• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

high torque starter

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Unfortunately for Steve in this case, the corrections to the terminology only come up haphazzardly here now and then and, in this case, may have seemed to be inappropriately timed, within the context of the question. You were correcting a percieved mistake, but not answering the question at hand. And also, evidently, hit Kyle on a sore subject to boot! Good shooting!
That, and the fact that nobody's brought up the subject here recently enough to give people pause to think about it, may have got us here to this little segué.

Personally, I'd like to see a dedicated thread, just to discuss/correct the 50 year long possible mis-representation of the little device that energizes the starters on most of our Fords. I've finally just taken to calling it a relay/solenoid/thingy in some of my posts in order to cover more bases and maybe bring the subject up to the fore again.

I may be wrong, but the use of the word "solenoid" in our cases could stem from a couple of sources:
1) Mabye Ford used to use a solenoid activated starter motor in older models(?) and the word just kinda' stuck? Don't know, 'cause I'm not that familiar with Fords older than the sixties.
2)Maybe some people, being more familiar with the good ole GM type starter that we've all come to know and love, started using the term out of ignorance and just assumed that anything that energizes a starter just HAD to be a "solenoid". Or...
3)Maybe some early adopters of the technology just used that word to describe our little relay/solenoid/mag-switch/whateverstevecalledit/thingies because, inside that little plastic case, there is in fact a "rod" that is actuated, pulling a connecting bar over two electrical contacts to peform it's function. It's a stretch perhaps, but...
Even though it's not a lever moving a load (like wedging a spinning gear into the larger ring-gear of the flywheel/flexplate), if you look at it cross-eyed and squint, it could look like a solenoid at work.

Yeah, that's it. That's the ticket...
Now, what was the question again??? Oh look! A Bronco.......!

Paul
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
It will always be a solenoid to me. I don't care what the rest of you guys call it.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Hooahh! Well said!!!!
Even though I call it a relay now, I can live with that.

Paul
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
[offtopic] :D
Well, most relays contain a solenoid to operate the switch contacts. But to me, it's like calling a flashlight a light bulb. Yes: there's one in there, but the terms aren't interchangeable. Not all relays contain solenoids; not all solenoids are in relays. Not all flashlights contain light bulbs; not all light bulbs are in flashlights.

I think the confusion stems from lazy parts manufacturers who labelled any high-current electrical component having to do with the starter as "solenoid" just because GM solenoids burned out their contacts so often that the market had to cater to them. But that's purely conjecture.

Anyway: I always distinguish because they ARE different, and they do different things, and they have different uses, symptoms, & failures. Case in point: that OTHER active thread where someone is attempting to install a solenoid starter in place of a non-solenoid type. How confusing would it be for him if we called BOTH things "solenoid"? ;)
[/offtopic]
 

76 bronco J

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 20, 2005
Messages
1,480
>>>>> see pic below of starter relay/mag switch/solenoid / what ever the hell you want to call it....... I've always thought the linear motion plunger thingy circled in red is the solenoid
 

Attachments

  • ----------------------.JPG
    ----------------------.JPG
    142.2 KB · Views: 115

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Agreed. Pretty much what I was saying in scenario 3 above.
However, even your example pic calls it a "Relay" right there in the text.

For now, it's all about who's doin' the talkin' I guess.
As in, "anybody got a solenoid for a 400M?"
But then, that's a whole 'nother can-o-worms...

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Ok, sorry everybody, especially for another drawn out post, but this is way to interesting to drop just yet. Sorry 00gyrhed too, for straying a bit from your original post. But hey, it's "related" in a 6-degrees-of-separation kind of way.

I've always thought the linear motion plunger thingy circled in red is the solenoid

You might be right. Maybe it's just not considered a solenoid, by some, because the motion plunger is not performing any mechanical duties outside of the enclosure, like we've come to expect from solenoids.
That would make it just a plunger "switch", which would make it a relay (or mag-switch)? After all, even a standard relay is closing an electrical contact inside the enclosure. Whiich is just what the Ford starter switch is doing.

So lets dig deeper. Unlike a common relay however, it's pulling a plunger rod through the coils to close the contacts, rather than using the magnetic field created to close a spring-loaded contact set, with no movement through the actual coils.
But movement of a rod through coils is the very definition of a solenoid! If only it'd perform some mechanical function, it'd be easier to define.

