• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Dana 44 ball joint pre load question

widowmaker77

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
564
As I’m putting my cut and turned 73 bronco
Dana 44 back together, I’m trying to do all the stuff I’ve never done in the past (example) I’m trying to pre load the new ball joints correctly. I’ve set the adjuster to get a straight pull of 23-25 lbs. once I torqued the top ball joint nut to 100ft lbs, the hubs are extremely hard to turn side to side. I understand I should not pay attention to these readings after I torqued the top nut but in order to move the hub it takes around 50ft lbs of pull to move each hub separately. Does this sound normal? Again this is my first time actually trying to set ball joint preload.
 

Apogee

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 26, 2005
Messages
6,348
Loc.
Tangent, OR
Did you tighten the bottom ball joint to 100 ft-lb, torque the sleeve to 40 ft-lb with the special socket, check the turn effort (~25 pounds), torque the top nut to 100 ft-lb, then recheck the pull effort? If there's a big difference between the top ball joint nut be torqued or not, I'd be concerned that it wasn't fully seated if/when you torqued the sleeve or that the bottom joint was fully seated to begin with. You can always go back and loosen up the sleeve a bit to get the pull effort where you want it to be...too high, and your steering will feel sticky and possibly not want to return to center on it's own (assuming you have adequate caster to make that happen).
 
OP
OP
widowmaker77

widowmaker77

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
564
Yeah I did all that. Torqued the bottom to 90lbs then torqued the sleeve to 25. Then I checked the pull and adjusted sleeve until I reached 25ish pounds of pull. Torqued the upper nut to 100lbs and that’s when I saw it was really hard to turn so I re checked the pull to see how much it went up after I torqued the top nut and saw it was around 50ft. Lbs now. I think i
Will go back and loosen the adjuster until I get 25 again the re toque the top nut.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
widowmaker77

widowmaker77

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
564
Loosened the adjusters and re set my pull to 25 films. Torqued top castle to 100lbs. Rechecked my pull and with everything torqued down I’m sittting at 25ilbs of pull now. So I’m not sure what happened the first time but I’m saying it’s good now. Thanks for the help @Apogee !!
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Something is (sorry, was) wrong with your method.
You don’t check the pull torque until the top nut has been torqued. You don’t even care what the pull effort is until it’s entirely assembled.
The specification for pull torque is only after it’s fully assembled. That means put your inner sleeve down to whatever it will torque to, then torque the top nut to its final specification.
Then, and only then, check your effort on the knuckle. I don’t believe the book says anything about checking it before and after. Unless you have a different book.
There’s no need to check it before hand because obviously it changes after you’ve done the final.
So you were absolutely right to question the extra tightness you were seeing.

The reason I say “whatever the sleeve will torque to” is because we’ve been having problems for years now getting the full torque on the sleeve.
Turn it to whatever it’ll go to before you start seeing more than two threads below the top yoke. If you’re nowhere near 40 pounds, so be it. The last several I’ve done barely made it to 20 pounds.
We’ve had several further discussions about it here on the forums and many others have experienced the same discrepancy. 30 years ago we didn’t have any trouble with new parts. Now it seems like even simple, mechanical bits like this are out of spec brand new!

I’m glad you got it down to a reasonable amount. But you spent a lot of time trying to get it to the maximum that it’s supposed to be.
The specification is “less than” 26 pounds.
Anything between 5 pounds and 25 pounds therefore, is within spec.

One thing that may have changed is the ball joints getting the lubrication more evenly spread or some other natural occurrence after having moved them around quite a bit during the extended installation process.
 
OP
OP
widowmaker77

widowmaker77

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
564
Something is (sorry, was) wrong with your method.
You don’t check the pull torque until the top nut has been torqued. You don’t even care what the pull effort is until it’s entirely assembled.
The specification for pull torque is only after it’s fully assembled. That means put your inner sleeve down to whatever it will torque to, then torque the top nut to its final specification.
Then, and only then, check your effort on the knuckle. I don’t believe the book says anything about checking it before and after. Unless you have a different book.
There’s no need to check it before hand because obviously it changes after you’ve done the final.
So you were absolutely right to question the extra tightness you were seeing.

The reason I say “whatever the sleeve will torque to” is because we’ve been having problems for years now getting the full torque on the sleeve.
Turn it to whatever it’ll go to before you start seeing more than two threads below the top yoke. If you’re nowhere near 40 pounds, so be it. The last several I’ve done barely made it to 20 pounds.
We’ve had several further discussions about it here on the forums and many others have experienced the same discrepancy. 30 years ago we didn’t have any trouble with new parts. Now it seems like even simple, mechanical bits like this are out of spec brand new!

I’m glad you got it down to a reasonable amount. But you spent a lot of time trying to get it to the maximum that it’s supposed to be.
The specification is “less than” 26 pounds.
Anything between 5 pounds and 25 pounds therefore, is within spec.

One thing that may have changed is the ball joints getting the lubrication more evenly spread or some other natural occurrence after having moved them around quite a bit during the extended installation process.
Thanks for the explanation @DirtDonk ! Guess I need to do some more research on this. I was following the procedure monster Mike explained on one of his monster garage videos.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Well, I have to say he’s usually very accurate. So I better go back and reread the manual myself!
But I don’t remember any mention of testing pull effort until the very last step.
 
