• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Drivetrain Noise Diagnosis

Amitchla

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
59
Hi guys,

I'm trying to rationalize through a noise that developed recently on a long drive. My mechanic has told me it's a transmission issue, but this solution doesn't make sense to me, so maybe you guys can help with my understanding.

The truck is a 69 with a 347, NP435, Trutrack, big Bronco 9in rear, GM 1 ton front, and a Dana 20 with Rock Eater gear set.

I initially noticed the problem on the highway after driving around 50 miles. I started to smell gear oil, but upon inspection, I couldn't find anything leaking.

Within 15 more miles or so, the truck started to make a loud whirring sound and vibration under load - which was worst in 3rd (or, technically 4th) gear. I pulled over and ended up getting the rig towed home (thank you AAA unlimited).

Later that week - I drove it around locally to try and troubleshoot the problem. In RWD, the same as above happened at in-town speeds. When I switched it to FWD only, the noise went away - or at least nearly. There might have been a slight residual noise as above, but not even close to the severity of RWD.

Sounds like the rear differential, then, right? The kicker - the rear diff was newly installed, and had less than 500mi on it.

I drove the truck to my mechanic (FWD, 20 miles on the highway, no problem), and told him the problems. He went through it, and got back to me saying that it was the transmission. I checked with a couple friends, who disagreed, and I asked him to check again. After some time passed, he came back again saying that it was indeed the transmission.

He mentioned they did the standard test of lifting the wheels off the ground and spinning the tires, and there was no noise made, which meant the differential should be fine.

I'm pulling the rig back to my house so that I can work on it myself, since I currently have plenty of free time thanks to the current world situation.

As an aside, I want to do the AX15 swap anyway, rather than put money into rebuilding the NP435, though this wasn't at the top of my list. Sometimes the Bronco makes the decisions for you though, right?

My concern is that, after I go through and replace the transmission, the problem won't be solved.

Questions:

1. What does this problem sound like to you?
2. Would the rear end make noise when lifted off the ground if RWD was not engaged?
3. Could this be an issue with the transfer case, as it seems to be making noise in RWD and not FWD?

Thanks for the help, and Happy Father's Day to all of you dads out there!
 

doran4x

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2004
Messages
405
Drive it and take temp reading of transmission and rear end. If it’s bearing failure it will show a much higher temp.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

B RON CO

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 29, 2016
Messages
2,484
Loc.
Statesville, NC
Hi, the temp gun check is a good idea.
Next I would pull the rear driveshaft and spin each wheel. Next take the wheels off so so can spin the rear end yoke by hand. Any tightness, lumpiness and noise and you need to pull the diff. I would probably pull the diff anyway, for inspection, because it is the easiest thing to do.
You can pull the front driveshaft and spin the yokes on the Dana 20 while in neutral. If a helper steps on the clutch you can try each gear. I don't think I ever tried to spin a tranny from the output shaft while someone held the clutch, but why not.
Before we install a manual transmission in any car I go through each gear and see how it feels when I spin it through the input shaft.
Good luck
 

oldiron

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 21, 2005
Messages
1,054
Do you not trust your mechanic? If not, take it to another shop that you trust and get a second opinion.
Greg
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
The rear end is still full-width? Was it checked for trueness?
And what about the wheel bearings? Were they new, and did they use the factory retainer plates, or aftermarket?

Assuming they were the tapered roller bearings, is there any chance that an inner seal was installed anyway? They're meant to be used with sealed ball bearing setups only, so that could have cooked a bearing at higher speeds.
Is there any gear oil weepage at the vent tube? How high is the vent hose routed?

What's the deal with a GM 1ton front end? Assuming it's a Dana 60 of course, but presumably it was changed so that it had a driver's side diff instead of the GM/Dodge/Jeep passenger side diff?

What kind of oil are you using in your NP435? If it's gear oil then it's still possible that the transmission was overheating. But a lot less likely due to the test that showed the noise being much less in FWD. As you figured, the ONLY thing isolated in FWD is the rear end and the rear driveshaft.
However, the load dynamics in the transfer case has changed as well, so I could see something wrong in the t-case acting different between FWD and RWD only modes.
What gear lube are you using in the t-case? If it's too thick it might not be splashing up into the rear output housing enough to efficiently lube the bearings. With the new lower crawler gears installed, I don't know what has changed in that relationship, but it would probably be worth looking at the transfer case too.
Or at least not ignoring it!

