• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

11 pack or 9 pack?

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
I have owned my Bronco for well over 15 years. 10 plus years ago i did a 3.5 inch basic lift from Toms.

It has worked flawlessly but it did have to add a "add a leaf" after about 2-3 years due to sagging. I did not at all care as the flex i am getting is so incredible.

I am going to purchase a new set of rear springs.

I am looking for opinions as to a 9 leaf 3/12 inch kit offered from a vendor and a 11 leaf pack offered by another vendor. THERE IS A PRICE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO.

What i truly like about the Tom's springs was the "PLUSH" ride quality bot on and off road!! My truck is not a trailer queen (i know sounds funny saying that here! HA-HA!) and we drive it every weekend to and from the trail head. It is VITALLY IMPORTANT that we have a soft FLEXY ride!

I also want to replace the "REAR SHACKLE" hangers for the rear springs THEY are the original from 1973!! Any advice on these would be great and much appreciated!

Whats the 2 cents out there!? ALL opinions are welcomed!

I NEED to pull the trigger on this asap!

THANKS MAN!!!:cool:;D
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,114
Springs are a hard one. A big issue with the really soft ones is getting the ride height right. Very small changes in weight have a large change in ride height. So often you find complaints that the lift is not as advertised. I don't find those complaints to be as valid as they appear simply because of modification variation.

Another thing about soft springs, they are well known for getting into axle wrap. Being soft, they wrap a lot under load and the U-joint suffers. I really like to see some sort of torque control (generally a torque arm) so the springs don't have to suffer through torque bending loads.

What's wrong with the shackle hangers? They are welded to the frame and are generally trouble free. Not a wear item. The shackles themselves are not a wear item either and unless they have had a hard life they should last forever. There are aftermarket shakles to replace ones that have had (or will have) a hard life. The bushings are consumable however.
 
OP
OP
matt w

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
Springs are a hard one. A big issue with the really soft ones is getting the ride height right. Very small changes in weight have a large change in ride height. So often you find complaints that the lift is not as advertised. I don't find those complaints to be as valid as they appear simply because of modification variation.

Another thing about soft springs, they are well known for getting into axle wrap. Being soft, they wrap a lot under load and the U-joint suffers. I really like to see some sort of torque control (generally a torque arm) so the springs don't have to suffer through torque bending loads.

What's wrong with the shackle hangers? They are welded to the frame and are generally trouble free. Not a wear item. The shackles themselves are not a wear item either and unless they have had a hard life they should last forever. There are aftermarket shakles to replace ones that have had (or will have) a hard life. The bushings are consumable however.

Thank you,
I have a "Wrap Trap" from Wild Horses to help control axle wrap. I guess i worded it wrong...I was concerned with the "shackles" themselves. I thought "now" would be a good time to replace them in order to circumvent future failure.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
While a lot depends on how the spring is made and what its capacity is. I would say that for the most part the 11 pack springs could be softer as far as ride but may have more load capacity overall and have more flex than the 9 pack springs. but like I said it depends on how there made and what there spring rates are.
Now the softer spring will tend to sag faster than the stiffer springs.
Overall I think just about any of the higher spring count springs out there today will give a very good ride.
 

garberz

Bronco Influencer
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
6,864
Loc.
Conejo Valley, Ca.
I have owned my Bronco for well over 15 years. 10 plus years ago i did a 3.5 inch basic lift from Toms.

It has worked flawlessly but it did have to add a "add a leaf" after about 2-3 years due to sagging. I did not at all care as the flex i am getting is so incredible.

I am going to purchase a new set of rear springs.

I am looking for opinions as to a 9 leaf 3/12 inch kit offered from a vendor and a 11 leaf pack offered by another vendor. THERE IS A PRICE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO.

What i truly like about the Tom's springs was the "PLUSH" ride quality bot on and off road!! My truck is not a trailer queen (i know sounds funny saying that here! HA-HA!) and we drive it every weekend to and from the trail head. It is VITALLY IMPORTANT that we have a soft FLEXY ride!

I also want to replace the "REAR SHACKLE" hangers for the rear springs THEY are the original from 1973!! Any advice on these would be great and much appreciated!

Whats the 2 cents out there!? ALL opinions are welcomed!

I NEED to pull the trigger on this asap!

