Hi guys,
I'm trying to rationalize through a noise that developed recently on a long drive. My mechanic has told me it's a transmission issue, but this solution doesn't make sense to me, so maybe you guys can help with my understanding.
The truck is a 69 with a 347, NP435, Trutrack, big Bronco 9in rear, GM 1 ton front, and a Dana 20 with Rock Eater gear set.
I initially noticed the problem on the highway after driving around 50 miles. I started to smell gear oil, but upon inspection, I couldn't find anything leaking.
Within 15 more miles or so, the truck started to make a loud whirring sound and vibration under load - which was worst in 3rd (or, technically 4th) gear. I pulled over and ended up getting the rig towed home (thank you AAA unlimited).
Later that week - I drove it around locally to try and troubleshoot the problem. In RWD, the same as above happened at in-town speeds. When I switched it to FWD only, the noise went away - or at least nearly. There might have been a slight residual noise as above, but not even close to the severity of RWD.
Sounds like the rear differential, then, right? The kicker - the rear diff was newly installed, and had less than 500mi on it.
I drove the truck to my mechanic (FWD, 20 miles on the highway, no problem), and told him the problems. He went through it, and got back to me saying that it was the transmission. I checked with a couple friends, who disagreed, and I asked him to check again. After some time passed, he came back again saying that it was indeed the transmission.
He mentioned they did the standard test of lifting the wheels off the ground and spinning the tires, and there was no noise made, which meant the differential should be fine.
I'm pulling the rig back to my house so that I can work on it myself, since I currently have plenty of free time thanks to the current world situation.
As an aside, I want to do the AX15 swap anyway, rather than put money into rebuilding the NP435, though this wasn't at the top of my list. Sometimes the Bronco makes the decisions for you though, right?
My concern is that, after I go through and replace the transmission, the problem won't be solved.
Questions:
1. What does this problem sound like to you?
2. Would the rear end make noise when lifted off the ground if RWD was not engaged?
3. Could this be an issue with the transfer case, as it seems to be making noise in RWD and not FWD?
Thanks for the help, and Happy Father's Day to all of you dads out there!
I'm trying to rationalize through a noise that developed recently on a long drive. My mechanic has told me it's a transmission issue, but this solution doesn't make sense to me, so maybe you guys can help with my understanding.
The truck is a 69 with a 347, NP435, Trutrack, big Bronco 9in rear, GM 1 ton front, and a Dana 20 with Rock Eater gear set.
I initially noticed the problem on the highway after driving around 50 miles. I started to smell gear oil, but upon inspection, I couldn't find anything leaking.
Within 15 more miles or so, the truck started to make a loud whirring sound and vibration under load - which was worst in 3rd (or, technically 4th) gear. I pulled over and ended up getting the rig towed home (thank you AAA unlimited).
Later that week - I drove it around locally to try and troubleshoot the problem. In RWD, the same as above happened at in-town speeds. When I switched it to FWD only, the noise went away - or at least nearly. There might have been a slight residual noise as above, but not even close to the severity of RWD.
Sounds like the rear differential, then, right? The kicker - the rear diff was newly installed, and had less than 500mi on it.
I drove the truck to my mechanic (FWD, 20 miles on the highway, no problem), and told him the problems. He went through it, and got back to me saying that it was the transmission. I checked with a couple friends, who disagreed, and I asked him to check again. After some time passed, he came back again saying that it was indeed the transmission.
He mentioned they did the standard test of lifting the wheels off the ground and spinning the tires, and there was no noise made, which meant the differential should be fine.
I'm pulling the rig back to my house so that I can work on it myself, since I currently have plenty of free time thanks to the current world situation.
As an aside, I want to do the AX15 swap anyway, rather than put money into rebuilding the NP435, though this wasn't at the top of my list. Sometimes the Bronco makes the decisions for you though, right?
My concern is that, after I go through and replace the transmission, the problem won't be solved.
Questions:
1. What does this problem sound like to you?
2. Would the rear end make noise when lifted off the ground if RWD was not engaged?
3. Could this be an issue with the transfer case, as it seems to be making noise in RWD and not FWD?
Thanks for the help, and Happy Father's Day to all of you dads out there!