OP
OP
widowmaker77

widowmaker77

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
564
Well, I have to say he’s usually very accurate. So I better go back and reread the manual myself!
But I don’t remember any mention of testing pull effort until the very last step.
This is the video I was referring to.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Finally got my computer back connected. The phone is awkward sometimes!
Thought I'd seen all their vids, but think I missed this one originally. Thanks for sharing it.

But, per the book...
"Torque lower nut to 70-90lbs"
"Adjust sleeve to 40lbs"
"Torque upper nut to 100lbs"
"Check pull-torque to LESS THAN 26lbs"
This per the older Chilton's '66 to '77 Bronco book. Older brown colored Haynes book dittos this.
My still older Chilton's '66-'73 Bronco book mirrors these. I have not looked at my '71 Bronco Factory Manual (on disk unfortunately) yet.
Never seen any book mention checking the pull-torque prior to the final tightening of the nuts to finish the install. The pull check is always the last step.

By the way, regarding tightening nuts on tapered joints that might spin, this happens quite often. All the time maybe? Certainly most of the time...
Because of this common issue on ball-joints, tie-rod ends, and any other tapered joint, I bring along another floor jack, or just use the one that lifted the truck to jack-stands in the first place, and push up on the lower joint. Job done! You can use any tool you have handy to lift/put pressure on the knuckle, but a floor jack is the ticket if you have one handy.
Like Mike said, make sure the Zerk fitting is not in place. Leave it out, or if it's already installed, remove it.

Paul
 

Beresb

Contributor
New Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2020
Messages
34
Loc.
Alberta
Something is (sorry, was) wrong with your method.
You don’t check the pull torque until the top nut has been torqued. You don’t even care what the pull effort is until it’s entirely assembled.
The specification for pull torque is only after it’s fully assembled. That means put your inner sleeve down to whatever it will torque to, then torque the top nut to its final specification.
Then, and only then, check your effort on the knuckle. I don’t believe the book says anything about checking it before and after. Unless you have a different book.
There’s no need to check it before hand because obviously it changes after you’ve done the final.
So you were absolutely right to question the extra tightness you were seeing.

The reason I say “whatever the sleeve will torque to” is because we’ve been having problems for years now getting the full torque on the sleeve.
Turn it to whatever it’ll go to before you start seeing more than two threads below the top yoke. If you’re nowhere near 40 pounds, so be it. The last several I’ve done barely made it to 20 pounds.
We’ve had several further discussions about it here on the forums and many others have experienced the same discrepancy. 30 years ago we didn’t have any trouble with new parts. Now it seems like even simple, mechanical bits like this are out of spec brand new!

I’m glad you got it down to a reasonable amount. But you spent a lot of time trying to get it to the maximum that it’s supposed to be.
The specification is “less than” 26 pounds.
Anything between 5 pounds and 25 pounds therefore, is within spec.

One thing that may have changed is the ball joints getting the lubrication more evenly spread or some other natural occurrence after having moved them around quite a bit during the extended installation process.
I just installed new ball joints from Tom’s OFFROAD & the sources I looked up said torque bottom to 90 then top sleeve to 50 then castle nut to 100. I haven’t checked with pull method but the knuckle is pretty tight to turn. Saw some report the same like Matt’s Garage but not sure of the outcome. Is there a downside?
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
A downside to being too tight? Yes. Tighter steering and inability to return to center. For starters…
Are the ball joints lubeable? If so, have you greased them?
When you torqued the upper sleeves, how far into the yoke did the sleeve extend? Got pictures?
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
widowmaker77

widowmaker77

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
564
I just installed new ball joints from Tom’s OFFROAD & the sources I looked up said torque bottom to 90 then top sleeve to 50 then castle nut to 100. I haven’t checked with pull method but the knuckle is pretty tight to turn. Saw some report the same like Matt’s Garage but not sure of the outcome. Is there a downside?
I ended up using the old threaded sleeves I took out because I never could get the preload right using the new sleeves that came with the new ball joints. You really need to get like a suitcase scale or similar and check the preload. It’s pretty tight just turning by hand but turn the knuckle a couple times back and forth before you hook the scale to it.
 

Beresb

Contributor
New Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2020
Messages
34
Loc.
Alberta
Ball joints greased. The pull would be over 50lbs as I used a scale that went to 50 and maxed out. I need to figure out how to attach pics here! I believe the sleeve went in without issue but I too used the old one as the new ones didnt fit the socket
 

Beresb

Contributor
New Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2020
Messages
34
Loc.
Alberta
Figured out how to attach pics!
 

Attachments

  • 20250409_182121_Original.jpeg
    20250409_182121_Original.jpeg
    279 KB · Views: 151
  • 20250408_172443_Original.jpeg
    20250408_172443_Original.jpeg
    197.6 KB · Views: 180

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
I thought the factory spec was 40 pounds. Don’t have the book in front of me, but you could try unscrewing the sleeve slightly and seeing if that loosens up the pull torque.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Just reread your first post again.
Why did you check the pull torque while you were adjusting the sleeve? You’re supposed to set the sleeve to a specific setting, then torque the top nut, then check the pull torque.
You do not adjust it as you are checking. The scale test is the last thing you do. There is no checking while you are torquing the sleeve.
 

Beresb

Contributor
New Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2020
Messages
34
Loc.
Alberta
I didn’t test the pull torque ahead until after I had torqued the castle nut. It moved nicely til I did the final torque to 100, so I guess I’ll go back and try again
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Sorry, but when I mentioned rereading the first post again, it was actually the first post in the thread from Widowmaker. Not yours.
Got a little mixed up with the two different discussions.
 
Top