• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Starter relay for Explorer swap?

1buckeyefan1

Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2017
Messages
641
Alright, i've read at least a dozen different threads about why a starter relay is good for the Explorer 5.0 swap. After culling through the dozens of posts debating the semantics of a solenoid vs. relay, i find myself even more confused.

1.) I started with a 2001 Explorer/Mountaineer. I've got through all of my parts and don't have any donor starter relay in my bins.. I'm guessing either I tossed it, or Ford stopped using fender-mounted relays in favor of a Bosch one in this year. I've been going with OEM motorcraft parts for my build and would like to find a OEM relay...if it's really needed?

2.) I'm using a reman Motorcraft SA851 PMGR starter. I'd like to keep my engine bay as clutter-free as possible. I don't plan on hooking a bunch of aux wires off it, like a winch, etc.

3.) I have a Motorcraft SW1951C relay on the way. According to Rockauto, this was used up to 1999 explorers. However, it's a 3 lug.. unsure if this adds value according to Steve83's diagrams i've read through...which show the aux wire running off the I terminal.

https://www.supermotors.net/registry/media/809586_1

4.) Steve83 specifically calls out Motorcraft E9TZ-11450-B, which still has the I terminal, which he connects to the starter as an auxiliary power source (per Bowsher, helps w/ intermittent ignition?)

5.) I'm even more confused by the WH diagram, which calls for putting the starter wire and battery wire on the same terminal.. and using the relay as the aux source?
http://cdn.wildhorses4x4.com/downloads/WH/6038 10-12-09.pdf

6.) I've read most of 904Bronco's posts and know that I need a relay w/ a diode in it to safeguard my ECU, but can't determine which (both?) motorcraft relays contain the diode?

I guess my question is 1.) do I really need a relay, as to reduce the clutter and 2.) should I go with the SW1951C vs. E9TZ-11450-B and how do I wire that extra 12ga wire to the starter?
 

Attachments

  • motorcraft SA851.jpg
    motorcraft SA851.jpg
    21.8 KB · Views: 204
  • SW1951C.jpg
    SW1951C.jpg
    154.8 KB · Views: 191
  • E8TZ-11450-B.jpg
    E8TZ-11450-B.jpg
    172.2 KB · Views: 234
  • startersolswap.jpg
    startersolswap.jpg
    63.3 KB · Views: 249

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Yes, you need the relay.
Even Ford still used them.

If you want to see clutter, you should try connecting all of those extra wires down on your starter because you got rid of the fender mounted relay. It’s just a bad overall idea to connect everything to the starter.
And in that case you’re going to want an auxiliary power stud mounted somewhere convenient anyway which will bring back your clutter at least to that one small location.

You can however put the starter relay anywhere you feel it’s clean and out of the way.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
If you look at any 60s and 70s General Motors car the positive battery cable was run straight down to the starter solenoid on the back of the starter. Just like we say to do it from the fender mounted relay.
The relay does multiple things.
It reduces the load on the ignition switch.
It reduces the chance of starter run on, when done correctly.
It gives a convenient point to connect auxiliary power wires.
Probably other things I’m missing, but you get the point.

The reason it reduces the chance of starter run on is for the time people use the same relay location for both starter wires.
If you wire it directly from the ignition switch to the solenoid on the starter, you should not have starter run on. But then you do put the higher load on the ignition switch.
 
OP
OP
1buckeyefan1

1buckeyefan1

Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2017
Messages
641
If you look at any 60s and 70s General Motors car the positive battery cable was run straight down to the starter solenoid on the back of the starter. Just like we say to do it from the fender mounted relay.
The relay does multiple things.
It reduces the load on the ignition switch.
It reduces the chance of starter run on, when done correctly.
It gives a convenient point to connect auxiliary power wires.
Probably other things I’m missing, but you get the point.

The reason it reduces the chance of starter run on is for the time people use the same relay location for both starter wires.
If you wire it directly from the ignition switch to the solenoid on the starter, you should not have starter run on. But then you do put the higher load on the ignition switch.

As always, thanks for your responses Paul. I'm pretty you chimed in every relay thread I found over the last 10+ years ;) After reading the old threads, I was pretty sure the relay was necessary...at least enough to order one today before posting this. I'll probably mount it below the battery tray to keep with the clean look. If anyone has any 'clean' mounting ideas, i'd love some pics.

I'm still curious on the 3 vs. 4 terminal relays.. assuming the 'I' terminal is removed from the SW1951C (for modern EFI vehicles?). I'm still slightly curious how most have wired up this type of relay?
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Correct.
From the sound of it you only need a three terminal style, but a four terminal style would not be the end of the world and certainly could be usable.
You just would leave the “I” terminal blank.