THANKS MAN!!!:cool:;D

Regarding the shackles, the stock shackles allow for more articulation than the aftermarket ones. I have a couple of friends that run them, and the inside of the shackle binds on the frame before it reaches the end of its travel. The red shackle is the stock one. Something to think about if you’re wanting to use all your rear travel, and I think you do.
My shackles are original too, I carry a spare with the bushing already loaded. I’ve seen the stock shackles tear numerous times, so I can see your concern.

Mark
 

Attachments

  • 18F41427-532E-4DE9-8AF1-FED704F27D76.jpg
    18F41427-532E-4DE9-8AF1-FED704F27D76.jpg
    53.5 KB · Views: 106
  • E5088795-9A91-4DE5-8576-522BAA5C0660.jpg
    E5088795-9A91-4DE5-8576-522BAA5C0660.jpg
    83.8 KB · Views: 109

Jluck

Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2017
Messages
118
If I was happy with a product that i had for 10 years, I don't care if the leafs had 8 or 20 leafs I wouldn't even think about buying another vendor's product personally.
 

garberz

Bronco Influencer
Joined
Jun 24, 2007
Messages
6,864
Loc.
Conejo Valley, Ca.
If I was happy with a product that i had for 10 years, I don't care if the leafs had 8 or 20 leafs I wouldn't even think about buying another vendor's product personally.

It too bad you can’t buy some of the products the vendors had 10 years ago. The newer parts are supposed to be better, but that’s not always the case. Sometimes I think the older springs were better quality than the new stuff being offered.

Mark
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
I was going to agree with that sentiment! But if you can't get them, you can't get them.
I'm curious though. You said the "basic Tom's spring" is what you have. Is that one of the flexy 9, 10, or 11 leaf packs, or their standard style with 5, or 6 leaves?
If those, and you think they ride pretty good, that asks the question how heavy is your rig?
Great to hear about someone who still actually wheels their Bronco as well!

From my limited experience, the 9-leaf packs have some advantages, but street ride is not one of them. Though neither are really that bad, the 11-leaf packs still seem to have the advantage in street ride.
The 9-leaf should have a slight advantage in axle-wrap reduction, but your Wrap-Trap should take care of that, and you already have it mounted. So you're generally good there.
There might also be an advantage in load capacity between one or the other, but I really don't have load range data on anyone's rears in front of me. Including our own!

To my way of thinking, the 9-leaf pack has the slight advantage in load carrying capacity, but given that some of the 11-leaf packs tend to sit high right out of the box (eh hem, WH... nod, nod. wink, wink... %););D) some of that capacity is certainly added right back into a particular 11-pack.
Loading the vehicle up simply lowers the spring closer to it's natural advertised height.
That does not equate automatically to another 10 years of added capacity, but it's a good beginning.

That's about all the insight I have at the moment. I realize it's a tough decision.
I don't consider any of the EB springs truly "good" riding, because the vehicle itself is not actually designed along those lines to have the best of all those parameters. But "better" is still better, so I agree the search is important.

Good luck on that score!

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Do your current springs have the double-wrap front eye? If not, this change would be a good time to take a close look at the condition and location of your bolt holes in the hangers.
With the added girth of the double-wrap (at least with ours) the outer wrap gets close to the hanger itself. This has never caused any trouble that I'm aware of, but being that all Broncos are different, as we've found out, some of the leaves will actually touch metal as they flex.

Sometimes this is due to the difference in an individual spring, sometimes due to the individual differences in hole location, and often as not, due to the hole being slightly wobbled out.
I know the holes in my '71 were wobbled out oval before the rig was ten years old. With your wheeling experiences and different springs in it's life, it should be worth checking the ones on your rig out.

I just filled mine a little, but the next time I have them out I'm going to add some Ruff-Stuff weld-washers and actually lower the front holes by about a half diameter of the bolt. As little as 1/8" is fine, but I'll probably go 1/4" on mine.

Just some food for thought.

Paul
 

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
WH 11 leaf packs ride pretty darn soft.
I am running them.

I have two Buddy's with different springs.
Duff 11 pack and BC 9 pack.
Both running Bilsteins.

Duffs are softer. With the Duff Torque Tamer to control axle wrap, he has the best of both worlds.

The BC springs are a bit stiffer but not objectionable at all and those Bilsteins help a lot.

All of these fat leaf packs are better than the old "over-arched" 5 leaf packs.
You really can't go wrong. Just watch your shipping costs. These boogers are heavy.

