The dash in my '68 was painted a semi-custom, fairly glossy parchment lookalike and it's pretty nice. Too much gloss in front of me doesn't always make me happy, but this one I like.
Goes good with the other white features in the pale blue (Peacock Blue) rig.
Not long ago I drove my soon-to-be-ex-favorite '72 Explorer model in Orange and that body color dash drove me nuts within two minutes of getting in and heading down the road.
Just way too bright of a color right in front of me all the time.
A body color dash in a more subdued color on the other hand would likely not have been as antagonizing, but not completely sure after that experience.
My old low-gloss Parchment in the '71 was never "cool" enough and I always wanted a different color. But now I'm not so sure it wasn't a better color than I gave it credit for.
Good luck in the choice!
Paul