Split the difference and you can’t go wrong. Gears matter . I am running 4:11s and seems to be just about perfect for what I am running. Just my two cents worth.
 

Attachments

  • DA6FA15C-67B6-400F-90F4-A9AA3C9C3C7E.jpeg
    DA6FA15C-67B6-400F-90F4-A9AA3C9C3C7E.jpeg
    257.5 KB · Views: 116

ep67bro

Contributor
Bronco Junky
Joined
Aug 28, 2008
Messages
3,873
Loc.
Easton, MD
33s all the way with that lift It is a great look and as you dad and other say they just look right on the early broncos! I had 33x 12.50 x 15s on a few broncos and they looked great and wheeled well. My 70 has 33x 10.50x 15s BFG AT/2 on it with no lift, 302, 3 speed, and 4.10 gears and it clears fine is good on the street. I have had great luck with the BFG AT tires for the last 30 years. Run them on everything from broncos, f150s, and F250s. Long tread life ok off road and quiet on road.
 
Top