And speaking of which, could the smell have been burning grease? Perhaps the driveshaft CV head or u-joints are failing? Very easy to over-tighten the u-bolts on the rear u-joint, and also easy to forget to lube the centering ball's female zerk fitting.

Is the driveshaft still off? How much rotational play is there in the rear end? Since it's almost new it should be very tight. You should only be able to move the yoke a few thousandths of an inch. If it's more like 3/8 to 1/2 inch on the other hand, while a 9" can live like that for a long time, it's not a good sign for such a newly built one.
I don't actually know how a Truetrac would make it act though, so maybe there is some play inherent in that unit. I know you can get a lot of strange rotational movement in a Detroit Locker. Makes it feel like the backlash is way too loose, but in fact the play is in the locker unit itself.
Not sure if the limited-slip Truetrac has any of the same characteristics. Mine is half buried so I can't check it right away to answer that.

Good luck.

Paul
 
OP
OP
A

Amitchla

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
59
@doran and @RON - thanks for the input! I'll do a temp check on these when I get the truck back this week, and report back.

@oldiron - I do trust him, I just want to logically understand how this makes sense as the transmission.

@DirtDonk - great points across the board, and a good many questions that I currently don't have answers to, so I'll have to investigate further.

I bought the truck in September from a guy in Lynwood, and the truck was built as a rock crawler. Unfortunately the paperwork that he gave me doesn't have very much info about the suspension and driveline build, so I have been slowly learning the things that the PO didn't tell me or wouldn't respond to after I bought the truck. It HAD a Detroit locker, but that blew out within the first month I owned the truck, thus the change to the Truetrac.

The PO did mention that the truck "ate U-joints". It's got a 5.5in WH lift and 3in body lift. It also had 37s, which I've recently switched down to 35s. My guess is that part of the reason for the big front end is for the high pinion.

I haven't done a full fluid flush since purchasing the vehicle, and I don't know what was being used prior, though the PO seemed VERY thorough in everything he did, so I would hope it was all done well. Also read as "I would ass-u-me".
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
...I have been slowly learning the things that the PO didn't tell me or wouldn't respond to after I bought the truck.

Seems a common story these days.
But just the fact that they let you know about the penchant for eating u-joints at least indicates there was some honesty going on there. A good sign for sure.

It HAD a Detroit locker, but that blew out within the first month I owned the truck, thus the change to the Truetrac.

Hmm, I wonder what it took to do that? Were you in 4wd or 2wd? Playing around with the new toy, or just driving along?

The PO did mention that the truck "ate U-joints". It's got a 5.5in WH lift and 3in body lift. It also had 37s, which I've recently switched down to 35s.

Good call on the 35's in my opinion. Especially if you don't need the extra inch of clearance for heavy off-roading.
And that much lift and tire is very capable of eating u-joints. But it depends a LOT on how the angles of the drivelines are set up.

My guess is that part of the reason for the big front end is for the high pinion.

Then it's not a GM setup. It's Ford, because Ford was the only manufacturer that used high-pinion Dana axles until Jeep finally did too many years later. But none of those would have been D60's either.
Maybe the guy didn't build it either and just didn't know what he had. Happens all the times, whether it's a quick-flipper or even someone that's had the Bronco for two or three years.
But with the lack of info from the old PO, maybe a few pictures here would let us know if you got everything you bargained for.
Doesn't hurt to know...

I haven't done a full fluid flush since purchasing the vehicle, and I don't know what was being used prior, though the PO seemed VERY thorough in everything he did, so I would hope it was all done well. Also read as "I would ass-u-me".

