• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Aired-down: how far per one tire revolution?

OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
My great-grandmother's self-winding watch kept stopping on her. She didn't move enough to keep it wound up. We got her a battery powered Timex instead.

My former employer, Sensata, makes a huge number of the TPMS sensors. They've probably already sto, er..... tried the idea. As a guess, current technology can't make one small/light enough to not badly affect tire balance. That, or there's too much profit in selling replacements to make it worth developing.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Some of the early aftermarket ones were just that. Self awakening and self charging. We had some at a division of Hidden Hitch that were interesting.
I think they were held on by metal strap around the entire wheel. Not integrated into the valve stem.
The system in my 2019 truck registers quickly and without the truck in motion.
 

AZ73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
3,813
Ugh, we still haven't gotten it across. The tire tread is a fixed length, it does not matter what the radius of rotation is, a tire of X diameter will have a tread length of X*PI. One rotation of the tire is one circumference worth of distance traveled. How can it be any less?


I already explained it. Multiple times. I even gave you an example with drag tires. The tire tread ISN'T a fixed length. It's not a metal rim. It's rubber, and it LOSES circumference on the contact patch due to compression of the rubber on the direction line, and expansion out the side walls. That's how it moves a SHORTER distance on the contact patch. Because a flat line is a SHORTER distance than an arc. 1-3% worth, and another 1-3% aired down. Your thought process only works of the contact patch is a line, a single point of contact on the ground Like it would be if it was a steel wheel.
Here's ANOTHER example - the diameter of the center hole of a tire is X. it's circumference is X*PI. And yet you can mount it on a rim that's (X+2")*PI. How can that be? It's STRETCHED over the rim, and then snaps back. It's circumference becomes roughly (X+1")* PI while it's going on the rim, then snaps back to X*PI. It's NOT a "fixed" length. It's just that length when nothing else is affecting it. It's not a steel tank track, it's a rubber tire. The reverse happens on the road. The contact patch COMPRESSES the rubber making it about 1.7" shorter (on a 33" tire at 35 psi.) It drops from a circumference of 103" to 102.7 Aired down to 6 lbs makes it 4" shorter - about 98.7" This is due to deflection, like the flat tire below. The outside circumference gets pushed up and doesn't touch the road making the distance traveled shorter.

The tire "deforms". It's not "fixed". At the extreme is a flat tire. What happens to the outside circumference of a tire when its flat? It gets deformed into the tire cavity. It can't compress enough so it gets pushed up into the cavity and out the sides. The part being pushed up isn't making the tire travel any distance. The distance you will travel is significantly shorter than you would if the tire was not flat. And yet the circumference it the same on the tire but the effective circumference - the distance you travel - is much smaller.


Flat.png


Real life example? 24 hours of Daytona Porsche GT3 cars need about 10 gallons of extra fuel compared to the theoretical distance their tires would travel without accounting for the smaller effective circumference. Over the 24 hour race they lose about 29 miles of distance due to effective circumference being smaller than the theoretical tire circumference of 28" race tire.


As I mentioned before in the earlier thread, tire companies know this and take it into account when they report Rev's per mile.
I pulled up BFG T/A K02 tires, 33X12.5 to use as an example.
BFG lists the diameter as 32.5". Using this circumference the math is 3.1416×32.5=102.1" 1 mile=5280 ft×12 in/ft=63,360 in.
Revolutions = D/C = 63,360/102.1=620.3 revolutions per mile.

BFG lists them at 640 revolutions per mile. Why? Because the effective circumference is shorter than the tire circumference.
Exactly 3.1" less they calculate. This is more than my 1.7" example calculation earlier and is due to flexing of the massive tread which gets squished slightly flatter due to the weight on rubber, adding to the reduction in effective circumference. Check yourself. Pick any tire.


If you're still not convinced, well, best wishes. I'm just trying to educate people.
 
OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
Yes, but you're coming to the wrong conclusion looking at the same thing that I'm looking at. That flat tire, why is it concave in that one spot? What force is causing it to do that? It doesn't want to take that shape naturally.

Are you convinced of the accuracy of those mfg's numbers, or have you verified them yourself?
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
Yes, but you're coming to the wrong conclusion looking at the same thing that I'm looking at. That flat tire, why is it concave in that one spot? What force is causing it to do that? It doesn't want to take that shape naturally.

