• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Flaming River vs IDIDIT

Jolly Roger

Full Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2013
Messages
157
Want to install a tilt column in my bronco. Running a 4r70W auto trans. Would you go Flaming River or IDIDIT. Interested in pros and cons of both.
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222
I haven't used an IDIDIT but I'm on my second Flaming River. After my recycled 78-79 F-Series tilt started to get pretty worn out many years ago, I decided to switch to a Flaming River unit. It was pretty good until about 5 years ago when it started making a pretty awful grinding/squeaking noise when turning. I drive in pretty dusty/dirty environments and figured that some dust had probably gotten in the bearings.

I pulled it and sent it back to Flaming River for a rebuild at which time they told me it was an obsolete model. However, they told me they would sell me a brand new one for the cost of a rebuild ($100) so I jumped on it. The replacement doesn't make any noises but it has some slop in the tilt mechanism that I find annoying (one of the reasons I swapped out my Ford column years ago).

If I change columns in the future, I'll go with an IDIDIT.

Todd Z.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
The Ididit (and probably the FR too?) should work reasonably well with an overdrive transmission too. I have one with my 4R70 and many others are running them as well.
Lining the pointer up the first time can be finicky, and may not be perfect (mine's pretty darn close) but it works well.

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Well it's certainly not price!%)
Is that one the correct length? That would be the only true deal-breaker in most cases.
If it's a good length, then the only other things you have to do are whatever it takes to adapt it to a Bronco.
That would include using different firewall clamps and seals for the different diameter outer housing. And buying a new steering wheel (this one takes a GM based wheel, where the Direct Fit will use a Bronco wheel). And then purchasing a mounting kit of some kind to let it bolt up under the dash properly.

All that is not necessarily a big deal to some, if they have to buy a new wheel anyway, and can fab up or find proper mounts to make it a nice clean and tight install, but for many that's too much work and the costs start to add up to at least closer to the cost of a Direct Fit column.
Generic will almost always be less expensive ultimately, but not always quite as much as thought initially.

For many then, that's too much hassle and the extra cost to get one that almost literally bolts right in and uses stock EB parts as replacements is worth the extra money.
That's why we went to the trouble of having one made specifically for the Bronco in fact. Even though costs for generic had come down quite a bit over the years, it was just a big pain to make them work as well.

Paul
 

hyghlndr

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 19, 2009
Messages
5,264
Loc.
Hockessin, Delaware
I have used both and several ebay cheapie. The cheap ones have more play and are more loose, imho. I would probably go with Ididit unless on a major budget.
 

sprdv1

Contributor
REBEL
Joined
Mar 8, 2007
Messages
81,996
Never heard too many complaints on the idid its...
 

904Bronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Messages
6,720
Loc.
San Martin, CA
Lining the pointer up the first time can be finicky, and may not be perfect (mine's pretty darn close) but it works well.

Paul

Thanks Paul ;D
I spent some time on that and got it the best I could!
The one thing I do not like about either unit is that there is no illumination for the gear selector... Like the Factory has.
 

Yeller

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
7,692
Loc.
Rogers County Oklahoma
all of the cheap ones I've run have had very poor turn signal switches that would short out internally and run the battery dead or the lights would not function properly. had good luck with both Ididit and FR
 
OP
OP
J

Jolly Roger

Full Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2013
Messages
157
Thanks for the replies.. Looks like the IDIDIT is going to be the choice for me and I notice WH has free shipping on them right now.
 

Dannyboy71

Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2011
Messages
420
Thanks Paul ;D
I spent some time on that and got it the best I could!
The one thing I do not like about either unit is that there is no illumination for the gear selector... Like the Factory has.

This is my biggest grip! Get in the truck at night and you can’t see
The gear selection. That’s dumb
 

chriskent85

Full Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
293
This is my biggest grip! Get in the truck at night and you can’t see
The gear selection. That’s dumb

the cheap one I posted has the gear selector that lights up. Not sure if I selected the right length in the post but they make them in just about any length you want.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
...The one thing I do not like about either unit is that there is no illumination for the gear selector... Like the Factory has.

Yeah, my same gripe!
Thanks for bringing that up. I've been meaning to find out why this is the case. It's not like it would take much work to have our cake and eat it too.
After all, the light is there already because it's part of the turn signal switch.
Unless they're not using the auto switch for some reason?
Hmm, I'll have to look inside one now.

Luckily that's not a problem for me...:cool:;);D

Paul
 

mgb0302

Sr. Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2002
Messages
429
Jolly Roger- I have a 4R70W and an IDIDIT column. The only "issue" I ran into was the shift linkage on the 4R moves counter clockwise from P to 1st gear. In park, it is at the 3 o'clock position and moves to the 10 or 11 in 1st gear. This requires either a cable shifter mounted to the steering column inside the engine bay, OR an adjustable adaptor that replaces the stock shift linkage (Both available from LOKAR), and a small shaft with threaded heims at each end (BC Broncos) to go from column to shift linkage). I went with the adaptor and shaft. The adaptor can be clocked but I found there is only one position to mount it (11 o'clock) so that you get full range of the shift linkage. However, the issue then becomes the front driveshaft is very close to hitting the linkage if the trans is in low(1st) gear. Luckily mine does not seems to be hitting the drive shaft while in low gear but it appears to be awfully close.