Haha! Yeah, normally I would disagree and say that almost nobody changes the gear lubes in these old rigs. But in your case the fact that so much has been done and so many new parts have been added, it'd be strange if the lubricants had not been changed in every instance.
Still, like other stuff it does not hurt to know. And most of these things are literally cheap insurance.
If the diff cover on the front is clean and dry, chances are it's a new cover gasket. And therefore newer gear lube too. But it never hurts to open the fill plug, stick a pinky in there and see what the lube looks like. If it's clean and green, you're in good shape. Same for the rear.
And if either one of them is not up to the fill line, then you should add some to find out how low it was.
As said, cheap insurance...
You just never know if you bought something from a good honest person, or a shyster/flipper/evil-doer. Lots more of the latter in the Bronco world than you might think. I don't suppose you have bedliner over the whole tub?;)%) (inside joke around here)

I think a few pictures would be in order. For one thing, if nothing else we love seeing pics of our fellow members Broncos! But we can often see things that the new owner might have missed in all the excitement. Especially if you have not been intimate with Broncos before this one.
You can't upload images directly unless you become a contributor for 12 bucks a year, but you can upload them initially to your "garage" and your "gallery" features in your User CP up top here.

A few pics of your driveshaft angles and axle and steering setups (but you didn't say the steering was scary, so that's a plus!) might indicate why it eats u-joints.

Good luck. Maybe we'll find something that can help.

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
oops! I see you're a contributor already. Thanks for that!
Now there's no excuse to not throw up some pictures. Maybe even of some of your first adventures (you definitely need to document those!) or maybe your tow back home!

Paul
 

bax

Contributor
Old Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
14,552
Best thing to say is. When you get it back take it apart. Some people that install the 435 cut the floor out to be able to put the top cover on the trans from inside the truck. If you have this option, you can do an inspection of the trans. Keep in mind if you find a problem you will have to pull it to fix it. The 435 is a tough trans. Big bearings that as a rule don't fail. The main shaft is two pieces and the most common problem is usually the person who rebuilt it before you got it. bad bearing install and low oil level is about the only way to burn one up.
A bad pinion angle will also vibrate the drive line. As a rule you dont get burnt oil smell from a drive angle problem. There are also roller bearings between the trans output shaft and the transfer case. This can be a problem area. the rear cv joint in the driveshaft can go bad and set up a vibration. the dana 20 output shaft bearing set up is also an area in need of inspection. But again not much oil smell. The rear end being new is more of a red flag than if it was old. A bad gear set up or bearing pre load could be a problem. you will get oil smell with this. Tear it all down and go thru it. You will find the problem. Good luck
 

bax

Contributor
Old Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
14,552
Seems a common story these days.
But just the fact that they let you know about the penchant for eating u-joints at least indicates there was some honesty going on there. A good sign for sure.



Hmm, I wonder what it took to do that? Were you in 4wd or 2wd? Playing around with the new toy, or just driving along?



Good call on the 35's in my opinion. Especially if you don't need the extra inch of clearance for heavy off-roading.
And that much lift and tire is very capable of eating u-joints. But it depends a LOT on how the angles of the drivelines are set up.



Then it's not a GM setup. It's Ford, because Ford was the only manufacturer that used high-pinion Dana axles until Jeep finally did too many years later. But none of those would have been D60's either.
Maybe the guy didn't build it either and just didn't know what he had. Happens all the times, whether it's a quick-flipper or even someone that's had the Bronco for two or three years.
But with the lack of info from the old PO, maybe a few pictures here would let us know if you got everything you bargained for.
Doesn't hurt to know...



Haha! Yeah, normally I would disagree and say that almost nobody changes the gear lubes in these old rigs. But in your case the fact that so much has been done and so many new parts have been added, it'd be strange if the lubricants had not been changed in every instance.
Still, like other stuff it does not hurt to know. And most of these things are literally cheap insurance.
If the diff cover on the front is clean and dry, chances are it's a new cover gasket. And therefore newer gear lube too. But it never hurts to open the fill plug, stick a pinky in there and see what the lube looks like. If it's clean and green, you're in good shape. Same for the rear.
And if either one of them is not up to the fill line, then you should add some to find out how low it was.
As said, cheap insurance...
You just never know if you bought something from a good honest person, or a shyster/flipper/evil-doer. Lots more of the latter in the Bronco world than you might think. I don't suppose you have bedliner over the whole tub?;)%) (inside joke around here)

I think a few pictures would be in order. For one thing, if nothing else we love seeing pics of our fellow members Broncos! But we can often see things that the new owner might have missed in all the excitement. Especially if you have not been intimate with Broncos before this one.
You can't upload images directly unless you become a contributor for 12 bucks a year, but you can upload them initially to your "garage" and your "gallery" features in your User CP up top here.