Are you convinced of the accuracy of those mfg's numbers, or have you verified them yourself?
The mfg's numbers are "good enough" for this analysis. But this is the problem when you get into the trivial details at the boundary.

As a casual reminder, this thread started with: Inflation is proportional to axle height, which is proportional to instant center radius, which causes a significant error in reported distance traveled per mile. MOST of the zealots believe that the error is on the order of 100% Meaning that a 1% reduction in pressure results in a 1% reduction in height, and a 1% error in distance, which becomes a 1% error in speed.

The infidel reports that a 50% reduction in pressure results in a 1% reduction in speed. (and for this, you have been chastised and villified.)

But the zealots have now conceded that there is not a 1:1 relationship between pressure and reported MPH. But there IS a discrepancy between instant center radius and revolutions per mile. The analysis is this: A properly inflated Porsche Daytona radial tire has an OD of 28 inches. So in theory, if the tread were in-compressible...it would yield a distance of 28*(pi) inches per revolution, or 87.92 inches per rev. this equates to 720.65 revolutions per mile. BUT the empirical data shows that the actual revolutions per mile, when fully loaded is a STUNNING 0.88% difference. After 3300 miles, a GT3 car lost 29 miles of reported distance. The on-board telemetry did not agree with the calculated revolutions by 0.88%.

That being said, the better analysis is the BFG where the discrepancy is 640 vs 620 revolutions per mile. But wait! What nominal OD is @AZ73 using? The tread depth on a BFG KO2 is 15/32. So a bald BFG "33 inch" KO2 will be 15/16 of an inch smaller. 31-9/16 out of 32-1/2 is a 3% difference. Do you suppose BFG reports their revolutions per mile at new tread, bald tread or somewhere in between? (this is where I contend that it doesn't matter...but that's kind of the whole point.)

Lastly,@ntsqd I urge you to draw a cross section of tire as a model. If you look at the carcass of the tire, the tread / tubeless area has an inner layer of rubber, and then a build up of steel, kevlar, nylon, "belts" and then a layer of over-coated rubber, and then the tread blocks. The in-compressible "belt" layer is well above the surface of the pavement. The overall length of the in-compressible belt is the figure of merit. We casually use the OD as the approximation of the "caterpillar track" but it is really the inner belt core that approximates an in-compressible solid, while the inner rubber, and outer rubber/tread are basically in elastic deformation about the central axis of the belt core. This accommodates the error observed and calculated by the Germans. Nobody is reporting the length of the in-compressible solid. But I would imagine it accounts for another 1% reduction in error.

Lastly lastly...if you consider the typical low profile run-flat tire. You can have zero pressure, and still have similar revolutions per mile.

Last lastly...The error in the zealot analysis is the assumption that the instant center radius is (Pi *D) to belt length. Your assertion is that belt length is 99% fixed. The alternate assertion is that the instant center equates 99% to a circumference. It does not.
 

ssray

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2010
Messages
922
Loc.
South Central NE
Here's ANOTHER example - the diameter of the center hole of a tire is X. it's circumference is X*PI. And yet you can mount it on a rim that's (X+2")*PI. How can that be? It's STRETCHED over the rim, and then snaps back. It's circumference becomes roughly (X+1")* PI while it's going on the rim, then snaps back to X*PI. It's NOT a "fixed" length. It's just that length when nothing else is affecting it. It's not a steel tank track, it's a rubber tire.
I think I would remove this example. It sounds like you've never changed a tire from this statement. 1. A tire bead has a steel bead wire/wires in it. Tough stuff when you cut through it. 2. When mounting, the drop center is what allows getting the tire on. It only needs to stretch in two directions to get over the maximum diameter and the rest of the tire deforms enough to allow that. Similar process the rest of the way
 
OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
There is steel in the tire beads just as there is in the tread. The tire will only stretch (or shrink) at the bead as much as that steel will allow it to. It can, however, deform from being round and that deformation is what allows the bead to be fit over the lip on the wheel.

Good point on the steel and other reinforcements not being at the very max OD of a tire. It is those belts that really "fix" the length of the tread.

I've been wrong before. I likely have parts of this wrong. I'm hoping to clarify and learn myself.
 
Last edited:

Chiclassics

Full Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2025
Messages
253
I did some math below..someone has to test the %s at different air pressures indicated at the bottom of this post.

