• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

New brake kits

LittleBeefy

Huge Brakes - www.hugebrakes.com
Joined
Aug 1, 2023
Messages
67
No rear brake to match?
We have a rear brake kit on our website also, but it only fits the large bearing with 3.5” by 2.375” flange. We are looking at adding a complete Explorer kit as well. There are some really good brake kits out there for the rear already, but for the money, it’s hard to improve over the Explorer kit. The El Dorado calipers are not my preference though.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
Been a long time since I've talked about brakes in technical terms. I'm likely very rusty. My random thots:

The common mantra when I worked at wilwood was that swept area really only mattered in the sense that if the shape of the pad was bigger then that resulted in potentially longer pad life because it follows that there would be more pad volume. Not always true, but usually true.
Mu is unitless, and in no case in my intro physics class when we were looking at a mass on a ramp or a mass on a flat surface did the area of that mass' footprint on the ramp or the ground enter into the force to move the mass calculations. This is no different, we're trying to slide a mass (the pad) along the ground (the rotor). Maybe physics has changed since I had that class (highly doubtful) or my memory is skewed (highly likely), but that is the simple physics model that I see working here.

I can see where a hard, quick brake application would be easier to cool than a long, soft(er) brake application. Two factors at play there. Thermal conduction takes a little time to heat the center of each rotor's pair of 'faces', and Large vs. small thermal delta. A HS welding class instructor really managed to drive home the adage "The more radical the temperature difference, the more radical the reaction." Put a bunch of BTU's into a rotor quickly and that energy will initially be right at the surfaces of the rotor resulting in a large thermal gradient within the rotor. Give it a little time and that gradient's delta will be much smaller. But initially that delta is quite large. Now expose that really hot surface to ambient air. It's really hot compared to the air around it, which will drive the thermal convection at a higher rate than a little later when the temperature delta isn't as large. Note that I'm talking fractions of a second, not hours. It would not come as a surprise to learn that a brake system can put more BTU's into a rotor in a set period of time than it can shed those BTU's by all means of cooling itself within that same period of time.

Everyone talks rotor diameter when that really isn't all that important. Pad centriod radial distance is what is important and that is driven by rotor OD, but they're not in lock-step with each other. Looking at most late model RDB's and the thing that strikes me about them is how small the inner radius of the pad is. Yes, they've put larger rotors in there to fill the openings in the wheels. But then they made the inner pad radius small, effectively moving the centriod radial distance closer to the axis of rotation than if the pad were a more traditional shape. They've given the public the look that they wanted while not excessively increasing the rear brake's effectiveness. Those pistons look to be really tiny on top of everything else.

Which brings up a theory that I've wanted to test for years. Say we use the GM D52 pad on a 12" rotor and measure the maximum braking power that such a system can generate.
Then I put those pads in the mill and remove the inner 1" of pad material. I just moved the centriod radially outward .50" without changing anything else. Now what is the maximum braking power that the same system can generate? Wish that I had access to wilwood's brake dyno. Even their old one would work for this experiment. The resulting braking power can be calculated, but would it really work?

For most pads, but not all, Mu is pretty close to static. The closer you get to a street service pad, the more this is a dominating goal. Race drivers can deal with pads that have wildly varying Mu (vs. temperature), but do not ask the general public to deal with that. Try to imagine a world where all of the "soccer moms" out there had to drive in a way that kept the brake pads up to operating temperature. Not a world that I want to drive in. They need a pad that 'grabs' the same regardless of temperature. That ideal Mu curve will be slightly lower when cold so that the brakes aren't "grabby", but once warm it is a pretty flat Mu vs. Temperature curve.

If you want to have some fun, assume that brake torque is exactly equal to internal combustion engine torque (it's not, but go with me here) and do the HP calculation for your brake system. The number can be quite impressive.

Those who want more rear brakes than the Exploder system, but like the general design of it should look at the early 2000's Expedition RDB's.
 
