I'll just throw the reminder out there...
Build the 9" first and go for a drive. If you don't like it, not that big of a deal to regear again. Sell some lightly used gears for a small loss and an evening setting up the 9" again. Once you do the front you have a LOT of money tied up in gears.
This is the plan. I actually have a 9" center with 4.56 gears I was going to try. After running the numbers and getting advice I realized the 4.88/5.13 are my real options and I'll probably sell of the 4.56 gears.
The difference between 4.88's and 5.13's is only 5%, so it's not a huge change and if that makes or breaks the drivability of a rig, you're cutting things a bit close in too many ways IMO. While I may prefer that I went with 5.13's once mine is back on the road, the 4.88's should be totally usable and at that point you're just splitting hairs. I liked the shift points with my setup better with the 4.88's and I figured if I ever ditched the manual for an auto, the 4.88's were a better choice given the additional advantage of a torque converter.
That is why I ran the whole spread sheet above at different MPH. I wanted to see what each ratio looked like and where possible dead spots were. Mountain passes make this so important.
I would talk to the gear manufactures on the gears themselves as to heat treatment and durability. getting the right set may make all the difference in the world especially as you push the structural limits of the gears themselves. I now this was a big issue with drag racing at one time. who's gears are King of the hammer guys using?
Good point, even though the D44 gears are front and not as crucial as the rear gears, I'm closer to the D44 strength limits than the 9". So a high quality gear set is important.
What are the "best" gear manufacturer's? Yukon seems high priced and well regarded. Are there better? I feel like OEM is usually the best quality, but I'm not seeing Spicer gears for the HPD44 unfortunately.
Maybe a cryo treated gear set? IDK.