With some area junkyards the savings might be pretty good. But not all.
Like doghows, we're not all within easy reach of one, so acquisition cost for used parts goes way up in those cases. In time and money.
And some just don't have the desire to go junkyard hopping anymore. I still "enjoy" it somewhat. But I'd buy new every time over sweating it out with a recalcitrant part in an oily gravel pit with all the wrong tools!
Around here the yards are in pretty good supply, but they don't have as many early seventies GM trucks as they used to either. So it's a crapshoot if you can even find the right stuff. It's just a narrow range of years that have the correct parts actually. Which is part of the new/used dilemma anyway.
And around here now they charge for every nut and bolt and piece of any assembly until they're almost the same as buying new anyway. So the reasons for buying used parts are getting scarcer at least here. May be the same for other large metro areas too?
I can see some of the cost coming from increased property taxes, business practices that take time and money, and the fact that here in CA (and probably more and more places) they have to be much more diligent about what they let hit the ground. Assuming a dirt/gravel base, they have to spend more money to keep it much cleaner than in some other areas with fewer restrictions, just to keep the bad stuff out of the drinking water.
Then there are the buffoons (I include myself in this sometimes) that think you need to shred the seats and headliner to get the door off or the radio out. Or bend the trunk lid in half to get to the rear window. Or cut the computer wiring harness at the firewall to take off an injector rail. So at least some of the potential profits go away from attrition.
I'm not complaining about that though. I happen to prefer good water and healthy air and plants over cheap parts. As long as it seems fair enough on the surface.
So some junkyard prices in CA then, are totally legit to be higher than elsewhere. But it still stings when a used spindle costs more than a new one! If it wasn't getting so hard to find the new ones though, I might have more of an argument against them charging more for the old stuff than I got used to paying back in the day!
Sorry for the long segué there Pops. Just sayin' that it all depends. You can still find the parts both new and used. Just need to find out if one is better for you and if it's cheaper too.
Around here and in a lot of areas, new parts look like a good choice.
Of course, that's easy for me to say. As always!
Paul