So it seems like a relay to me, but "mag-switch" is pretty a pretty darn descriptive term too and sounds like just another name for a relay. Or vice-versa.
So which came first? Mag-switch sounds like an original description and relay more of a name that followed the function of the switch.
Not scientific conclusion by any means. And I'm not old enough to remember who's on first, but I have been doing a lot of reading tonight. And that's led to another conclusion.
Maybe they're all correct names! Wait! What'd he say? No way! Yes way.

Steve or Raymond, either of you got any info on the history of the term "Mag-Switch", or relay for that matter.
Maybe it's just a cultural/geographical thing (not that THAT would ever happen!) where, in the US it's called a relay, and in Canada it's called a mag-switch? Like boot and trunk. Loo and bathroom, queue and line, Americans and Americans (north, central and south types, that is)? Etcetera...
I think you use the term relay too Ray, but do you ever use the term mag-switch for a standard little square box type Bosch "relay"?
Just curious.

After doing some reading, and following Steve's links, I think that we can indeed use all three words interchangeably. We may not like it, but it looks to be true.
In at least one definition of "solenoid", even though it's primarily used in mechanical actuator terms, there is a paragraph that says it can be used to "close electrical contacts" and maks no mention of mechanical levering, which is what many of us thought was the only function.

Here's the paragraph:
"In engineering, the term solenoid may also refer to a variety of transducer devices that convert energy into linear motion. The term is also often used to refer to a solenoid valve, which is an integrated device containing an electromechanical solenoid which actuates either a pneumatic or hydraulic valve, or a solenoid switch, which is a specific type of relay that internally uses an electromechanical solenoid to operate an electrical switch; for example, an automobile starter solenoid, or a linear solenoid, which is an electromechanical solenoid."Seems that by the definition of most, "solenoid" is primarily the magnetic field and the movement of something through it. No definitive mention of it having to perform some mechanical action.

Make of it what you will, but they said it best on Saturday Night Live...
"It's a floor wax AND a dessert topping!!!"

I know what you believe Steve, from what you said earlier, but it says it in your link too
What say you all? Start a new thread yet? We can even discuss the various meanings of "turning over vs starting vs cranking vs firing" "HEI vs hei" "limited-slip vs posi-traction", "HID vs Xenon" and all sorts of other pet-peeve soon-to-be-generic words and phrases.

Paul
 
Last edited:

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
Not all magnetic switches are relays, and not all relays are magnetic switches.
- I have a magnetic switch on each window & door in my house for the alarm system. They're not relays.
- I have some old solid-state relays in a junk box in my garage. They contain no magnets or coils, and no switches.
So again: the terms aren't interchangeable.

Yes, MOST relays contain solenoids. But ALL idle air control valves (IACs, for you EFI-savvy types ;)) contain solenoids; so do all EVRs, CANPs, TABs/TADs... Even the horn & all the speakers fit ANYONE's definition of "solenoid". Does that mean we should call them all "solenoids", Viperwolf1? The engine contains several pistons. Should we all start using the term "piston" to refer to a complete engine?




I think I have an explanation that will clarify...

The term "solenoid" refers to a particular mechanism; the way it's built. And even though the things we're discussing do contain solenoids, calling them all "solenoid" only confuses them. They ARE different. The starter solenoid (on the starer) is built with a massive electromagnetic coil whose primary function is to shove the Bendix into the ring gear. If it only needed to turn on the starter motor, it could be MUCH smaller (lighter, cheaper, less power consumption), and there'd be no reason to put it in such a harsh environment as the bottom of the engine, under the exhaust. So even though it DOES turn on the motor, that's obviously not its main function.

The term "relay" refers to an OPERATION; what it does. A relay takes a weak (low-current) input signal and steps it up to a strong (high-current) output. All relays, regardless of construction, do that. And that's what the starter relay (on the fender) is for: it allows the ig.sw. to pass only a fraction of the current needed to operate the starter. So whether it's built on an electromagnetic solenoid, or a vacuum diaphragm, or a flux capacitor, it'll always be a relay. :D
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
:eek:

What was this thread about? Starters or what? ;D

Definitely "or what" now.
Much more interesting I think. But hopefully 00gyrhd got his questions answered in there somewhere too.

Paul
 
Top