Last edited:

duffymahoney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
2,734
We have a rear brake kit on our website also, but it only fits the large bearing with 3.5” by 2.375” flange. We are looking at adding a complete Explorer kit as well. There are some really good brake kits out there for the rear already, but for the money, it’s hard to improve over the Explorer kit. The El Dorado calipers are not my preference though.
I have never looked into the explorer, the El Dorado are giant piles though:)
 
OP
OP
toddz69

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222
The rear kit on the website is the SSBC kit, which has been around forever - I like it better than the Eldorado-based stuff since I think the parking brakes in the late 80s/early 90s Varga calipers in the kit work better than the Eldorado calipers. I also like Master Power Brakes' rear kits with the late model Mustang calipers too.

Glad to see that SSBC was revived a few years ago - they have some unique offerings.

Todd Z.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
There is a reason that most OEM RDB's use floating calipers. They are particularly needed with C-Clip axles. Full-floats not so much. Semi-floats I oddly don't have much experience with, but expect those to behave more like a FF than a c-clip.
 

LittleBeefy

Huge Brakes - www.hugebrakes.com
Joined
Aug 1, 2023
Messages
67
The rear kit on the website is the SSBC kit, which has been around forever - I like it better than the Eldorado-based stuff since I think the parking brakes in the late 80s/early 90s Varga calipers in the kit work better than the Eldorado calipers. I also like Master Power Brakes' rear kits with the late model Mustang calipers too.

Glad to see that SSBC was revived a few years ago - they have some unique offerings.

Todd Z.
I like the SSBC stuff too. I’m in the process of engineering a kit to use the SSBC 6 piston aluminum calipers for the front. It’s gonna be a beast and will look amazing when it’s done. Again, will fit Broncos from 66-79 with original knuckles, spindles and hubs, or you can reuse the GM stuff if you previously swapped.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
I'm not a fan of their enclosed pad caliper design for the Brawler and Barbarian calipers. In use that bridge limits hot air flow and traps it inside the caliper. In service the whole caliper has to come off in order to replace the pads. Not too big of a deal, just a needless pita. Unless you've shimmed the caliper alignment, then it's really a pain.
It is true that this open area around the pads is where a fixed caliper flexes the most, but the caliper bows such that the center fastener is in tension and not compression. Other brands have used bolt-in bridges and they could have too.
 

duffymahoney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
2,734
My buddy designed these, 100% designed and made from scratch caliper. Ceramic disks! Pretty wild stuff.
 

Attachments

  • 367526395_207479568675949_3770238204226433117_n.jpg
    367526395_207479568675949_3770238204226433117_n.jpg
    190.9 KB · Views: 105
  • 367528918_324718809986003_9099368863769740944_n.jpg
    367528918_324718809986003_9099368863769740944_n.jpg
    164 KB · Views: 111

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
Looks like a Z car to me.

Duffy, did your friend only do the rotor assemblies, or were the calipers part of the project?
 

duffymahoney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
2,734
Looks like a Z car to me.

Duffy, did your friend only do the rotor assemblies, or were the calipers part of the project?
The caliper is 100% brand new designed by him for the 240z. It's Hoover Chan's 240z, he is very famous in the import car world.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
I'd be interested to talk to your friend.

Am guessing that the pic of them on the car was a test-fit. The caliper is upside down.
 

duffymahoney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 26, 2015
Messages
2,734
I'd be interested to talk to your friend.

Am guessing that the pic of them on the car was a test-fit. The caliper is upside down.
I am sure it was. Hoover owns and runs one of the nicer import build shops in the US. My buddy Fran designed it, who is also famous in the import and especially Porsche world.

I bounce ideas/ design elements off Fran a lot. He has a eye for design that also looks good and functions well. The looks good is the part most designers miss.
 

LittleBeefy

Huge Brakes - www.hugebrakes.com
Joined
Aug 1, 2023
Messages
67
Which brings up a theory that I've wanted to test for years. Say we use the GM D52 pad on a 12" rotor and measure the maximum braking power that such a system can generate.
Then I put those pads in the mill and remove the inner 1" of pad material. I just moved the centriod radially outward .50" without changing anything else. Now what is the maximum braking power that the same system can generate? Wish that I had access to wilwood's brake dyno. Even their old one would work for this experiment. The resulting braking power can be calculated, but would it really work?
NERD ALERT: this is about to get into the physics weeds.

