• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Which EFI Tank......?

WPS 73 Bronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2023
Messages
545
Loc.
The Woodlands, Tx
So when I research the different EFI tank options, I see a big price difference.

Tom's is about $900. (Maker unknown, 23 Gallon 16 g steel)

WH's is about $1300. (M1A1 23 Gallon SS tank)

Duff's is about $1900. (Lick Creek 20 Gallon SS tank)

Can someone suggest pro's and cons between the different tanks, besides Carbon vs SS?
I plan to eliminate the aux tank for retractable side steps, so no external fuel pump options.
 
Last edited:

56f100bbw

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
2,406
Loc.
Tucson / lakeside AZ
I’ve been looking at the same thing for my 77 bronco trying to figure out which gas tank they are kind of pricey just bought one last week for my Mustang fastback and it was only 120 bucks but it’s stamped steel probably China
 

Brush Hog

Full Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2022
Messages
241
Loc.
NorCal
I just installed tom’s 23 gallon tank. Non EFI though. Was pretty straight forward. Tank is heavy and awkward so wrestling it in was not easy plus working around my dual exhaust. I like how it looks and fits. Some reviews said the large tanks looked like loaded diaper hanging down under their broncos. The Toms tank tucked up nice and high (I have 1” BL) and looks great. Can’t comment on durability yet.
 

904Bronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Messages
6,720
Loc.
San Martin, CA
I have had good luck with Aero Bronco 23 gal tanks, Jacob is good to work with and is willing to do custom things. There was a mass buy here on this site a number of years ago and the Norcal Bronco website has done a number of mass buys. It is Not a pretty tank, but it is rugged, especially if you add the welded on skid plate. I know their prices have gone up, just like everyone else's, but it might be an option.
https://aerotanks.com/about-us/

And I see a big disclaimer that some tanks are not available in CA, nor do I see a listing for the 23 gal EFI tank? Maybe it might be worth a phone call to ask since you live out of this state...

I have seen the WH's SS tank, good looking product, but the price you listed would make me hesitant to purchase...
 

Shimmy

Contributor
1977 Bronco
Joined
Jun 20, 2021
Messages
1,396
Loc.
Maple Valley
I like the design of the JD tank, but at over $2k shipped it just seems a little ridiculous for a tank. I'm still weighing the options too.
 

Soylent

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
May 4, 2016
Messages
690
Loc.
California
I installed the WH with the skid plate. Very nice welds. Fairly easy install but definitely a two person job getting it lifted up in there. This is the amount of “diaper” with no body lift.

IMG_7088.jpeg
 

bronco italiano

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 1, 2004
Messages
2,595
I have had good luck with Aero Bronco 23 gal tanks, Jacob is good to work with and is willing to do custom things. There was a mass buy here on this site a number of years ago and the Norcal Bronco website has done a number of mass buys. It is Not a pretty tank, but it is rugged, especially if you add the welded on skid plate. I know their prices have gone up, just like everyone else's, but it might be an option.
https://aerotanks.com/about-us/

And I see a big disclaimer that some tanks are not available in CA, nor do I see a listing for the 23 gal EFI tank? Maybe it might be worth a phone call to ask since you live out of this state...

I have seen the WH's SS tank, good looking product, but the price you listed would make me hesitant to purchase...
https://aerotanks.com/product/1970-1977-ford-bronco-replacement-tank/
 

bronco italiano

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 1, 2004
Messages
2,595
So when I research the different EFI tank options, I see a big price difference.

Tom's is about $900. (Maker unknown, 23 Gallon 16 g steel)

WH's is about $1300. (M1A1 23 Gallon SS tank)

Duff's is about $1900. (Lick Creek 20 Gallon SS tank)

Can someone suggest pro's and cons between the different tanks, besides Carbon vs SS?
I plan to eliminate the aux tank for retractable side steps, so no external fuel pump options.
JD is 2300 less shipping if you add the fuel pump plate/fuel pump/skid plate.
Are you against running a low pressure and high pressure fuel pump on the frame rails?
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222
One good thing about the Duffs and WH tanks is that they use the newer style sending units, which finally allow your fuel gauge to work properly.

I have the WH tank and really like it - I had to do some sealing upgrades beyond what the instructions said to get mine to not leak. The pump is extremely noisy - I'm going drop the tank someday when I'm feeling ambitious and wrap it in foam.

Todd Z.
 

Wild horse 75

Sr. Member
Joined
May 9, 2023
Messages
464
Loc.
BC
Look at the Krawlers edge tank. Similar to the Duff tank in that it mounts only to the frame but it’s a bit cheaper and comes with a skid plate for mounting.
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222
Look at the Krawlers edge tank. Similar to the Duff tank in that it mounts only to the frame but it’s a bit cheaper and comes with a skid plate for mounting.
Note the KE tank hangs a lot lower than most of the other tanks.

Another thing I don't like about some of the tanks is that they use a 340 lph pump, which requires an additional fuel pump relay in most instances. The more common 255 lph pump is more than sufficient for most of our engines' needs.

Todd Z.
 
Last edited:

Wild horse 75

Sr. Member
Joined
May 9, 2023
Messages
464
Loc.
BC
Note the KE tank hangs a lot lower than most of the other tanks.

Another thing I don't like about some of the tanks is that they use a 340 lph pump, which requires a fuel pump relay in most instances. The more common 255 lph pump is more than sufficient for most of our engines' needs.

Todd Z.
You should always install a relay in a fuel pump circuit. That’s the only way you can insure clean full 12V all the time.
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222
You should always install a relay in a fuel pump circuit. That’s the only way you can insure clean full 12V all the time.
Correct (edited my original reply above). I have one in my fuel injection harness. It's rated at 20 amps max per my Ford Motorsport installation manual. The 340 lph pumps often require more than that which would've required an additional relay to be added.

Todd Z.
 

Wild horse 75

Sr. Member
Joined
May 9, 2023
Messages
464
Loc.
BC
Correct (edited my original reply above). I have one in my fuel injection harness. It's rated at 20 amps max per my Ford Motorsport installation manual. The 340 lph pumps often require more than that which would've required an additional relay to be added.

Todd Z.
Yeah that would be the exception to my always. I still like to run a relay just in case and for future upgrades. I also prefer to run self resetting circuit breakers on fuel pumps and fans. Fans especially. They can sometimes spike way higher than normal when they start spinning. And a fuse would just blow and need to be replaced but a circuit breaker will reset after a few seconds and you’re back up and running.
 

Colo77Bronco

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2004
Messages
694
Loc.
Colorado Springs
So when I research the different EFI tank options, I see a big price difference.

Tom's is about $900. (Maker unknown, 23 Gallon 16 g steel)

WH's is about $1300. (M1A1 23 Gallon SS tank)

Duff's is about $1900. (Lick Creek 20 Gallon SS tank)

Can someone suggest pro's and cons between the different tanks, besides Carbon vs SS?
I plan to eliminate the aux tank for retractable side steps, so no external fuel pump options.
That’s the starting point for the duffs. Once you add a fuel pump and make it complete its mid $2k range. I really like the tank but the price is just way too high.

I went with the Wild Horses tank. Found it to be best balance of quality and price.
 
Top