• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

TIG v. MIG

67 Halfcab

Full Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
251
ntsqd;2646010 As to the "too much heat for sheet metal" statement said:
Please reread my post. Nowhere did I mention blowing through. The OP mentioned this about his GMAW welding. I talked about heat input and the resultant warping from shrinkage.

In GMAW welding when you pull the trigger the wire initiates and the arc starts. Most of the heat from the arc goes to melting the wire. When you release the trigger, the wire stops feeding and the arc stops. In the garage you are most likely using the short circuit transfer mode, the coolest of the three GMAW transfer modes. Basically this means the wire actually touches the base metal, shorts out, heats up, and explodes, then does it again, ect, ect, ect. This is what causes the "frying bacon" sound you hear.

In GTAW you light off on the piece by pushing down on your control pedal or pushing the decay button (ignoring scratch start here), wait for the arc to stabilize, then ramp up your arc to build the weld puddle. When the puddle is the size you want you can then begin adding wire and moving along the joint. As human beings, we are not as efficient at consistently adding the wire at the correct rate as the machine is. This means you naturally move along the joint at a slower rate than you would with an semi-automatic machine. If the wire you are trying to melt into the puddle is larger in diameter than the thickness of the base material (remember we are welding thin guage body sheet metal here) you are going to have a rough time at it. When you are done with the bead you then stop adding wire and slowly ramp your arc off. In starting the arc, moving along the joint, and stopping the arc you have added extra heat to the base metal with GTAW that GMAW would not have.

The heat added while welding both melts the base metal and causes expansion along the weld joint. As the weld joint cools it contracts more than it expanded causing distortion that we see as warping. The more heat that is put into the base metal the worse the warping. When using GTAW over GMAW you are adding extra heat to the base metal in the arc start, slower travel speed, and extinguishing the arc. This extra heat means more warping.

Can GTAW be used to weld sheet metal? Of course it can. Is it the best choice to use to get the best possible results? No it isn't. For welding sheet metal stick with your GMAW machine. If performing lap joints, keep your stringers short and skip around a lot. If you are plug welding, put a backing bar behind the joint to support the puddle and act as a heat sink. If you are using a butt joint, make your weld a series of tacks, moving around the joint to keep it cool and distribute the distortion until you have a completed weld.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
When welding sheet metal with a TIG I use a small filler. When welding SST I've been known to use .025 & .032 304SST Safety Wire (Yes, I know the SST alloy rule, this is never structural). With carbon steel I take the smallest filler that I have and hammer it flat making it as thin as I can get it. Or I shear off thin strips of the same sheet metal for the filler.
EDIT: Forgot to mention that I've also been known to use MIG filler wire with the TIG. Spool out some and cut it off. Feed it like normal TIG filler.

In welding sheet aluminum I've been known to use reverse polarity with a red tungsten and a sheared-off piece of the base metal for the filler.

Blanket statements like "Is TIG the best for sheet metal, no it isn't" are deceitful and misleading. Maybe it is and maybe it isn't the best choice. It really depends on the needs and the goals of the join. Choose the method best suited to the project. Sometimes that will be TIG, other times that will be MIG. On rare occasions the best choice will be Oxy-Fuel.

Yes, I do know that it's currently called GTAW in the industry but most know it as TIG so that's what I call it.
 
Last edited:

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
I have always heard that TIG will make a lower deposition weld that will be far easier to grind down. Grinding can cause warping too if you create too much heat.
I have also heard that TIG has a smaller heat effected area than MIG.
And finally I have heard that TIG has less of a tendency to show itself through your body work/paint later the way MIG can.
Having said all that. I can't TIG, hell I am just an average MIG weldor, so don't take what I say to heart. There are some serious weldors on this site ......
 

Bferrari

Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2013
Messages
857
Hammer welding with a TIG torch leaves the best welds i've ever seen on sheet metal. It also gives you the ability to shrink/strech your metal with the hammer and dolly as you go. Alot of times you can't tell there has been a weld there aside from the discoloration in the metal from the heat. Check it out on youtube, they have a few examples of guys doing this with a gas welder.
 

lowbush

Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
1,807
Loc.
Summerland Key, FL
I have always heard that TIG will make a lower deposition weld that will be far easier to grind down. Grinding can cause warping too if you create too much heat.
I have also heard that TIG has a smaller heat effected area than MIG.
And finally I have heard that TIG has less of a tendency to show itself through your body work/paint later the way MIG can.
Having said all that. I can't TIG, hell I am just an average MIG weldor, so don't take what I say to heart. There are some serious weldors on this site ......

I TIG, but in saying that I am not a production welder, but I tell you after switching to TIG I never looked back. It's slow as watching paint dry but it's also very controlable. You can keep the head zone down to a 1/4 inch radius for body panels or flair it out to 6 inches for roll cages where you need the heat spread to soften the joint all by tungston / cup / input selection. I feel I have to do less touch up / filler / sanding work since I switched to TIG and TIG welds are slightly stronger than MIG welds. In a production environment it would not be cost effective, but for me just putting around in the garage and being as OCD as I am about doing things the best I can, TIG works for me. I personally would never go back to MIG.
 

Jeff10

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 20, 2011
Messages
2,182
Loc.
Indianapolis
Hey Guys,

Thanks for sharing your experience. I'll look forward to giving TIG a try.

There's a welding supplier here in Indy (Sutton-Garten) that offers welding classes. They're $75 for each 3-1/2 hour session. It's great because they provide all the metal you can join together. I used them when I wanted experience with MIG. I'm pretty sure that I'll go back to them for TIG. A couple of us went just as hobbyist; but, they also provide certifications. Highly recommended.

Thanks again.

Jeff
 

Crawdad

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 16, 2011
Messages
3,635
I've always wanted to get into welding. So at age 33 I joined the AF to learn a hobby. One of my best decisions!
 
Top