I don't think moving the centroid of the pad further from the center of rotation would improve brake torque if the the piston did not also move the same direction and distance. I had to really think on it for a while to come up with a logical model to rationalize why, but here's what I came up with. I will assume the pad is perfectly rigid to simplify things because its not relevant to the explanation. Assume our starting point has the centroid of the pad aligned with the center of the piston. All of the force generated from the hydraulic advantage of the MC over the piston would be expressed outwardly directly into the surface of the rotor. Let's call that force Vector A. Now, move the centroid of the pad laterally away from the center of the piston. You have now introduced an angle. Let's call that force Vector B. The magnitude of Vector A and B are the same. Decompose Vector B into two components: the force that is in the same direction as Vector A (call that Vector B1) and the force that is orthogonal to Vector A (call that Vector B2). Vector B1 has a lower magnitude than Vector A and is resulting in less clamping force. Vector B2 is a force in a direction that is parallel to the surface of the rotor and is simply pushing on the inside of the caliper casing and not contributing to clamping force at all. So, if you move the pad centroid away from the center of the piston, you are reducing clamping force and adding stressors to the caliper casing.

As Einstein said "In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice, but in practice there is". I, too, would want to test it out to measure the forces and results, but the practical engineer in me keeps screaming "you don't get something for nothing" so I'm rationalizing that. Maybe there is something I'm not accounting for here in the entirety of the closed system from pedal to pad.
 

lars

Contributor
Been here awhile
Joined
Jun 29, 2001
Messages
3,334
Loc.
NorCal flatlands
NERD ALERT: this is about to get into the physics weeds.

I don't think moving the centroid of the pad further from the center of rotation would improve brake torque if the the piston did not also move the same direction and distance. I had to really think on it for a while to come up with a logical model to rationalize why, but here's what I came up with. I will assume the pad is perfectly rigid to simplify things because its not relevant to the explanation. Assume our starting point has the centroid of the pad aligned with the center of the piston. All of the force generated from the hydraulic advantage of the MC over the piston would be expressed outwardly directly into the surface of the rotor. Let's call that force Vector A. Now, move the centroid of the pad laterally away from the center of the piston. You have now introduced an angle. Let's call that force Vector B. The magnitude of Vector A and B are the same. Decompose Vector B into two components: the force that is in the same direction as Vector A (call that Vector B1) and the force that is orthogonal to Vector A (call that Vector B2). Vector B1 has a lower magnitude than Vector A and is resulting in less clamping force. Vector B2 is a force in a direction that is parallel to the surface of the rotor and is simply pushing on the inside of the caliper casing and not contributing to clamping force at all. So, if you move the pad centroid away from the center of the piston, you are reducing clamping force and adding stressors to the caliper casing.

As Einstein said "In theory, there is no difference between theory and practice, but in practice there is". I, too, would want to test it out to measure the forces and results, but the practical engineer in me keeps screaming "you don't get something for nothing" so I'm rationalizing that. Maybe there is something I'm not accounting for here in the entirety of the closed system from pedal to pad.
I can follow your reasoning and it makes sense to me. Intuitively it seems to me like the centroid of the pad and piston areas should lie on the same radius for the reasons you describe.

All that said: I have the same Dodge-based front caliper & rotor setup as ToddZ, a Ford h-boost fitted with a 1.25" bore master cylinder, Explorer rear discs all stopping 35" tires on a heavy (5300 pounds with full fuel) Bronco and I couldn't be happier. The front brakes replaced "T-bird" Ford calipers clamping stock rotors with a 1.125" master cylinder, all other stuff the same. The brake feel (utterly subjective) was about the same, and it stopped well until it didn't. Which was during any long descent. Tried lots of pad variations over almost 20 years, no improvement. Presumably the substantial extra thermal mass of my current setup is what solved that problem. In any case, brake fade is a thing of the past for me. Finally.

Long way of saying that it's nice to see someone get the big rotors and calipers on the market. Not as pretty as the Wilwood stuff, but plenty functional.
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,607
Loc.
Fremont, CA
I can follow your reasoning and it makes sense to me. Intuitively it seems to me like the centroid of the pad and piston areas should lie on the same radius for the reasons you describe.
@LittleBeefy and @ntsqd

Nerd alert received!

