First, is your suspension sitting where it should? Does the Bronco sit relatively level, and you're happy with the stance as it is?
If so, what's the actual measurement between upper and lower mounts?
There may not be a perfectly sized shock, so you may have found your best compromise already. But sitting perfectly in the middle of the travel is not a requirement. The amount of shock travel is roughly half of the amount of suspension travel (approx 45° angle) or thereabouts. I don't think they're actually 45 degrees, but whatever they are is reducing the amount of distance the shock travels per inch of wheel travel.
Hmm, now I'm curious what the exact angle is on these things!
How much lift (if any?) is yours running?
Paul