Duff-Tennessee
JBG-Michigan
BC-Texas
WH-California
TBP-Oregon
 
OP
OP
matt w

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
Regarding the shackles, the stock shackles allow for more articulation than the aftermarket ones. I have a couple of friends that run them, and the inside of the shackle binds on the frame before it reaches the end of its travel. The red shackle is the stock one. Something to think about if you’re wanting to use all your rear travel, and I think you do.
My shackles are original too, I carry a spare with the bushing already loaded. I’ve seen the stock shackles tear numerous times, so I can see your concern.

Mark

Thanks Mark!! ya that's what i want, the most possible flex. With that said I will go ahead and keep the stocker's and like you get 2nd set for "in case"! ha!!;D:cool:
 

Jluck

Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 27, 2017
Messages
118
It too bad you can’t buy some of the products the vendors had 10 years ago. The newer parts are supposed to be better, but that’s not always the case. Sometimes I think the older springs were better quality than the new stuff being offered.

Mark

Interesting way to approach life for sure. Maybe I'm a brand bitch but it doesn't matter if I'm talking guns, bullets, tools, appliances or most anything else, if something gives me a decade plus of reliable service (and am happy with) I'm not switching to something else. Good luck as I'm sure most of the well known Bronco parts houses have satisfactory springs as Id tend too think there all built at a handful of well known spring manufacturers. .
 
OP
OP
matt w

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
It too bad you can’t buy some of the products the vendors had 10 years ago. The newer parts are supposed to be better, but that’s not always the case. Sometimes I think the older springs were better quality than the new stuff being offered.

Mark

I agree Mark... i believe these 10 year old springs are 11 pack as well...they now offer 9...that's why i'm asking the questions
 
OP
OP
matt w

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
Do your current springs have the double-wrap front eye? If not, this change would be a good time to take a close look at the condition and location of your bolt holes in the hangers.
With the added girth of the double-wrap (at least with ours) the outer wrap gets close to the hanger itself. This has never caused any trouble that I'm aware of, but being that all Broncos are different, as we've found out, some of the leaves will actually touch metal as they flex.

Sometimes this is due to the difference in an individual spring, sometimes due to the individual differences in hole location, and often as not, due to the hole being slightly wobbled out.
I know the holes in my '71 were wobbled out oval before the rig was ten years old. With your wheeling experiences and different springs in it's life, it should be worth checking the ones on your rig out.

I just filled mine a little, but the next time I have them out I'm going to add some Ruff-Stuff weld-washers and actually lower the front holes by about a half diameter of the bolt. As little as 1/8" is fine, but I'll probably go 1/4" on mine.

Just some food for thought.

Paul

Don't get me wrong...at this point I'm leaning towards the 11 pack! ya know years ago i used THIS mfg. to build springs for my Jeep. These were the best springs Iv'e been on. What i liked was they asked weight, winch, tools, tire chains, ice chest, etc. I have not hit them up yet,,,BUT maybe i should try them for the Bronco!? i'm wondering if anyone else had had experience with this mfg on their EB!?? http://www.alcanspring.com/order.htm
 

Rustytruck

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
10,872
Have you thought about having the springs rearched? Thus keeping the ride you like and get the heigth you want.
atlasleafspring.com
or
deaverspring.com
 
OP
OP
matt w

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
Have you thought about having the springs rearched? Thus keeping the ride you like and get the heigth you want.
atlasleafspring.com
or
deaverspring.com

That is an excellent thought however i did have to add a "leaf" to the pack due to sag after about 2-3 years i think!? its been so long i don't remember.
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,625
Loc.
PNW
Totally agree on the bushings wearing and being a consumable BUT I sure would buy new hangers...

Buy new spring hangers...those posted earlier looked like BEEF!! I would definitely upgrade as I used to eat ONE a year..seriously, one side or the other would crack and tear in half...I've been told by some that I'm hard on parts but I don't believe them! lol

My .02 on who you buy from is this...doesn't matter who the retailer is (well, ya want good service of course), it's the MANUFACTURER of the spring that you want to buy again if you've had great luck for the past 10 years.

Bilsteins make a heck of a difference compared to the old Raunchos we all used to run!!
 

chuck1022

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2017
Messages
620
I am looking for the 11 leaf stock height packs, not seeing them anywhere?
 
Top