Assumptions:
  • Tire size: 225/55R17 (section height ≈ 0.12375 m; rim radius 17″ ≈ 0.4318 m → tire radius RRR ≈ 0.5556 m)
  • Load on that wheel: 1000 lb ≈ 4448 N (typical axle load for a mid-size car)
  • Tire width: 225 mm = 0.225 m
  • Pressures: 32 PSI → P32=32×6894.76 Pa=220 632 PaP_{32}=32\times6894.76\ \text{Pa}=220\,632\ \text{Pa}P32=32×6894.76 Pa=220632 Pa and 5 PSI → P5=5×6894.76 Pa=34 473.8 PaP_{5}=5\times6894.76\ \text{Pa}=34\,473.8\ \text{Pa}P5=5×6894.76 Pa=34473.8 Pa
The Math:
  1. Contact patch area A=load/Pressure
    • A32=4448/220632=0.02016 m2
    • A5=4448/34473.8=0.12903 m2
  2. Contact patch length L=A/widthL = A / \text{width}L=A/width.
    • L32=0.02016/0.225= 0.0896 (≈ 9.0 cm)
    • L5=0.12903/0.225= 0.5735 (≈ 57.3 cm — very large flattening at 5 PSI)
  3. Flattening (sagitta) for a chord of length L on a circle radius R:
    s= R - sqrt{R^2 - (L/2)^2}
    • s32≈0.00181 m
    • s5≈0.07972 m
  4. Effective rolling radius Reff=R−s Then circumference C=2πReff
    • C32≈3.4793 m
    • C5≈2.9897 m
  5. Percent change in distance per rotation:
    C5−C32/C32≈−14.1%.


At 5 PSI the wheel travels ~14.1% less distance per rotation than at 32 PSI.
At 10 PSI it’s ~3.1% less.
By 15–25 PSI the change is small (under 1%).
 
Last edited:

bmc69

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
12,015
The mfg's numbers are "good enough" for this analysis. But this is the problem when you get into the trivial details at the boundary.

As a casual reminder, this thread started with: Inflation is proportional to axle height, which is proportional to instant center radius, which causes a significant error in reported distance traveled per mile. MOST of the zealots believe that the error is on the order of 100% Meaning that a 1% reduction in pressure results in a 1% reduction in height, and a 1% error in distance, which becomes a 1% error in speed.

The infidel reports that a 50% reduction in pressure results in a 1% reduction in speed. (and for this, you have been chastised and villified.)

But the zealots have now conceded that there is not a 1:1 relationship between pressure and reported MPH. But there IS a discrepancy between instant center radius and revolutions per mile. The analysis is this: A properly inflated Porsche Daytona radial tire has an OD of 28 inches. So in theory, if the tread were in-compressible...it would yield a distance of 28*(pi) inches per revolution, or 87.92 inches per rev. this equates to 720.65 revolutions per mile. BUT the empirical data shows that the actual revolutions per mile, when fully loaded is a STUNNING 0.88% difference. After 3300 miles, a GT3 car lost 29 miles of reported distance. The on-board telemetry did not agree with the calculated revolutions by 0.88%.

That being said, the better analysis is the BFG where the discrepancy is 640 vs 620 revolutions per mile. But wait! What nominal OD is @AZ73 using? The tread depth on a BFG KO2 is 15/32. So a bald BFG "33 inch" KO2 will be 15/16 of an inch smaller. 31-9/16 out of 32-1/2 is a 3% difference. Do you suppose BFG reports their revolutions per mile at new tread, bald tread or somewhere in between? (this is where I contend that it doesn't matter...but that's kind of the whole point.)

Lastly,@ntsqd I urge you to draw a cross section of tire as a model. If you look at the carcass of the tire, the tread / tubeless area has an inner layer of rubber, and then a build up of steel, kevlar, nylon, "belts" and then a layer of over-coated rubber, and then the tread blocks. The in-compressible "belt" layer is well above the surface of the pavement. The overall length of the in-compressible belt is the figure of merit. We casually use the OD as the approximation of the "caterpillar track" but it is really the inner belt core that approximates an in-compressible solid, while the inner rubber, and outer rubber/tread are basically in elastic deformation about the central axis of the belt core. This accommodates the error observed and calculated by the Germans. Nobody is reporting the length of the in-compressible solid. But I would imagine it accounts for another 1% reduction in error.

Lastly lastly...if you consider the typical low profile run-flat tire. You can have zero pressure, and still have similar revolutions per mile.

