• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

F'ing intermittent starter issue

chuzie

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 21, 2006
Messages
2,761
'77 Bronco.
EZ harness
RJM EFI
Reduction starter
351W with 4R70W

I have this intermittent starting issue that is making me nuts and I can't track it. I go to turn key to START and get the starter relay single click. Sometimes it takes 100 actuations and sometimes just 2 to actually get it to crank. Sat in dunkin donuts parking lot like a douche for 30 minutes yesterday trying to get the darn starter to turn.

Replaced starter (Explorer starter)
Replaced starter power cable.
Checked ignition signal for 12v on START. Got 12v 100 times.
Has not been under water.

This thing should ground through case, right?

What am I missing here?
 
OP
OP
chuzie

chuzie

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 21, 2006
Messages
2,761
Reduction gear has relay case mounted. I did change starter so i suppose it is possible a new relay is defective though this issue was occurring with old starter and relay.
 

NicksTrix

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 1, 2001
Messages
6,410
what have you got for grounds? block & body have clean grounds?
if your grounds are solid it sounds like a solenoid. how are the grounds on it?
 

Terkish

Sr. Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2008
Messages
414
How are the connections and cables to your battery?
I have had a starting problem in the past where corrosion went down the battery cable inside the insulation. Didn't show on the outside and caused resistance in the cable and I would just get a click when trying to start.
Its worth checking anyway. Good luck.
 

Crush

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
May 30, 2007
Messages
3,463
Loc.
Greenbottom, WV
ok so we are all on the same page the solenoid is on your starter and the relay is mounted somewhere on the right side of the engine compartment (wheel tub, fender skirt or firewall). even late model fords have the relay. I got my setup off an explorer and my buddy got his off an f-250. The wiring is a little different than normal but it is done that way and if the relay is bad it will cause the problem you are speaking of. Now if you rewired it differently (say like GM products, which can be done with the high torque mini starter) then starter or solenoid could very well be the problem. Relays are inexpensive so I would try that first and see what happens. Also grounds are a good culprit to this problem. If the starter is wired correctly(and I assume it is) then a ground from the battery to the block and a groumd from the block to the firewall are both needed. some people put a ground from the block to the frame but I have found that the motor mounts and body bolts serve as that. Hope this helps

crush
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Since you have a click each time you turn the key, it sounds like the ignition switch, and the fender mounted relay are working.
Which side of the relay is the large starter cable mounted to? Same as the battery, for constant hot to the new starter? Or still on the opposite side, so that it only gets power to the starter-mounted solenoid when you turn the key?

Carry a long prybar/screwdriver and a hammer with you, and the next time this happens tap the new starter to see if it's just sticking. Sticking is usually the sign of an old tired and worn out starter. But with the questionable quality of some modern products these days, it doesn't hurt to at least hit the starter a few times to rule it out.

And even if it turns out the starter is fine, at least you got some joy out of hitting something and looking useful while in parking lots playing with your clicker. %)

Paul
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
ok so we are all on the same page the solenoid is on your starter and the relay is mounted somewhere on the right side of the engine compartment (wheel tub, fender skirt or firewall). even late model fords have the relay. I got my setup off an explorer and my buddy got his off an f-250. The wiring is a little different than normal but it is done that way and if the relay is bad it will cause the problem you are speaking of. Now if you rewired it differently (say like GM products, which can be done with the high torque mini starter) then starter or solenoid could very well be the problem. Relays are inexpensive so I would try that first and see what happens. Also grounds are a good culprit to this problem. If the starter is wired correctly(and I assume it is) then a ground from the battery to the block and a groumd from the block to the firewall are both needed. some people put a ground from the block to the frame but I have found that the motor mounts and body bolts serve as that. Hope this helps

crush

The newer stuff with the mini starter only use the fender mounted relay to energize the coil of the starter solenoid. That's pretty small current compared to what the starter actually draws and allows use of less robust ignition switches and wiring. The cable to the solenoid is run directly to the battery.
 
OP
OP
chuzie

chuzie

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 21, 2006
Messages
2,761
Signal wire goes straight to relay mounted on starter as does the power supply from battery. No fender mounted solenoid (relay). Is this too much for the ignition signal wire/switch ? Should it go through a relay instead?

As soon as I get back i will take a gander at grounds.
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
Signal wire goes straight to relay mounted on starter as does the power supply from battery. No fender mounted solenoid (relay). Is this too much for the ignition signal wire/switch ? Should it go through a relay instead?

It's probably borderline too much for the switch and wiring. You will know when it is too much when the wiring between the switch and solenoid melts. I would add a relay just to be safe.

Since the solenoid is clicking it is getting a start signal. I would look closely at the cables. I recently used a jumper cable between the battery and solenoid to get a '96 bronco running that had a corroded starter cable.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,114
Are you sure you are hearing the starter solenoid clunking, or the voltage regulator? Some of the old mechanical voltage regulators can have a clunk that sounds like a solenoid.

You have tried rocking the shifter while holding the key in start?

I had more but you already commented you no longer have the fender solenoid so I will skip those steps.

A volt meter (in this case a test light will even work), have someone hold the key in start. Work quickly so it doesn't have to be there too long. Put the ground wire on the ground of the battery. Start with the positive battery post, then then positive battery terminal, then the lug of the cable on the starter, then the post of the starter, then that little jumper wire off the solenoid to the motor, then the starter case. Follow EVERY single step of the power and see where voltage drops off at.
On the flip side, Put the ground clamp on the positive terminal and chase every point on the ground side. You have to do it loaded (key in start) to make any weak grounds really show as bad.
At some point you will have voltage stop at a place it shouldn't, that point is your problem. It really is amazing that 2 pieces of metal touching each other are not conductive.

Another hint, turn the headlights on and try to start. Do they stay full brightness or do they go dark? That can help chase down bad connections as well. Going dark is a bad connection (providing when it is in a good mood the battery will start the truck). Staying bright tends to point to a localized issue near the starter more then the battery terminals.
 
OP
OP
chuzie

chuzie

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 21, 2006
Messages
2,761
I have a 3g. Not sure my vr is that loud. 95% sure it is solenoid i hear. I have tried rocking shifter to no avail. It just helps me actuate faster.

Lots of post Christmas fun for me.
 

Bronco73

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
May 29, 2003
Messages
3,016
Loc.
Cape Coral, FL
I recently had a starting issue the same as you have described and it turned out to be a grounding problem. This was on my daily driver 98 mountaineer. I had a bad ground between the block plate and starter.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
If the battery terminals are good, it has to be either a bad solenoid (the contacts in the back of it), or a bad starter (damaged brushes not making contact with the commutator). Where are these starters coming from, and what brand(s) are they? Can you post pics of the battery terminals? Look at these:

.
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
If the battery terminals are good, it has to be either a bad solenoid (the contacts in the back of it), or a bad starter (damaged brushes not making contact with the commutator).

Wrong. Starter can't work if it doesn't get enough current through bad cables.
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
So you think his cables are that bad, but after messing with the key for 30 min, they become good enough to crank? I've only seen that at the terminals, where the battery acid attacks them. If the cable is burned out, it'll never crank.
 

Viperwolf1

Contributor
electron whisperer
Joined
Aug 23, 2007
Messages
24,451
So you think his cables are that bad, but after messing with the key for 30 min, they become good enough to crank? I've only seen that at the terminals, where the battery acid attacks them. If the cable is burned out, it'll never crank.

Acid wicks down the cables and corrodes them under the insulation. Very common problem and not easy to see. Cable becomes stiff and insulation may swell. I never said cable was burnt out.
 
Top