I visited a very reputable restauration shop here in Houston this week. They restore 10-12 EB's a year, and over a 100 vehicles a year. Most of their work is on Chevy's, but about 25% is Ford products, and all classic vehicles.
I'm now more confused as they told me I should stray away from the 408 and drop in a 347 (only 35 less HP @ 415). Their issue has been the cam in the 408 being too big. They feel that the Blueprint 347 is a perfect fit for a Bronco. That's their number one engine of choice due to torque, HP, and compression ratio of 10.1.
They also expressed concerns with EFI (Holley, Pro Flow, etc) becasue they are so dificult to tune due to the extreme termperature swings we see here in Houston. They said go carb all day long.
I wouldn't say this if I wasn't so biased from building more than a few and wheeled with more than a few sb strokers for several decades.
2 main points:
- No way is this shop experienced in owning, driving or wheeling an EB. Sorry but they aren't long term anyway. Maybe to tune it but that's it and here' s why. HP and torque are two totall different entities & they know this but didn't share anything but an HP # with you. Torque gets 5,000#'s moving. The difference is not seat of the pants feel it is VERY REAL and very satisfying to know that when you need it, it's there. When wheeling depending on the terrain then it's a gamechanger on a heavy vehicle with large OD tires. This isn't a Mustang with 26.5" tires.
Try to believe me when I say this- you can't kill the torque in a 408 with a "cam being too big". I mean if it won't idle it's too big but I run over 250 duration @ .050" lift and over .609" lift with 1.65 rockers and my 460 sb idles at 775rpm and probably has 200 more ft lbs of torque at 2K rpm than a 347. There is no comparison- none.
- Tuning. Temperature swings affecting tuning? Altitude affecting tuning but not temp. Temp is EZ to tune. Air density without mass air is not. Houston does not have the temp swings I have here. Zero degree days with sub -10 and sub -20 degree days that I have started right up and driven off in- yes, I pull my tube doors and run my full doors but still run my windbreaker behind the front seats (1/2 cab). I commonly get 100 deg summer days that my rig starts up fine and we had record 115deg heat 4 summers ago. 95 deg days and 57deg nights are common here in the Valley-that's a temp swing.
I know guys running TermX and no issue- zip. Altitude is a totally different game and because neither the TermX or ProFlo have mass air that is their major tuning fault. I have spoken at length with 3 different Holley techs strictly about altitude and know how to deal with this now when let's say I load my trailer at my 1800ft elevation and tow to CO to 6K feet or Moab at 4K ft. Any non-mass air vehicle will eventually adapt to the difference but takes time and won't be perfect but decent. Usually a bit rough for a while. Same when you get home.
Do not let these guys tell you a cam is too big for a 408 unless it's a monster (by my stds) and then usually it's the lift limitations on the valves for that head that would limit you.
These guys are biased and it's not a legit bias either. It's personal or they had trouble with something once and now want to practice the KISS method since they can tune a 347. I know, rough but they must have had a problem that nobody else had/has because that problem ain't real.
HP comparison between a 347 and a 408 might only be whatever small amount they quoted you (probably with the 347 cam in the 408 block to get such low numbers for a 408 BUT its the TORQUE that you want and everyone notices with a big block cubed yet small block stroker. They said only 35 more HP? Seriously, if they got the smallest cam from a stock 289 and put it in a 408 and dyno'd it the numbers for the 408 and used a large cam for the 347 then it might be only 50-75hp more than a 347 but if you properly size all the parts then the 408 will blow the pants off the 347. You have 63 more cubes in the 408. At 1.5hp per cube that means you should/could/outta have 90 more hp and a LOT higher torque #'s between the two.
Carb is fine if you're never wheeling it. Street rods run carbs all day every day and no issues. Save a bunch of coin too.
Sorry I wrote a book but you said you were a bit confused and this shop is pointing you towards their comfort zone for some reason and it probably has to do with the difference of bolting on a carb and it runs decent and nobody complains compared to wiring up an injection system and having to get it to run properly compared to the absolutely simplicity of bolting on a carb. If this shop puts out 100 vehicles/year then this is their go to familar for what works for them. Takes 20 minutes to unpack a carb and bolt it on-literally. Takes a little more time than that for efi.
Street queen? Go 408 w/Vic Jr and never look back.
Yes, I'm biased towards the stroker because once again I'll say it, not ONE person who has installed a sbf stroker has regretted it that I know. Not a one.