A few pics of your driveshaft angles and axle and steering setups (but you didn't say the steering was scary, so that's a plus!) might indicate why it eats u-joints.

Good luck. Maybe we'll find something that can help.

Paul

Dam Paul, do you type that fast or do you have software that you just talk to the screen.
 
OP
OP
A

Amitchla

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
59
@bax - great, thank you! The set up on this one is similar to you’ve mentioned, so I can unbolt the floor panel and access the top of the tranny. I’ll definitely go through it when I get the rig back.

@dirtdonk - regarding the locker, it happened while driving on the road in 2wd. I was returning from my old mechanic’s shop. Upon turning right hand corners, it began to pop and buck really badly. After taking it to the new mechanic, he mentioned it was blown.

I’ll still be off-roading, of course, but not competitively, and the inch less of clearance isn’t an issue for me.

To note as well - I had this mechanic lower it 2in as well, prior to the new wheels and tires, to make it more road driveable and more accessible for the wife. I know the mechanic was aware of driveline angles and etc, but could lowering the rig 3in effectively cause some sort of failure?

I’ll attach a couple older photos later tonight. I’ll have to take some new ones this week to focus on some specifics here. Thanks again for the input!!
 
OP
OP
A

Amitchla

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
59
Here are a few photos of the progression of the rig so far, and the pics I currently have of the driveline. I’ll grab some more later this week.
 

Attachments

  • 0F92802F-FE62-44E5-90AB-23B781A29F68.jpg
    0F92802F-FE62-44E5-90AB-23B781A29F68.jpg
    128.2 KB · Views: 105
  • 6581C763-59F7-495E-9F48-8F40ABC411D2.jpg
    6581C763-59F7-495E-9F48-8F40ABC411D2.jpg
    135.1 KB · Views: 150
  • BA2EB29E-866A-41FD-A498-B58C4E1BE353.jpg
    BA2EB29E-866A-41FD-A498-B58C4E1BE353.jpg
    108.8 KB · Views: 133
  • 31B9C784-6D3F-4A22-BE9D-86EC73AB20A6.jpg
    31B9C784-6D3F-4A22-BE9D-86EC73AB20A6.jpg
    147 KB · Views: 143
  • D5944428-44AB-418B-BBE4-A220AB693449.jpg
    D5944428-44AB-418B-BBE4-A220AB693449.jpg
    136 KB · Views: 135
  • 9D477CE6-8EB3-4DFD-A81F-FC1D73E61411.jpg
    9D477CE6-8EB3-4DFD-A81F-FC1D73E61411.jpg
    115.5 KB · Views: 122
  • BE42C1F3-390E-4051-8BCC-D2FD0F5EBB11.jpg
    BE42C1F3-390E-4051-8BCC-D2FD0F5EBB11.jpg
    99.5 KB · Views: 160

bax

Contributor
Old Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
14,552
well pinion angle looks good. heck the truck looks like it is put together well. Perhaps a little bump steer but that's an easy one to fix. HP front too, very nice.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Dam Paul, do you type that fast or do you have software that you just talk to the screen.

Hah! Yep, all in the fingers. Had two semesters of typing in Junior High and just never forgot.

@bax - great, thank you! The set up on this one is similar to you’ve mentioned, so I can unbolt the floor panel and access the top of the tranny. I’ll definitely go through it when I get the rig back.

And just to eliminate this other potential for noise, make sure that none of the shifters are touching the body. It doesn't usually "hurt" anything, but just from wondering about the strange noises it produces can make you wonder what is about to explode!

To note as well - I had this mechanic lower it 2in as well, prior to the new wheels and tires, to make it more road driveable and more accessible for the wife. I know the mechanic was aware of driveline angles and etc, but could lowering the rig 3in effectively cause some sort of failure?

Not in and of itself, but it can lead to other things like changes in the driveline angles and such.
But something I see right off is that the rear shocks, as shown in the pics, are set up for extra suspension droop/extension but not leaving much to compression. If they were not changed for shorter ones, or were not relocated, they will be bottoming out.

Another thing is that the front end is a Dana 44 high pinion, but the steering linkage is GM 1-ton stuff. Which is likely where the previous owner got his info. Or perhaps was not good in communicating "front end" stuff when he sold it to you.