Assuming you are going with the explorer for the modern EFI? What about coil packs versus distributor?
Either way, if you’re using fuel injection and the computer is controlling the ignition you generally do not need the old circuit from the I terminal because you don’t need that connected to your ignition.
And in fact there probably is not a wire in the harness to do so.
 

904Bronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Messages
6,720
Loc.
San Martin, CA
Late to the party... I see Paul is on it!

People have written here that they have used the old style Relay without issue.
EFI relay has a diode in the start circuit to prevent feedback to ECU.
Really any EFI Ford vehicle relay will work.
The "I" terminal seems to still be around because it is easier to sell one part that fits so many vehicles.
The Explorer PM starter has a hot battery wire to it and uses a 12-10G wire to engage the little solenoid on it.
The start circuit wire is like 18g or less, it is just a signal wire to close the fender relay and not suitable to operate the PM starter.
That's why Ford still uses it on the Explorers and other vehicles.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
I'm still curious on the 3 vs. 4 terminal relays.. assuming the 'I' terminal is removed from the SW1951C (for modern EFI vehicles?).
THIS IS RONG!!!
Use of the I terminal depends on which ignition switch is used. If the switch is a modern design with an I output (hot in RUN & START), then the relay's I terminal would be redundant/unnecessary. If the switch is an older design (like the original for the eB which lacks an output hot in both positions), then the relay's I can supply that function.
THAT WAS RONG!!!
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
1buckeyefan1

1buckeyefan1

Sr. Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2017
Messages
641
I was just about to post that it all makes sense now until Steve posted that the stock EB ignition switch still needs the relay's I terminal.
Is this what Bowsher was posting about a few years back (needing the I terminal to keep power to the ignition while in start?)

https://classicbroncos.com/forums/threads/explorer-edis-starter-solenoid-wiring.262101/post-2791741

Doug, or others.. what type of ignition switch are you using with the modern 3-post relay in your Explorer swaps?

I've got my ignition switch that came out of my previously modified EB. I assume it's stock and considered upgrading?

Thanks for the prompt responses guys! I wouldn't be undertaking this w/out y'alls experience to lean on!
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
I think almost everyone is still using a stock style bronco ignition switch.
I believe Steve could be incorrect though, in that I believe the stock switch does have one single terminal that is hot in both run and start.
That is the terminal with the green and red wire for the voltage regulator and the red with green wire for the ignition coil.

But I’m only pretty sure that’s correct, so let’s discuss this at greater length.
It was always my thinking that if the ignition switch ever defaulted and was only hot in run, the I wire from the starter relay would make up for that.
Or a better way to look at that would be that it actually masks the problem with the ignition switch.
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222
When I did my EFI swap 25 years ago, I used a 4 post relay, NAPA PN ST-404 (which probably cross-references to the Motorcraft PN that Steve links above). It's a modern relay with 4 posts (I just moved all 4 wires from my original relay over to the new one) and it has the diode in it for EFI. I think it was originally for a mid '80s Tempo application. I was one of the original guys that did the PGMR starter swap in the EBs - followed an article that appeared in Street Rodder magazine in the late '90s. Wrote an article about it and soon a lot of the vendors came out with kits - I wired mine exactly like the diagram that you linked from WH above - has worked perfectly for about 23-24 years now.

Todd Z.
 

Wes harden

Jr. Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2005
Messages
111
The I terminal on the fender solenoid, is to provide 12v to the ignition coil during cranking. once the engine starts and the solenoid opens, the coil gets reduced voltage @7-9 volts.
Modern EFI engines do not need the I terminal.

The I terminal was added after certain conditions kept the engine from cranking and starting. Old style starters need a lot of amp to work, and can draw battery voltage down to 9-10volt on good day. If you say had a hot soak condition the amperage could be higher, and the voltage drop lower, this would then cause the coil voltage through the resistance circuit to be to low to make spark and start the engine.

New batteries and starters are far more efficient, even with higher compressions and horse power we make today. You do not need the I terminal.
Iirc the explorer had a cable to the starter and then a second power feed to a relay center/power distribution block. Duplicating the relay center is the way to go here. As stated above heavy cable from battery to main lug on starter, min 12 gauge wire from load side of relay to crank signal terminal on starter solenoid. The ecu harness should have an existing start signal wire to control the start relay in your relay center.

Don't read to much in solenoid vs relay bs they are both the same thing, one is bigger than the other. I suppose all but those attached to the actual cranking motor are relays. The solenoids on cranking motors not only close an electric circuit, but they also move/slide a plunger to engage the drive teeth with the fly wheel/ flex plate.
 
Last edited:

Big Slim

Full Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
339
my motor was from a 98 and the yellow/blue wire went directly to the fuse box to a bosch style relay. that is how i hooked mine up. just got it running but no issue so far.
 
Top