I just went through this with my temp guage.
There is a voltage regulator (of sorts.. ) behind the instrument cluster. It supplies power to the three guages. If the other two guages work then chances are, the voltage regulator is OK. The voltage regulator pulses power to the guages, so, depending on what kind of volt meter you have (analog vs digital), if you measure the voltage, it will look pretty strange. An analog meter will show the needle bounding back and forth from about 3 volts to about 10 volts. At least that's what mine did. My digital showed different voltages from 0.0 to 8.something...
My suggestion is to disconnect the oil pressure sending unit, turn the key on, and use your voltmeter to measure (look at) the voltage on that wire. This will give you an idea of what your meter will indicate for proper supply to the sending unit. Then, measure the voltage at the temperature sender. If its the same, then replace the temp sending unit.
If it's not the same, then measure the voltage at the back of the temperature guage in the instrument panel. The temp meter has two wires on it. The black (with a white tracer???) is the supply from the voltage regulator. The other wire, red with white tracer, is the one going out to the temp sending unit. Measure the voltage at the back of the guage, where the red/white wire is. If you don't have proper voltage, the guage is bad. If you have voltage, then the wire is broken somewhere between the guage and the sending unit.
I found a bad connection at the firewall wiring harness connector. The female connection was broken down inside the connector. I
engineered a fix by running one new wire from the gauge to the engine compartment side of the harness. This will do 'till I install a new replacement harness...