And one more thing (well two actually) is regarding your engine setup. Which is very nice by the way!
One is that your electric fuel pump is up high and in the engine compartment. I'm glad it seems to work well now, but be aware that if you start having running issues that is the wrong place for an electric pump of that type.
They want to be low and as close to the tank(s) as possible because they don't like "pulling" they prefer "pushing" gas.

The other is that your open element air filter being right on the MAF sensor and on the top of the wheel well makes it susceptible to the laws of aerodynamics. Namely the eddies and turbulence of the engine cooling fan blowing into the filter and upsetting the ability of the MAF sensor to take a balanced and consistent reading.
When things are new these are not as big a deal. But as parts and pieces age or get put through more work, these issues can rear up and bite you.
So just be aware of those things.

Paul
 
OP
OP
A

Amitchla

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
59
well pinion angle looks good. heck the truck looks like it is put together well. Perhaps a little bump steer but that's an easy one to fix. HP front too, very nice.

Thanks! The goal with this truck was to buy something that had a lot of very good work done to it, and I *think* I accomplished that goal, minus the few things that have gone wrong. That's what makes these rigs fun though, right?

The steering is pretty tight, honestly. The PO installed the 4x4x2 box "over the knuckle." I've considered installing a sway bar for better street steering/cornering, but this would involve cutting the shock hoop (as I understand), and this mod isn't at the top of my list currently.

Not in and of itself, but it can lead to other things like changes in the driveline angles and such.
But something I see right off is that the rear shocks, as shown in the pics, are set up for extra suspension droop/extension but not leaving much to compression. If they were not changed for shorter ones, or were not relocated, they will be bottoming out.

Yep! This pic was taken post-lowering, and pre-new-shocks. I bought the appropriate length Bilsteins (from WH, actually, per Justin) and the rear rides a lot better. The front is still set up with a shock hoop and dual Duff shocks that I'll likely also replace with Bilsteins, eventually.

Another thing is that the front end is a Dana 44 high pinion, but the steering linkage is GM 1-ton stuff. Which is likely where the previous owner got his info. Or perhaps was not good in communicating "front end" stuff when he sold it to you.

Ah, ok! Cool. Well, that's good to know, then. The write ups look like modifying these are pretty labor intensive.

One is that your electric fuel pump is up high and in the engine compartment. I'm glad it seems to work well now, but be aware that if you start having running issues that is the wrong place for an electric pump of that type.
They want to be low and as close to the tank(s) as possible because they don't like "pulling" they prefer "pushing" gas.

Ok - got it! I'll have to check the vicinity of the fuel tank and see if there's an area where that could be shifted to.

The other is that your open element air filter being right on the MAF sensor and on the top of the wheel well makes it susceptible to the laws of aerodynamics. Namely the eddies and turbulence of the engine cooling fan blowing into the filter and upsetting the ability of the MAF sensor to take a balanced and consistent reading.

Huh - interesting! So, essentially, this could be affecting my fuel/air mixture? Maybe this is (one of) the reason(s) it smells like it's running rich.

For the driveline issue - what indicates a bad u-joint?

Another note - The PO mentioned he liked to drive "very fast and aggressively" and mentioned Glamus, and also others have mentioned the truck might have been set up for jumps. I'm not *positive* but the 9in casing in the rear might be slightly bowed as well. I mentioned this to my mechanic, but he didn't seem concerned.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Thanks! The goal with this truck was to buy something that had a lot of very good work done to it, and I *think* I accomplished that goal, minus the few things that have gone wrong. That's what makes these rigs fun though, right?
Another note - The PO mentioned he liked to drive "very fast and aggressively" and mentioned Glamus, and also others have mentioned the truck might have been set up for jumps.
I'm not *positive* but the 9in casing in the rear might be slightly bowed as well. I mentioned this to my mechanic, but he didn't seem concerned.

You definitely got one that's set up!
Of course, that can also mean you will have to deal with things that are beat upon and almost broken to the point that they break or fail under your watch.
Which means you get to fix them!
And Glamis, as in Glamis Dunes / Imperial Dunes is an epic sand-fest of places to jump and break things! If it can survive Glamis, it can probably survive anything.;D:cool:

The PO installed the 4x4x2 box "over the knuckle." I've considered installing a sway bar for better street steering/cornering, but this would involve cutting the shock hoop (as I understand), and this mod isn't at the top of my list currently.