Last lastly...The error in the zealot analysis is the assumption that the instant center radius is (Pi *D) to belt length. Your assertion is that belt length is 99% fixed. The alternate assertion is that the instant center equates 99% to a circumference. It does not.
There ya go..picking on Zealots again.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
...off, 3 miles later is inferiorating..
:rolleyes: I love a good catachrestic eggcorn! (y)
That flat tire, why is it concave in that one spot? What force is causing it to do that?
Compression between the "circular" section of tread belts, and the sidewalls; analogous to a plastic milk jug being dented. If if sealed & squeezed hard (to create internal pressure), the buckled shape holds its own (deformed) shape. Since it happened when the tire was hot, and was held in that shape during cooling, the rubber at the bend isn't trying to straighten itself the way it would if you tried to buckle a cold tire similarly.

But that's an excellent example of the "compression" I mentioned earlier, on a scale large enough to see. The steel belts in that tread are still very close to their normal (circular) length. But the tire will roll a shorter distance because it rolls on the shorter flat surface; not the (concave) round surface of the tread. It's not the radius that's causing the shorter distance; it's the perimeter ("circumference", but not, since it's not a circle) being shorter due to the tread belt being compressed/wrinkled/SHORTENED (effectively). When the tire is pressurized, this still happens (to some degree, but not nearly as visibly), and that tread doesn't buckle away from the pavement - it scrubs, all the time. It compresses going into the leading half of the contact patch, and then stretches (ONLY back to its original length) coming out of the trailing half.
The in-compressible "belt" layer...
The belts are in-extensible, but they ARE compressible, just like any flexible member (rope, cable, chain).
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
The belts are in-extensible, but they ARE compressible, just like any flexible member (rope, cable, chain).
The belts are incompressible in the load regime under consideration.

(The boundary conditions are 15-50 psi.)

Your assertion does not allow for the existence of run flats. (Which we know exist). Are you postulating that run flats at zero psi do not rely on the relative incompressibility of the belt to suspend the tire?
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
The belts are incompressible in the load regime under consideration.
Yes, they are, as I've said at least twice already. If they can't compress, how do they change shape from circular to partially-circular with a flat segment (the contact patch)? Where did that arc length go?
Your assertion does not allow for the existence of run flats.
We weren't discussing run-flats or moon-rover wire tires or Mars-rover billet Aluminum wheels or ballasted ag tires or non-pneumatic tires or...

And my assertion that you quoted doesn't preclude or include them, or bumble bees, or unicorns.

Your assertion does not allow for chinese finger traps, which we know exist. And that's exactly how braided wire (like tire tread belts & RFI straps) easily compress.

(click this text)

Are you postulating that run flats at zero psi do not rely on the relative incompressibility of the belt to suspend the tire?
That's not a postulation - it's a fact. The tread belts support virtually none of the vehicle's weight when the tire (run-flat OR conventional) is flat because 1) they're compressible, and 2) they're at the wrong orientation to gravity - either the sidewalls are stiffened to bear the lion's share, or a secondary "tire" (usually non-pneumatic) is added inside between the primary tire & the wheel. But they're NOT stiffened with appreciably more steel (belts or otherwise); they're mainly stiffened with more rubber.
 
OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
Do not confuse flexible with compressible or stretchable.

Pressure vulcanize a Chinese finger trap full of rubber and report back on it's ability to change length.
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
Yes, they are, as I've said at least twice already. If they can't compress, how do they change shape from circular to partially-circular with a flat segment (the contact patch)? Where did that arc length go?

We weren't discussing run-flats or moon-rover wire tires or Mars-rover billet Aluminum wheels or ballasted ag tires or non-pneumatic tires or...

And my assertion that you quoted doesn't preclude or include them, or bumble bees, or unicorns.

Your assertion does not allow for chinese finger traps, which we know exist. And that's exactly how braided wire (like tire tread belts & RFI straps) easily compress.

(click this text)
1. Are we speaking the same language? They change shape because they deflect. How does a push chain work? Is it compressible? NO. Does it deflect? Of course it does.

You are conflating buckling and deformation with compressibility. This is a flawed analysis.
Is water compressible? (generally no) Does it deform under load? (absolutely)
Is steel compressible? (within its allowable modulus, no) Will a steel rod buckle? Certainly.

@ntsqd types faster than I do. And of course he's right.
 
Top