It's at this juncture, that I'd like to ask anyone that knows a Ford electrical engineer from that time period, to please give them a swift kick in the rear!
WTH Ford? Do we really need all these different sensors and plugs over the years to do the same damn thing?
K, rant over;D
Can any year 351W be used for this swap?
Yes, assuming you address the balancer, cam sensor, and lower intake requirements previously mentioned.
Thanks EFI Guy, I have a 351W but unsure of the year, guessing its pre-roller. Need to check into it.
EFI Guy mentioned that the EGR is recommended and most people claim that EGR actually increases gas mileage. Any other pro's/con's to running or not running the EGR?
All donors I'm finding are high mileage 130,000+, how reliable are the 4R70W's?
All donors I'm finding are high mileage 130,000+, how reliable are the 4R70W's?
On another note, I have read this entire thread and took notes (lots of info to process) but still a little confused on a few things. What would be the best year donor or combination of donors to use. I know pre-99 was mentioned because of the bigger injectors, '98-'01 has the better internals in the trans and the '96-'97 for the VSS wiring, injectors, 3 wire cam sensor, and I thouht I read its a better year for tuning?? Is the '98 a mutt and have the best of both, better trans, bigger injectors etc.?
EFI Guy mentioned that the EGR is recommended and most people claim that EGR actually increases gas mileage. Any other pro's/con's to running or not running the EGR?
EFI has much better control of the fuel and as a result there is no excess fuel washing the oil off the cylinder walls.
Maintenance matters more than miles.
Though I have seen several with bad transmissions on CL.
But for $1000 what do you expect?
130,000 isn't even high mileage on these, average for a 1996 would be at least 228,000
This has been discussed before, there should be no problem.
http://classicbroncos.com/forums/showthread.php?t=252073
Won't matter for the imbalance factor of the crank. ALL 351 Windsor motors used the same 28oz imbalance for the entire production run. It's up to you then to make sure the components you utilize are compatible with both the imbalance factor and the transmission and front accessory drive system and sensors.
One of the few stable things in our Ford world it sometimes seems!
About the only con I can think of is that it's extra plumbing. But if you have the entire motor as-is right out of the donor vehicle, it's not like you have to make something up custom. It's all right there. Still, some just want to get rid of anything that's not critical to getting an engine to start and keep the engine compartment clutter to a minimum.
Other than that, I can't really see any cons, as any extra heat up into the engine compartment is minimal and can (usually) be countered if needed.
Very. As are the engines themselves.
However, here is where you define the phrase "there are no guarantees in life" to a T.
I know several people who have put as-is Explorer donors in their rigs to save time and money and have not had one problem. Most Explorers were probably treated pretty well, and the drivetrains were probably designed and built pretty well as well. Too bad that still doesn't guarantee anything.
So, bottom line is that chances are pretty good that you can put a 130k Explorer motor and/or a 130k 4R70W into your rig without a rebuild or even a re-seal.
But I could just never bring myself to do that. It's ingrained in me (thanks Dad!) to never go to that much work without at least making sure that everything I'm putting in is new or as-new.
And yet I'm still tempted because of all the good luck everyone else has had.
Your decision then...
Paul
It looks like the other guys addressed most of your questions, but I'll add to it a little.
As far as one year being better over the others, I'm not sure that I would worry about it enough to chase me away from a donor of any year at the right price in an effort to hold out for the "right" year.
Most people prefer the 96 for non P heads and internal EGR. I kind of like the 98 because of the MUTT reasons, especially the upgraded trans. VSS can be added or removed from any year pretty easily. There really aren't any pros or cons to 2 wire vs 3 wire cam sensor.
The 99-01 system would actually be better for a very mild 351 out of the box. While the injectors are smaller (17# @ 40 PSI), they flow more because of the higher system pressure. It ends up being 23# and some change instead of 19# that the 96-98 run.
If you were going with a hotter 351 turning some serious rpm or a stroker then the 99-01 system won't cut it in stock form and you'd want bigger injectors. That is where I'd recommend the 98 and earlier system with some bigger "Ford Racing" injectors.
Tuning for injectors isn't as simple as punching in 19# or 42#. There is quite a bit of data that goes in to exactly how they work. There are hi and lo slope settings, voltage has different effects on different injectors. Some take longer to respond before they open, so that gets accounted for as well. Fuel pressure makes a ton of difference in how they work as well. Ford Racing is nice enough to give you the data you need for all of those settings at 40 psi, which makes a mail order tune a ton easier and pretty much as accurate as a stock calibration on the early systems. You want to avoid off brands or Ebay specials because there is no data for them whatsoever.
The only problem with that is, you don't get the needed data for the 65 PSI that the 99-01 system runs at. I can get it close using basic math, but it would be much better just sticking to the early system and using the data provided by the engineers.
There are a couple of cons to EGR that weren't mentioned. Hood clearance is probably the biggest especially if you don't want to run a body lift. The other is the Explorer exhaust manifolds are pretty much required for the later years for EGR to function. Most people hate them, they are a very restrictive design. But on a stock motor I think they'd be fine, they worked for Ford, and there are a few Broncos out there running them now with no complaints. They definitely aren't something that would go under the hood of my drag car though.
EFIGuy - two quick questions. One, I understand from you that when removing the EGR, its preferable to plug the lower intake center hole where the EGR normally passes, but wouldn't that require tapping and putting shavings in the intake? Does anyone sell an intake gasket with the EGR hole eliminated? Or is plugging the best way? I'm just not sure how you pull that off without getting metal everywhere.
Second - between your 9-5 and your EFI harness builds, how in the world do you find the time to keep up with this thread like you do? Its impressive, really, and a HUGE help to those of us treading in EFI territory who otherwise would've stayed far, far away without your support.
***EDIT***
I just read about your wife and putting your harness builds on hold and it nearly brought me to tears. I'll be praying for you both, and I can't respect you more for making your most important thing the most important thing right now. I'll start leaning on my CB brothers for my ridiculous noob questions about my EFI setup.