Can we please stick to the physics? It turns out that @ntsqd is correct it his original theory. BECAUSE his theory assumes that the caliper is sufficiently rigid so as to prevent "cocking" of the piston. So the forces that are imbalanced with respect to the centroid of the pad are countered by bending moment in the piston to bore interface. So we all can agree that it is a horrid design concept...but there is no reason why the piston needs to be centered on the pad. (in either plane)
It's just moronic to do so.

For the same reason that moving the caliper radially in and out will impact braking torque, moving the pad in and out will have the same effect. Obviously, the act of reducing the brake pad area necessarily changes Mu. (because of the way Mu is derived...) But if the brake dyno applies the same nominal hydraulic pressure on the same piston, the clamping force will be constant. The same clamping force will deliver the same force on a either pad. If you draw a free body diagram of the pad, you will see the same clamp force, on a smaller pad area, located farther from the axis. The brake torque will be increased, the pad will see greater pressure, and the pad will also see some very weird (and foolish) caliper binding, piston binding, and pad twisting, and a bunch of other horrid things.

At least, that's the way it works in theory. But as you correctly point out: In Theory...I am a millionaire on a beach. In practice, I am here with you.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
If you tightly model most calipers you'll find that the pistons are already not exactly centered on the pads. The big, single piston sliding calipers (GM D52 & D154, T-Bird, etc.) are the best (worst) examples of this. In the case of the D52 caliper the friction material footprint centroid is shifted up (larger acting radius) relative to the piston centerline. I'll estimate by about 3/16" or so. Wheel fitment is one very good reason to do this, can fit a larger rotor inside the wheel and not push the caliper body into the wheel.
So I'm not assuming that the parts are rigid enough to resist the lateral force, I'm saying that the lateral force isn't high enough to be a problem.

So far we've all assumed that the pad backing plate is perfectly rigid, which I can assure you it most definitely is not. Big or long pads call for multiple pistons just to keep the backing plate from bending all to heck under load. Even those aren't always successful.

And even the best caliper designs flex. The calipers used with the example D52 pad are incredibly flexible, as are most all sliding caliper designs. It is only the ubiquitousness of the GM sliding caliper used with the D52 pads that makes them attractive.

The caliper piston doesn't act thru it's centerline, it acts thru it's perimeter. Meaning that it is already a distributed loading on the pad backing plate. If you shift the actual friction material footprint under the backing plate far enough then those side loads on the piston become important. Until then they're also in the noise. I'll speculate that there is a tolerance ratio of offset to piston diameter that will simply model any of these offsets and reveal too much vs. still good, but I've no idea where that limit might be.
 
Last edited:

lars

Contributor
Been here awhile
Joined
Jun 29, 2001
Messages
3,334
Loc.
NorCal flatlands
@LittleBeefy and @ntsqd

Nerd alert received!

Can we please stick to the physics? It turns out that @ntsqd is correct it his original theory. BECAUSE his theory assumes that the caliper is sufficiently rigid so as to prevent "cocking" of the piston. So the forces that are imbalanced with respect to the centroid of the pad are countered by bending moment in the piston to bore interface. So we all can agree that it is a horrid design concept...but there is no reason why the piston needs to be centered on the pad. (in either plane)
It's just moronic to do so.

For the same reason that moving the caliper radially in and out will impact braking torque, moving the pad in and out will have the same effect. Obviously, the act of reducing the brake pad area necessarily changes Mu. (because of the way Mu is derived...) But if the brake dyno applies the same nominal hydraulic pressure on the same piston, the clamping force will be constant. The same clamping force will deliver the same force on a either pad. If you draw a free body diagram of the pad, you will see the same clamp force, on a smaller pad area, located farther from the axis. The brake torque will be increased, the pad will see greater pressure, and the pad will also see some very weird (and foolish) caliper binding, piston binding, and pad twisting, and a bunch of other horrid things.

At least, that's the way it works in theory. But as you correctly point out: In Theory...I am a millionaire on a beach. In practice, I am here with you.
Right! In my (going blind) mind’s eye I was thinking not rigid. Have seen so many disc brake pads over the years that were worn tapered, either axially or radially or both that I long ago concluded bending/cocking/whatever is happening. So it seems to me that getting centroid piled on centroid would make for badness reduction.
 
Top