Yes, a pic of the whole shaft would be a good thing to see next. That's a pretty steep angle for a 3.5" lift. Or at least it appears that way from this angle of view.
Some shafts are designed to have the splines show, and their seal even has spline notches in it. As the others said, yours does not look like that type and looks to be too far extended. Judging by the witness marks where the seal/wiper used to ride on the smooth shank of the shaft, I'd say it's pulled way out and your seal is also buggered. New smooth seal should be available separately once you get things dialed in.
Your rear fenders are uncut? Is your suspension extended right now, or is it at ride-height in the pic?
Paul