My next step is to take advantage of my Baumentator so I can flip a switch and the trans remains in 1st (or no higher than 2nd) when in 4wd!!!

The other benefit of the IDIDIT is the hazard switch is on the column which allows less clutter on a custom dash.

Hope that helps.
 
OP
OP
J

Jolly Roger

Full Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2013
Messages
157
Jolly Roger- I have a 4R70W and an IDIDIT column. The only "issue" I ran into was the shift linkage on the 4R moves counter clockwise from P to 1st gear. In park, it is at the 3 o'clock position and moves to the 10 or 11 in 1st gear. This requires either a cable shifter mounted to the steering column inside the engine bay, OR an adjustable adaptor that replaces the stock shift linkage (Both available from LOKAR), and a small shaft with threaded heims at each end (BC Broncos) to go from column to shift linkage). I went with the adaptor and shaft. The adaptor can be clocked but I found there is only one position to mount it (11 o'clock) so that you get full range of the shift linkage. However, the issue then becomes the front driveshaft is very close to hitting the linkage if the trans is in low(1st) gear. Luckily mine does not seems to be hitting the drive shaft while in low gear but it appears to be awfully close.

My next step is to take advantage of my Baumentator so I can flip a switch and the trans remains in 1st (or no higher than 2nd) when in 4wd!!!

The other benefit of the IDIDIT is the hazard switch is on the column which allows less clutter on a custom dash.

Hope that helps.

That helps a lot. Interested about the Baumentator comment. I haven't bought or installed a trans controller yet as I'm in the process of the build and acquiring parts. I do plan on using mine offroad so this switch you're referring to that keeps the trans from upshifting. What's that all about and how is that different then just putting the lever in 1st or 2nd gear.
 

mgb0302

Sr. Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2002
Messages
429
JR- Highly recommend the Baumenator for a couple of reasons:
1) Customer service is through the roof! Kevin (cant remember other guy's name) is awesome. Always willing to help.

2) Functionality- can do more things with it than a 40 year car really needs but some of the things are beneficial such as:

A) it can be wired so the upshifts are limited. I.E. like I mentioned in the previous post, you can flip a switch/ button so it does not go above 1st or 2nd. YES, this is the same as dropping the shift lever all they way done but my knees tend to hit the lever when it is that far down so it is a cool feature.

B) up to 4 different shift points. So you can settings for whatever you want to set up such as normal street driving, high performance, off-road, etc. You set the shift point rpm! Even my wife's Audi A4 only has 2 shift points.

C) If you run an electrical speedo, it has a single wire (tan) that provides the signal for the speedo (i.e. no need for cable). Also, this means that you can eliminate the speedo housing that would be required for a mechanical or VSS connection. The 2-3 inches saved by eliminating that housing helped make up for the extra length of my atlas (i.e. less of a steep driveline angle).

D) it can account for 4x4 low in the speedo. Flip a switch/ button and you can see that you're doing 2 MPH while climbing a rock!!! Ha

E) the wiring for the switches is ridiculously easy. Just run the wires to a 12v switch (i.e. power to one side of the switch and wire from trans harness to other side).

F) oh yeah, if you want to spend $1200, you can get paddle shifters for your steering wheel and shift like you're driving at Nuremburg raceway!!!

Honestly it is worth the money.
 
OP
OP
J

Jolly Roger

Full Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2013
Messages
157
JR- Highly recommend the Baumenator for a couple of reasons:
1) Customer service is through the roof! Kevin (cant remember other guy's name) is awesome. Always willing to help.

2) Functionality- can do more things with it than a 40 year car really needs but some of the things are beneficial such as:

A) it can be wired so the upshifts are limited. I.E. like I mentioned in the previous post, you can flip a switch/ button so it does not go above 1st or 2nd. YES, this is the same as dropping the shift lever all they way done but my knees tend to hit the lever when it is that far down so it is a cool feature.

B) up to 4 different shift points. So you can settings for whatever you want to set up such as normal street driving, high performance, off-road, etc. You set the shift point rpm! Even my wife's Audi A4 only has 2 shift points.

C) If you run an electrical speedo, it has a single wire (tan) that provides the signal for the speedo (i.e. no need for cable). Also, this means that you can eliminate the speedo housing that would be required for a mechanical or VSS connection. The 2-3 inches saved by eliminating that housing helped make up for the extra length of my atlas (i.e. less of a steep driveline angle).

D) it can account for 4x4 low in the speedo. Flip a switch/ button and you can see that you're doing 2 MPH while climbing a rock!!! Ha

E) the wiring for the switches is ridiculously easy. Just run the wires to a 12v switch (i.e. power to one side of the switch and wire from trans harness to other side).

F) oh yeah, if you want to spend $1200, you can get paddle shifters for your steering wheel and shift like you're driving at Nuremburg raceway!!!

Honestly it is worth the money.

You've sold me on it. Your build looks like what I'm going for. I plan to do the atlas as well and I'm running a built 351w. Which atlas did you go with?
 
Top