Yeah, some people run into trouble when installing a sway bar, others do not. But I don't think it's an insurmountable problem either. Maybe not high on the list yet though.

The steering linkage itself (the tie-rod specifically) is what was mounted tie-rod over knuckle (TRO) while the box is not considered part of that equation.
It's a part of it of course, but in TRO vs TRU (tie-rod under) it's all about the location of the tie-rod.

Yep! This pic was taken post-lowering, and pre-new-shocks. I bought the appropriate length Bilsteins (from WH, actually, per Justin) and the rear rides a lot better. The front is still set up with a shock hoop and dual Duff shocks that I'll likely also replace with Bilsteins, eventually.

Regarding cornering, your rear setup is commonly referred to as inboard shock hoop and that angle seems to promote lean in corners. If your original mounts are still in place you might be able to use those instead and find that you've gained some better handling characteristics as well.
The inboard hoops are generally for more wheel travel and less for street handling.

Ok - got it! I'll have to check the vicinity of the fuel tank and see if there's an area where that could be shifted to.

It can get quite busy under a Bronco. Especially if there is dual exhaust. But hopefully there is a spot there somewhere. In the meantime though it sounds like it's running, so at least it hasn't caused trouble yet.
The good news is that is that even though it's under the hood, it's considered a cool part of the engine compartment and the fan will keep air flowing over it.

Huh - interesting! So, essentially, this could be affecting my fuel/air mixture? Maybe this is (one of) the reason(s) it smells like it's running rich.

Possible. Also can lead to erratic idle, but certainly erratic metering.
Some other tuning could be necessary too, since we don't know what parts were used in the engine. If the installer mixed and matched ("matched" being a relative term) parts from various engines and manufacturers, but did not tune the computer to suit, you may just be seeing the results of that too.

Easy to test though. You can make some sort of a wind baffle shield to block turbulence at least partially from the filter area. You can even slap something together temporarily to see if anything changes.
Do that, then drive it a bit to see if it tunes itself out of the rich running.
Also find out where the oxygen sensors are in the exhaust. If they are too far away from the engine they may be not working properly.

For the driveline issue - what indicates a bad u-joint?

Lots of things and it can often be different every time.
Vibration either all the time, or under just certain conditions.
Noises from clunking, to clicking, to whining, to whistling.
Loose feel. If you can grab the driveshaft and the u-joint yoke and twist them in opposing directions and see movement in the joint, it's worn out.
They are dead tight when new and in good shape, so should have zero visible play in them.

Paul
 
OP
OP
A

Amitchla

Jr. Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2019
Messages
59
OK - as an update - my mechanic mentioned that the "bearings in the transmission have begun to wear out. You can still drive the truck around locally, but I wouldn't go too far."

This goes back to my original thought, though - if it is indeed the bearings in the transmission, why would there only be racket in RWD, and not FWD?

Could it be a bearing the the t-case, instead?

I'll be checking the u-joints tomorrow after I get the truck back.
 

bax

Contributor
Old Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
14,552
because it's not the bearings in the trans, unless it had 300K miles on it or ran without oil. as a rule the 435 does not have bearing problems.
 

tbratz

Jr. Member
Joined
May 29, 2006
Messages
140
Maybe this was already covered, but I went through a similar issue with mine and after trying everything, it ended up being my rear pinion angle was off. Looking at it it didn't even seem that bad, but when I excellerated or let of the gas and coasted it would do the same as yours. I placed a shim in the rear and it solved everything.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
OK - as an update - my mechanic mentioned that the "bearings in the transmission have begun to wear out...
This goes back to my original thought, though - if it is indeed the bearings in the transmission, why would there only be racket in RWD, and not FWD?

Well, even though it seems counter-intuitive, there is a slight change in the dynamics when you are running in front wheel drive. Maybe the load is just enough different that the noise changes. You did say that it did not go away completely, correct?

Could it be a bearing the the t-case, instead?

Yes, certainly.

I'll be checking the u-joints tomorrow after I get the truck back.

Good. You have to at least eliminate this as a possibility.
Don't discount what the mechanic is saying, even though it goes against our first thoughts. We have to assume that because they're there with the truck they might be able to determine something up close that we can't from afar.

Paul
 
Top