• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Disk vs. Drum Brake Prop. Valve

Zeke

Full Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2002
Messages
191
Hey Guys,

I just bought a '74. It was converted to disk brakes using '78-'79 knuckles-out.

I don't think the brake proportioning valve was changed. Is it necessary to change this ?

I will be putting on a power brake conversion.

Will a valve off of a '78-'79 Bronco work ?

Thanks for the help !
Zeke
 

TJK74

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 21, 2003
Messages
3,154
Loc.
Newark CA
Should work fine the way it is with the stock valve. If the rears are constantly locking up then look into a proportioning valve.
 

jsniper06

Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2006
Messages
567
Loc.
Crowley, La.
I have power brakes and just did the same conversion. Did not change the proportioning valve. Works great, no problems. If I were you I would not change it.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
I have the same setup on my 73 the stock H block works fine if it stops fine now then I wouldnt change it.
 

natureboy300

Full Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2005
Messages
171
Loc.
livermore
I put the cheby disk brake conversion on mine without a power brake booster. I still have the stock prop. valve in, the rears do lock up first even with a full tank of gas, but its very close. I am probably going to change it because on decents on loose gravel it does have a little tendency to lock the rears. If its mostly street driven it will probably be just fine.

NB
 

brixter

Sr. Member
Joined
May 21, 2004
Messages
609
Loc.
Tuolumne CA
I am adding power brakes to my 70 in the morning . I am adding a proportioning valve to mine . I have 79 disks on mine as well but I know the rear locks up a little to early and I almost found out the hard way while wheeling down a very rutted steep hill. The rears kept locking up on me and kept pushing me sideways down the hill .It was pretty hairy a few times and I almost rolled it.
Normal highway driving didnt show this , like I said I almost found out the hard way.
 

SaddleUp

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 23, 2004
Messages
9,655
Loc.
Vancouver, WA
Try it without first and see if the rears lock up too early. I've run mine with 4 different configurations (drum/drum, disk/drum, disk/disk, and finally back to disk/drum again with different front disks) and the only issue I've had is that the fronts locked up first when unloading it off the trailer when when I had disk/disk if the trailer was wet. I.E. I would slide the front tires in reverse. On the street and trails though this has never presented any problem and from what I can tell it doesn't do it anymore with the current disk/drum setup.
 

Mikey

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 15, 2001
Messages
1,480
I am adding power brakes to my 70 in the morning . I am adding a proportioning valve to mine . I have 79 disks on mine as well but I know the rear locks up a little to early and I almost found out the hard way while wheeling down a very rutted steep hill. The rears kept locking up on me and kept pushing me sideways down the hill .It was pretty hairy a few times and I almost rolled it.
Normal highway driving didnt show this , like I said I almost found out the hard way.

I know I sound like a broken record but if you have a disk/drum set up, you must use a stock-like combo valve (metering/prop valves in one). If you don't, you are not safe. The two brakes work differently and you must balance the system. You can search here and the web for why (disks actuate linearly while the drums are exponential).

Most disagree with me until something like this happens. %)

My .02.

Be safe!
Mikey
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
Ok I'll say it. broken record.
But you said it. Like you said the system must be balanced. If not then you'll have problems as some people do it just happens to be that its usually the rear brakes that have the problem. If the system is not balanced then you will need something to balance it the easiest way is with a adjustable valve installed in the rear line because its usually the rear brakes with the problem. On the other hand many dont have problems because by luck the system is balanced. The action of the brakes has very little to do with system balance unless the system was designed poorly to begin with. This is more true of newer vehicles where the abs and oversized brake systems are common.
 

Mikey

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 15, 2001
Messages
1,480
Here, read this article and then decide:
http://www.thebrakeman.com/valvetechi

On the second page, the last two torque curves are duplicates (looks like a cut and paste error) so be careful as you study the curves.

Balancing includes flattening out the drum curve to better match the linear disk curve. Changing cylinder sizes only moves the two curves up or down. Hence, the actuation does matter unless its a disk/disk or drum/drum.

An adjustable proportioning valve only adjusts the drum curve at the upper end and does nothing at the lower.

If your system isn't set up right, don't drive near me and we are good.
Cheers,
Mike
 

SaddleUp

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 23, 2004
Messages
9,655
Loc.
Vancouver, WA
Note the following paragraph that is above those "Example torque curves"

"These valves should not be used unless you are positive that all system components in that combination valve fit your needs, exactly."

Also note the disclaimer: "vehicle braking, as with everything to do with performance automotive, and racing, there will be a wide variety of factors affecting outcome. This article was intended to help you see how these factors can affect your finished product." I.E. This information may or may not be correct and we will not be responsible if by following it you end up crashing.

and finally:
"FIG. 1. THIS GRAPH ILLUSTRATES WHAT KIND OF TORQUE OUTPUT WOULD BE CREATED BY A TANDEM MASTER CYLINDER PRODUCING THE SAME PRESSURE TO A FRONT DISC, REAR DRUM"
This means this chart is worthless as a comparison in real world unless the master cylinder happens to apply the same pressure to both ends which will never be the case in a disk/drum setup where the caliper and wheel cylinders both have different pressure requirements.

Sorry but having had to use my brakes in a few panic situations I just don't buy the claim or implication that my brakes are unsafe because I don't have an extra valve in them. On the contrary I know that the brakes on my EB are safer than the stock brakes on any of my other vehicles. I made sure they were because I put my EB into far more situations where the brakes must work right than I do the others.
 

Mikey

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 15, 2001
Messages
1,480
Awwww...now you guys are getting emotional over an engineering technical thing. Don't take it so personal!

Once you study the situation, the facts will guide you. Don't go on faith. I'm an engineer, I go with facts. That's all. The only reason why I care is you may drive next to me one day. Beyond that, I really don't care....except for all the other people driving next to you when you do need those brakes. I truely hope you guys are NEVER proven wrong.

Just like arguing over HP improvements, to solve those arguments, you go to a dyno to see what really works. Wonder if there's a braking test range somewhere? Seat-of-the-pants is opinion only.

Anybody out there that has worked automotive designs for a big auto company? I'd like your opinions to set us shade-tree types straight. I only flight test hi-po military jet aircraft and only the electrical at that.

Cheers and keep 'em coming....the technical side, please. Being rude and insulting will NOT win you technical points.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
Yes I jabbed.
Please reread the article you pointed out to us it tells you the same thing we seat of the pants enginners have been telling you. We just didnt have a meaningless graph. Picking through and grabbing on the info you want to prove a point doesnt gain you any technical points either.
 
Top