The mfg's numbers are "good enough" for this analysis. But this is the problem when you get into the trivial details at the boundary.
As a casual reminder, this thread started with: Inflation is proportional to axle height, which is proportional to instant center radius, which causes a significant error in reported distance traveled per mile. MOST of the zealots believe that the error is on the order of 100% Meaning that a 1% reduction in pressure results in a 1% reduction in height, and a 1% error in distance, which becomes a 1% error in speed.
The infidel reports that a 50% reduction in pressure results in a 1% reduction in speed. (and for this, you have been chastised and villified.)
But the zealots have now conceded that there is not a 1:1 relationship between pressure and reported MPH. But there IS a discrepancy between instant center radius and revolutions per mile. The analysis is this: A properly inflated Porsche Daytona radial tire has an OD of 28 inches. So in theory, if the tread were in-compressible...it would yield a distance of 28*(pi) inches per revolution, or 87.92 inches per rev. this equates to 720.65 revolutions per mile. BUT the empirical data shows that the actual revolutions per mile, when fully loaded is a STUNNING 0.88% difference. After 3300 miles, a GT3 car lost 29 miles of reported distance. The on-board telemetry did not agree with the calculated revolutions by 0.88%.
That being said, the better analysis is the BFG where the discrepancy is 640 vs 620 revolutions per mile. But wait! What nominal OD is
@AZ73 using? The tread depth on a BFG KO2 is 15/32. So a bald BFG "33 inch" KO2 will be 15/16 of an inch smaller. 31-9/16 out of 32-1/2 is a 3% difference. Do you suppose BFG reports their revolutions per mile at new tread, bald tread or somewhere in between? (this is where I contend that it doesn't matter...but that's kind of the whole point.)
Lastly,
@ntsqd I urge you to draw a cross section of tire as a model. If you look at the carcass of the tire, the tread / tubeless area has an inner layer of rubber, and then a build up of steel, kevlar, nylon, "belts" and then a layer of over-coated rubber, and then the tread blocks. The in-compressible "belt" layer is well above the surface of the pavement. The overall length of the in-compressible belt is the figure of merit. We casually use the OD as the approximation of the "caterpillar track" but it is really the inner belt core that approximates an in-compressible solid, while the inner rubber, and outer rubber/tread are basically in elastic deformation about the central axis of the belt core. This accommodates the error observed and calculated by the Germans. Nobody is reporting the length of the in-compressible solid. But I would imagine it accounts for another 1% reduction in error.
Lastly lastly...if you consider the typical low profile run-flat tire. You can have zero pressure, and still have similar revolutions per mile.
Last lastly...The error in the zealot analysis is the assumption that the instant center radius is (Pi *D) to belt length. Your assertion is that belt length is 99% fixed. The alternate assertion is that the instant center equates 99% to a circumference. It does not.